Key takeaways
- Each carrier's analytics engine scores your number on its own, so a firm can be clean on one network and labeled on another.
- The FCC's examples of reasonable analytics include bursts of calls, short calls, low completion and complaints[2]: exactly the pattern of a firm calling back a batch of web leads from one number.
- Caller ID authentication proves a number was not spoofed, not that the call is wanted; calls signed with partial or gateway attestation start at a disadvantage[2][3].
- The label hits callbacks hardest, and most people already skip unknown numbers[4]. The durable fix is needing fewer callbacks.
The label arrives before your name
When a law firm calls a client back, the client's phone has decided what to show before anyone says hello. If the carrier's analytics think the number looks risky, the screen says Spam Likely, Potential Spam or Scam Risk instead of the firm's number, or the call never rings at all. The client sees a warning, lets it go to voicemail and, quite often, never listens to the message.
Carriers filter this hard because their customers are drowning. In 2025, 68% of US adults said they get scam calls at least weekly that try to obtain personal information, and 31% said at least daily[5]. One industry estimate cited by the FCC puts the average consumer at 13 spam or fraud calls a month[1]. Robocall volume has barely moved in years: one industry index puts it above 45 billion calls in every year since 2019[6].
Source: YouMail, 2026[6]
Show the data
| Year | Robocalls (billions) |
|---|---|
| 2019 | 58.5 billion |
| 2020 | 45.9 billion |
| 2021 | 50.5 billion |
| 2022 | 50.4 billion |
| 2023 | 55 billion |
| 2024 | 52.8 billion |
| 2025 | 52.5 billion |
Against that background, an analytics engine is built to err toward warning people. Lawful callers get caught, and law firms are well placed to be among them, because some of their most important calls look, to a machine, a lot like telemarketing.
How a call gets judged
Three separate things happen to an outbound call, and they are easy to confuse.
First, authentication. Voice providers had to fully implement the STIR/SHAKEN caller ID authentication framework in their IP networks by June 30, 2021[7]. The originating provider signs each call with an attestation level. A means it knows the customer and can verify the customer's right to use the number shown; B means it knows the customer but cannot verify the number; C means the signer has no relationship with whoever started the call[3]. Authentication tells the receiving network the number was not spoofed. It says nothing about whether the call is wanted.
Second, analytics. The receiving carrier, usually through an analytics partner, scores the number's behavior. When the FCC described reasonable analytics in 2019 it listed large bursts of calls in a short time, low average call duration, low call completion ratios, common caller name values across providers, many complaints about a line, sequential dialing, neighbor spoofing, comparison with the Do Not Call Registry and data from regulators, consumers and other carriers[2]. No carrier publishes its formula, and each engine reaches its own verdict.
Third, reports. When people tap report spam or block a number, that feeds the engines too. Reports from people who simply did not recognize your number count against it, however mistaken they are[2].
Bursts
Many calls from one number in a short window
Short calls
Low average duration, lots of quick hang-ups
Low completion
Most calls unanswered or sent to voicemail
Complaints
Recipients reporting or blocking the number
Dialing pattern
Sequential or list-like dialing, numbers on the Do Not Call Registry
Signing
Attestation level and the originating provider's record
Drawn from the factors the FCC gave as examples of reasonable call-blocking analytics[2]. Each carrier weighs them differently.
Why law firms trip the filters
None of the usual causes involves doing anything wrong. They come from how firms actually work the phones.
- Lead callback batches. An injury or mass tort firm works through the overnight web leads first thing in the morning, all from the main line. Many do not answer, the answered calls are short, and some recipients do not remember filling in a form. To an engine that is a burst of short, low-completion calls to strangers.
- Calling people who never saved the number. Prospects, witnesses, opposing parties and medical providers have no reason to recognize the firm, so declines and spam reports are more likely than on calls to existing clients.
- Attorney apps and softphones. An app that displays the office number while the call leaves through a different provider may be signed B or C rather than A, because the signing provider cannot verify the right to that number[3].
- A number with a past. Numbers are recycled. A new main line can inherit a reputation from a previous owner's calling habits.
- Your number in a scammer's hands. Spoofing someone else's caller ID to defraud or cause harm is unlawful[8], but it happens, and the complaints land on your number.
- Collection work. Firms that collect debts call a lot of people who do not want to talk. The FCC noted in 2019 that more than half of one analytics company's top 20 spam callers were debt collection callers[2].
Caller name is not the safety net many firms assume. In its 2025 order the FCC declined to require providers to display caller name information, noting that caller name databases are not reliable enough, and urged the industry to keep building newer branded calling tools instead[1]. Registering the firm's name is still worth doing, as covered in setting your caller ID name, but a correct name does not guarantee it will show or outweigh a spam score.
Diagnosing which problem you have
Before fixing anything, find out what is actually happening, and on which networks. Clients' reports are a start but rarely precise: someone said your call came up as spam is not enough to act on.
| What you notice | Likely cause | How to check |
|---|---|---|
| Clients on one carrier see a warning, others do not | That carrier's analytics scored the number | Call test phones on each major carrier from each outbound number |
| Warnings began after a lead campaign or a new hire | Burst, short-call or low-completion pattern | Pull outbound call logs for the weeks before the label appeared |
| Office desk phones show fine, attorney app calls get flagged | Partial or gateway attestation on app calls | Ask each provider what attestation your calls receive |
| Strangers call to say your firm phoned them | Your number is being spoofed | Log each report with date and time; compare with your own outbound log |
| Calls fail or go straight to voicemail with no warning | Blocking rather than labeling | Ask your provider whether calls are being rejected and with what code |
| A newly assigned number is flagged from day one | Inherited reputation | Test before publishing it; ask the provider for a different number if it is flagged |
Keep a simple log while you test: the date, the outbound number, the carrier of the phone that took the call, what the screen showed and whether it rang at all. Two weeks of entries tells you more than any vendor dashboard, and it is the evidence you will want if you dispute a label with a carrier. Repeat the same test calls a month after any change, because a label can come back as soon as the calling pattern that caused it does.
If the reports involve calls you never made, treat it as impersonation first and follow when scammers impersonate your law firm by phone. For everything else, the clean-up steps (registering numbers, disputing labels, asking for blocked-call lists and changing the calling patterns that caused it) are in how to remove Spam Likely from your firm's number.
What the label does to callbacks
The label lands on top of a habit people already have. 80% of Americans say they generally do not answer calls from unknown numbers, and 67% say they let such calls go and check the voicemail instead[4]. A firm calling from an unfamiliar number was already relying on voicemail. With a spam warning on the screen, the voicemail is all that is left, and a message from a number the phone just called spam gets less trust.
- Caller
- Your team
- System
01Caller
Prospect calls at 8:10 pm
Nobody answers; the prospect leaves a short message about a car crash.
02Your team
Paralegal calls back at 9:05
From the main line, the twelfth callback of the morning.
03System
Carrier labels the call
The prospect's screen shows a spam warning instead of the firm's number.
04Caller
Call goes to voicemail
The prospect ignores it and does not trust the message left.
05Caller
Prospect calls another firm
The next search result answers live, and the first firm never learns why.
Example sequence. The firm sees a returned call and a voicemail left; the label never appears in its own records.
That last line is the trap. A firm's call log shows the callback as made, so the label looks like a client problem rather than a firm problem. Reducing phone tag with prospective clients and what callers do when a law firm doesn't answer cover the wider pattern, and better messages help at the margin: see voicemail greeting scripts that get callbacks.
Help clients recognize the number
Part of the fix sits on the client's side of the call. Phones let people send anything that is not in their contacts straight to voicemail, and carrier apps let them block every call the analytics score as risky. A number saved as a contact usually rings through under the name the client gave it, whatever the network thinks of the number. So ask clients to save it, early and more than once.
- On the first call: the number you will see when we call is this one; please save it under the firm's name now so our calls are not screened out.
- In the engagement letter and the welcome email: list every number the firm calls from, including the direct lines of the paralegal and the attorney on the matter.
- In every voicemail: the firm's name, the reason in a few words and the number to ring back, said slowly. A message left behind a warning has to do all the work.
- Before an important call, such as a settlement offer or a hearing change: a short email, or a text where the client has agreed to texts, saying you will call from the main line within the hour.
None of this reaches prospects who have never spoken to you, and they are the callers a firm can least afford to lose. That is why the first conversation matters more than any of the workarounds.
The durable fix: fewer callbacks
Every outbound callback is a fresh chance to be labeled. A firm that answers more calls live the first time makes fewer of them, and the first conversation happens on the client's own call, where no warning appears. That is the strongest argument for live coverage in the evening and during overflow, more than any registration form.
Coverage does not need a bigger front desk. An SI Employee answers the firm's forwarded line on the schedule you choose, follows your approved intake questions, books consultations into one connected and tested calendar or takes a request your team confirms, and sends the summary, recording and transcript to the right person (see what it does). The estate planning example shows the effect: the morning-after-seminar rush is answered live instead of turning into a dozen afternoon callbacks.
Outbound calling still matters for reminders, documents and court dates. Spread it sensibly, keep each number's purpose clear, and watch inbound screening as well, because filters on your own line can hide calls from you too; screening sales calls and robocalls at a law office covers that side.
Frequently asked questions
Does every phone show the same label for my number?
No. Each carrier uses its own analytics, often through a partner, and some people add their own call-blocking apps. A number can be labeled on one network, clean on another and blocked by an app on a third.
Doesn't STIR/SHAKEN stop my number being flagged?
No. Authentication shows the receiving network whether your provider could vouch for the number[3]. Analytics still judge how the number behaves[2], so a fully authenticated number can still be labeled.
Will registering the firm's caller name fix it?
It helps people recognize you when a name is shown, but the FCC has declined to require name display and notes that caller name databases are not reliable[1]. Treat it as one step, not the fix.
How do I know if someone is spoofing our number?
The usual sign is strangers calling to say your firm phoned them when your own logs show no such call. Spoofing to defraud or cause harm is unlawful[8]; record every report and follow your impersonation plan.
Do spam labels affect our text messages too?
Texts are filtered through a separate system that depends on business texting registration. See 10DLC registration for law firm text messaging.
References
Federal Communications Commission (2025). Advanced Methods to Target and Eliminate Unlawful Robocalls, Eighth Report and Order (FCC 25-15) (opens in a new tab) โ
Federal Communications Commission (2019). Advanced Methods to Target and Eliminate Unlawful Robocalls, Declaratory Ruling and Third Further Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (FCC 19-51) (opens in a new tab) โ
Secure Telephone Identity Governance Authority (STI-GA) (2023). Improper Attestation (opens in a new tab) โ
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) โ
Pew Research Center (2025). Online Scams and Attacks in America Today (opens in a new tab) โ
YouMail (2026). Robocall Index: historical robocalls by time (opens in a new tab) โ
Electronic Code of Federal Regulations (Office of the Federal Register) (2026). 47 CFR 64.6301 Caller ID authentication (opens in a new tab) โ
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 47 U.S. Code 227 - Restrictions on use of telephone equipment (opens in a new tab) โ