Metrics and Firm Finance

What It Costs When Paralegals Answer the Phones

Paralegals covering the front desk lose drafting time to calls and restarts. A staff-time model, the overtime rule and ways to take the phones off them.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing9 min read

On this page
  1. The phone rolls to the nearest capable desk
  2. The minutes you see and the minutes you don't
  3. A staff-time model for paralegal phone duty
  4. Overtime: where the cost reaches payroll
  5. What it does to the callers
  6. Taking the phones off the paralegal's desk
  7. Run a two-week test before you hire
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. References
Metrics and Firm Finance: What It Costs When Paralegals Answer the Phones3x: the rate of sequence errors after interruptions averaging 4.4 seconds, in a 2014 experimentMETRICS AND FIRM FINANCEWhat It Costs WhenParalegals Answer the Phones3xthe rate of sequence errors after interruptions averaging 4.4seconds, in a 2014 experimentAva for LawyersInsightsMetrics and Firm Finance: What It Costs When Paralegals Answer the Phones3x: the rate of sequence errors after interruptions averaging 4.4 seconds, in a 2014 experimentMETRICS AND FIRM FINANCEWhat It Costs WhenParalegals Answer thePhones3xthe rate of sequence errors afterinterruptions averaging 4.4 seconds,in a 2014 experimentAva for Lawyers
Figure source: Europe PMC (EMBL-EBI), 2014[1]

Key takeaways

  • A paralegal in legal services earns a mean $32.45 an hour against $20.65 for a receptionist[2][3], so every hour of phone duty moved to the paralegal costs more before any drafting is lost.
  • The bigger cost is the restart. Interruptions of a few seconds doubled or tripled sequence errors in a multi-step task[1], and a phone call lasts minutes.
  • Paralegals generally don't qualify for the learned professional exemption[4], so phone duty that pushes drafting past 40 hours can become overtime at time and a half[5].
  • Measure two weeks of calls, then move routine and overflow calls off the paralegal's desk before hiring anyone.

The phone rolls to the nearest capable desk

In a firm without a receptionist, or one whose receptionist is at lunch, on leave or already on a call, the main line rolls to whoever is nearest and most capable. Usually that is a paralegal. The paralegal knows the clients, knows the cases and can actually answer the question, which is exactly why the arrangement feels efficient and exactly why it is expensive.

Start with wages. Legal services employers paid paralegals and legal assistants a mean $32.45 an hour in May 2025, and receptionists and information clerks $20.65[2][3]. Each hour of phone duty that moves from the front desk to a paralegal costs $11.80 more in wages alone. Add the employer's costs, which average 30% of total compensation for private employers[6], and the paralegal hour is about $46.36. And that is before counting what the paralegal was hired to do and did not do while on the phone.

  • The paralegal's direct line is printed on letters to new clients, so every follow-up rings their desk.
  • The office voicemail greeting names the paralegal as the person who will call back.
  • Drafting happens before nine and after five, because that is when the phone is quiet.
  • Deadline work gets checked twice as a habit, because it is so often interrupted the first time.

Two or more of those and the paralegal is the firm's receptionist in all but name.

The minutes you see and the minutes you don't

Call time is the visible part: a new inquiry, a client asking whether the hearing is still on, a records clerk confirming a fax number. The hidden part is the restart. Paralegal work is sequence work: calendaring a chain of deadlines, building a medical chronology row by row, assembling exhibits in order, completing a court form field by field. A dropped step in that work is not a typo. It can be a missed date.

The research on interruptions is blunt about sequence work. In experiments published in 2014, interruptions averaging 4.4 seconds tripled the rate of sequence errors in a multi-step task, and interruptions averaging 2.8 seconds doubled it; errors that had nothing to do with the sequence were unaffected[1]. A phone call is not three seconds. It is several minutes of someone else's problem, followed by a return to a half-finished task.

Sequence errors after brief interruptionsRate of sequence errors in a multi-step task, relative to the uninterrupted rate, from the study's reported results.
Sequence errors after brief interruptionsColumn chart. No interruption: 1Γ—; About 2.8 seconds: 2Γ—; About 4.4 seconds: 3Γ—.0Γ—1Γ—2Γ—3Γ—No interruption: 1Γ—1Γ—No interruptionAbout 2.8 seconds: 2Γ—2Γ—About 2.8 secondsAbout 4.4 seconds: 3Γ—3Γ—About 4.4 secondsSequence errors after brief interruptionsColumn chart. No interruption: 1Γ—; About 2.8 seconds: 2Γ—; About 4.4 seconds: 3Γ—.0Γ—1Γ—2Γ—3Γ—No interruption: 1Γ—1Γ—Nointerrupti-onAbout 2.8 seconds: 2Γ—2Γ—About 2.8secondsAbout 4.4 seconds: 3Γ—3Γ—About 4.4seconds

Source: Europe PMC (EMBL-EBI), 2014[1]

Show the data
Interruption lengthError rate vs uninterrupted
No interruption1Γ—
About 2.8 seconds2Γ—
About 4.4 seconds3Γ—
Example: one call in the middle of a demand package
  • Caller
  • Your team
  • System
  1. 01Caller

    10:40, the main line rings

    A new caller asks whether the firm takes slip-and-fall cases.

  2. 02Your team

    Paralegal answers

    Seven minutes of names and facts; the medical chronology stays open mid-row.

  3. 03Your team

    The message gets written

    Three more minutes to log the call and email the attorney the details.

  4. 04Your team

    Back to the chronology

    Finds the row, rechecks the last few entries before trusting them.

  5. 05System

    The draft slips

    Two more calls before noon; the package goes out a day later than planned.

Example sequence. Times are illustrative; your own log will show your pattern.

Multiply that by a normal morning and the pattern is familiar to anyone who has run a small litigation practice: the paralegal is busy all day and the drafts are always late. Neither the paralegal nor the attorney is doing anything wrong. The phone has simply been given to the person whose time is hardest to replace.

A staff-time model for paralegal phone duty

The calculator counts the paralegal hours that go to the phone each month and prices them at the paralegal's full cost. Count the restart in the minutes per call; a call that takes four minutes and costs three more to find your place again is a seven-minute call for this purpose.

ExampleExample: monthly cost of a paralegal covering the phones
Example: worked figures
InputExample
Calls a day to the main line18
Minutes per call, including the restart7
Share the paralegal answers70%
Paralegal cost per hour, with benefits$46.36
Calls a month391
Staff hours on these calls46
Hours handed off32
Monthly value of that staff time$1,479

How it is worked out: Calls a day Γ— 21.7 working days Γ— minutes per call Γ· 60 Γ— share handled = hours; hours Γ— hourly cost.

Assumptions

  • Paralegals and legal assistants in legal services earned a mean $32.45 an hour in May 2025.[2]
  • Benefits made up 30.0% of private employers' compensation cost in June 2026, so $32.45 divided by 0.70 gives about $46.36 an hour.[6]
  • Call volume, minutes per call and the share the paralegal answers are Example inputs. Take yours from a two-week tally.

Example for a small firm whose paralegal answers whenever the front desk can't. Working days only.

In this example the paralegal spends about 32 hours a month on the phone, roughly four working days, at a cost near $1,480. If the firm bills paralegal time, run the calculator again with the billing rate in place of the cost: that is the revenue those hours could have produced, and for many firms it is the more persuasive number.

Now change one input. If lunch and overflow calls go somewhere else and the paralegal answers a quarter of the calls instead of 70%, the same model gives about 11 hours a month, near $530. The calls still get answered. The difference is roughly 20 hours a month of drafting, which for a one-paralegal firm can be the gap between demand packages going out on time and going out late.

Two things the model leaves out. The first is errors: a deadline calendared wrong after an interruption costs far more than the minutes. The second is the attorney's time when the paralegal's backlog lands on the attorney's desk, which is the most expensive hour in the building.

Overtime: where the cost reaches payroll

When the phones eat the morning, the drafting moves to the evening. That matters because federal overtime rules say paralegals and legal assistants generally do not qualify as exempt learned professionals; the regulation's reasoning is that most specialized paralegal programs are two-year associate degrees, with an exception for paralegals who hold advanced degrees in another professional field and use that knowledge in the work[4]. A nonexempt employee must get at least one and a half times the regular rate for hours over 40 in a workweek[5].

Example: a paralegal at $32.45 who stays four extra hours a week to finish what the phones interrupted earns overtime at $48.68 an hour, about $195 a week and roughly $9,735 over 50 working weeks. That is payroll the firm can see, on top of the phone time it can't. Exempt status depends on the facts of each job and on state law, so check yours; are paralegals exempt from overtime goes into the tests.

Watch for off-the-clock work. A salaried paralegal who answers the office line from home after six, or checks voicemail on Saturday, may be working hours the firm owes for. Write down who covers the phones after hours and how that time is recorded.

What it does to the callers

A paralegal in the middle of a filing makes a hurried receptionist. New callers get a shortened intake, existing clients get β€œlet me check and call you back,” and on a deadline morning the phone may simply be left to ring. The callback then has to reach someone who did not answer an unfamiliar number: eight in ten Americans said in 2020 that they don't generally answer calls from unknown numbers[7].

Firms already struggle here. In Clio's 2024 secret-shopper study only 40% of law firms answered the phone, down from 56% in 2019[8]. A paralegal covering the desk between tasks is one of the ordinary reasons a call goes unanswered: nobody decided to miss it, but the person responsible was doing something more urgent.

Intake itself can be done by a nonlawyer. ABA Formal Opinion 506 says lawyers may train and supervise nonlawyers to gather a prospective client's initial facts and run an initial conflict check, as long as the prospect is always offered the chance to talk with a lawyer[9]. The problem is not that a paralegal takes intake. It is that intake by interruption is rushed intake. Paralegal vs intake specialist looks at who should own it.

Taking the phones off the paralegal's desk

Options for covering the main line so the paralegal answers only what needs a paralegal.
OptionCoversParalegal still handlesWatch for
Hire a receptionistOffice hours, in personLunch, leave and overflow coverThe full cost of the seat, not just the wage
Phone duty by rotaOffice hours, shared across staffHalf-days of interruptionsDeadline days still get hit
Answering service on overflowCalls not picked up within a set number of ringsExisting-client questions on callbacksMessage quality and what agents are allowed to say
SI Employee on forwarded callsOverflow, lunch, after hours or all dayCallbacks in set blocks, with the summary in handApprove the intake questions and escalation tree first

A receptionist is the traditional answer, and the true cost of hiring a law firm receptionist shows why it is a bigger decision than the wage suggests. Rotating phone duty spreads the interruptions instead of removing them; cross-training staff to cover intake is the right way to do it if you choose it.

An SI Employee takes a different route. The firm forwards its number on overflow, at lunch, after hours or all day. The SI Employee asks the firm's approved intake questions, including the names needed for the conflict check, routes urgent calls through the escalation tree, and sends each call to the AssistCall account with a summary, recording and transcript. Existing clients get their question written down and a callback in the paralegal's next block, so the callback takes two minutes instead of ten. A direct connection to case management software is planned rather than live, so for now someone copies what matters into the case file; summaries can also go to other systems by webhook (see integrations).

The solo personal injury example models exactly this firm: one attorney, one paralegal who until now took every new inquiry along with records, demand packages and client calls, and no receptionist. In that example the paralegal blocks the first 45 minutes of each day for the overnight calls, before the phones get busy.

Run a two-week test before you hire

  • Tally every call the paralegal answers for ten working days: time, caller type, minutes and whether it needed a paralegal at all.
  • Note the restart cost honestly. If a four-minute call cost ten minutes of drafting, write ten.
  • Mark which calls arrived during deadline work, and whether any deadline task was redone or checked twice afterwards.
  • Count the hours past 40 the paralegal worked in those two weeks, and ask what caused them.
  • Set two callback blocks a day for existing clients, as in handling existing client calls without interrupting attorneys, and see how many calls they absorb.
  • Put the totals into the calculator above, once at cost and once at the billing rate, and compare them with the price of each option in the table.

Most firms that run this test find the answer is not another full-time hire. It is fewer calls reaching the paralegal at the wrong moment, and the ones that do reach them arriving with the question already written down.

Frequently asked questions

Should paralegals answer phones at a law firm?

Occasionally, for calls that need a paralegal's knowledge. As routine front-desk cover it is costly: a paralegal in legal services earns a mean $32.45 an hour against $20.65 for a receptionist[2][3], and interruptions raise error rates on sequence work[1].

Can a paralegal do intake calls for new clients?

Yes, with training and supervision. ABA Formal Opinion 506 allows nonlawyers to gather initial facts and run an initial conflict check, provided the prospective client can always talk with a lawyer[9].

Do paralegals get overtime if phone duty makes them stay late?

Often, yes. Paralegals generally do not qualify as exempt learned professionals under federal rules[4], and nonexempt employees must be paid at least time and a half for hours over 40 in a workweek[5]. Check each role's facts and your state's law.

How do I measure how much time my paralegal spends on the phone?

Keep a ten-day tally of every call the paralegal answers, including the minutes it took to get back into the task. Put the totals into the staff-time calculator at the paralegal's full hourly cost.

References

  1. Europe PMC (EMBL-EBI) (2014). Momentary interruptions can derail the train of thought (Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 2014), Europe PMC record (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, May 2025: legal services, paralegals and legal assistants, mean hourly wage (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, May 2025: legal services, receptionists and information clerks, mean hourly wage (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 29 CFR 541.301: Learned professionals (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. U.S. Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division (2026). Overtime Pay (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Employer Costs for Employee Compensation - June 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑

  8. Illinois Supreme Court Commission on Professionalism (2Civility) (2024). Phone Calls Ignored, Emails Unanswered: Fixing the First Impression Problem for Law Firms (opens in a new tab) ↑

  9. American Bar Association Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility (2023). ABA Formal Opinion 506: Responsibilities Regarding Nonlawyer Assistants (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo