Key takeaways
- Run both services for about two weeks and move one route at a time, starting with daytime overflow.
- List every route into the old service before changing anything, including attorney mobiles and ad numbers[2].
- Export messages and recordings before notice runs out; information from prospects who never hired you is still protected[3].
- If the old service holds a number you advertise, port it before cancelling; a simple port should take one business day[1].
Where calls go missing in a switch
Calls rarely drop because the new answering service is bad. They drop in the gaps around the change. The main line moves on a Friday afternoon, but the after-hours schedule still points at the old service, which was cancelled the same day. An attorney's mobile still forwards unanswered calls to an account that no longer exists. A tracking number on last year's TV spot turns out to belong to the old vendor. Nobody notices until a client mentions they called three times.
Firms change services for ordinary reasons: messages arrive late or garbled, agents can't follow intake instructions, the contract terms change, or the firm wants consultations booked rather than logged. There is no shortage of alternatives. The Census Bureau counted 1,035 telephone answering service establishments employing 41,582 people in 2023[4]. If you are still choosing the replacement, how to choose a legal answering service covers the evaluation. This piece starts after the decision, with the cutover, which follows the same pattern whichever service you are leaving.
First, list every route into the old service
Before anything changes, write down every way a call can reach the old service. Firms nearly always find more routes than they expected, because they get added one at a time over the years and nobody keeps the list.
| Route | Where to check | What changes | Move on |
|---|---|---|---|
| Main line, daytime overflow | Phone system admin portal: ring group or no-answer rule | Forwarding destination | Day 0 |
| Voicemail overflow | Voicemail settings on the main line | Whether unanswered or full-mailbox calls roll to the service | Day 0 |
| Main line, nights and weekends | Phone system schedule or time-of-day rule | Destination for the after-hours schedule | Day 2 |
| Attorney mobiles | Each phone's forwarding setting or carrier code | Forwarding target, or switch it off | Day 2 |
| Ad and tracking numbers | Tracking provider dashboard and ad accounts | Where each number terminates | Day 7 |
| Numbers the old service holds | Contract, invoices and the service's account page | Port to your own carrier before cancelling | Port date |
Mobiles deserve their own check. On Verizon phones, for example, *72 plus a number forwards every call, *71 plus a number forwards only the calls you don't answer, and *73 turns forwarding off[2]. Other carriers use their own codes or app settings. An attorney who set *71 to the old service three years ago won't remember doing it, so check each phone and write down what you find.
The last row is the dangerous one. Some services supply the number a firm advertises, often a toll-free or tracking number, and cancelling before it moves can take the number with the account. Ask the old service in writing which numbers it holds for you and how to port them. Federal rules require carriers to complete a simple port within one business day, and a complete request received between 8 a.m. and 1 p.m. local time can go live at midnight that day[1]. Port first, confirm calls arrive, then cancel. If the firm is changing phone carriers as well, follow changing phone providers without losing calls and keep the two projects in separate weeks.
Get your records out while the account is open
Everything the old service holds about your callers is the firm's information: message logs, recordings, intake notes and the list of callers who never became clients. Ask for an export in a usable format, CSV for messages and audio files for recordings, as soon as you give notice, and again on the last day of service so the overlap weeks are included.
- The message log for the whole contract: date, time, caller, number, message text and who it went to.
- Call recordings and transcripts, if the service keeps them, with its stated retention period.
- The account's current instructions, including every note agents see on screen when your call arrives.
- Lists the service keeps for you: existing clients, do-not-transfer names, opposing counsel, blocked numbers.
- The service's call log for the overlap weeks, so you can see what still reached it after each route moved.
Treat the export as confidential material. California's Rule 1.18 says that even when no lawyer-client relationship follows, a lawyer may not use or reveal protected information learned from a prospective client, and material information can keep other lawyers in the firm from acting against that person[3]. Load every prospect's name from the export into the conflict system before the old account closes. Rule 5.3 asks lawyers to make reasonable efforts to ensure that nonlawyers the firm retains act consistently with the lawyers' obligations[3], so ask the old service to confirm in writing when it has deleted your data, and file the letter with the contract. Notice periods and data-return clauses are covered in answering service contract terms.
Carry the instructions over, not just the numbers
The old service's account notes hold years of small fixes: the client who must never be put through, the court clerk who always gets the managing partner, the opposing party who calls pretending to be a client. Ask for a full copy of everything an agent sees when your call arrives, and read it line by line. Some of it will be stale. The rest is institutional memory the firm paid for and will lose if nobody copies it.
Rebuild the instructions in a document the firm owns, rather than typing them straight into the new service's form, so the next change is easier. A firm-owned call-handling knowledge base is the natural home, and the service's version follows the format in writing call-handling instructions. Rewrite urgent-call rules as tests a stranger could apply, such as “a client is in custody tonight”, rather than judgment calls such as “anything important”.
A two-week overlap, step by step
Run both services at once. The old one keeps every route until the day that route moves, and the new one is built and tested while the phones still go the old way. An example timeline:
Day −14: build the new service
Greeting, intake questions, urgent rules, escalation numbers and message delivery are set up. No real calls yet.
Days −10 to −4: test it directly
Ring the new service's own number with scripted callers: a new prospect, an existing client, an urgent call, a wrong number and a caller who already has a lawyer. Fix and retest.
Day −3: give notice
Time the old contract's notice so service runs to at least Day 14, and request the first data export.
Day 0, a Tuesday morning: move daytime overflow
Change one forwarding rule, then call the main line from an outside mobile and let it ring through. Check the message arrives where it should.
Day 2: move nights and weekends
Switch the after-hours schedule and the attorney mobiles. Make a test call that evening and another on Saturday.
Day 7: move the rest
Ad and tracking numbers, ported numbers and anything else on the inventory. Ask the old service for its call log to confirm nothing still arrives.
Day 14: close out
Take the final export, load prospects into the conflict system, ask for written confirmation of deletion, then cancel.
Pick a quiet midweek morning for Day 0, never a Friday afternoon or the day before a holiday, and have someone who can change the forwarding sitting at the phone system for the first two hours. Testing your answering service with test calls has scripted personas and a scorecard for the direct tests.
- Your team
- Caller
- SI Employee
- System
01Your team
Forwarding rule changed
The daytime no-answer rule now points to the new service; the old one stays live.
02Caller
Test call from a mobile
An outside phone rings the main line and lets it go unanswered.
03SI Employee
New service answers
Greeting, disclosures and the first intake question, in the firm's name.
04System
Message arrives
The summary reaches the right inbox within minutes; check every field.
05Your team
Old log checked
The old service confirms no calls reached it on this route after the change.
Example sequence, repeated for each route on the inventory. Move the next route only when this one passes.
The first two weeks after cutover
Read every message the new service sends for the first ten business days, not a sample. Look for missing callback numbers, wrong urgency flags, misheard names and messages sent to the wrong person. Fix the instructions the same day and tell the service what changed.
Then look for anyone who fell through the gap. Compare the phone system's call log for the cutover days with the messages you received; a call on the log with no message attached is a caller to ring back. Leave a voicemail when they don't pick up. In Pew's 2020 survey only 19% of adults said they generally answer calls from unknown numbers, while 67% said they don't answer but check voicemail if one is left[5]. A voicemail with the firm's name and a direct number reaches people a bare missed call won't.
- Answer the call 19%
- Don't answer, check voicemail 67%
- Ignore call and voicemail 14%
Source: Pew Research Center, 2020[5]
Show the data
| Usual practice | Share of adults |
|---|---|
| Answer the call | 19% |
| Don't answer, check voicemail | 67% |
| Ignore call and voicemail | 14% |
When the new service is an SI Employee
The plan is the same, with a few differences worth knowing in advance. The firm forwards its number to the SI Employee on the schedule it chooses: overflow during the day, nights and weekends, or all day. Run fictional cases through intake, routing and booking before a single real call is forwarded, then move routes one at a time as above. You can hear it handle a test call before you plan the cutover.
- Escalation numbers must be direct lines or mobiles. A call can't be transferred back to the same line that forwarded it, so the main number cannot be a transfer destination.
- The escalation tree takes up to three destinations plus a tested fallback. If nobody picks up, the caller is told plainly and an urgent message is saved.
- Every call arrives in the firm's AssistCall account with a summary, recording and transcript, and the people the firm chooses are notified by email.
- The greeting carries the disclosures the firm approves. Florida Bar Opinion 24-1, for one, says an AI chatbot that talks with clients or third parties must say it is an AI program and not a lawyer or employee of the firm[6].
- A partner can listen to a call in progress, whisper guidance the caller doesn't hear, or take the call over, which is useful during the overlap weeks.
The three-attorney defense firm example shows a night line moving from an on-call attorney's mobile to an escalation tree with a backup at each step, which is the hardest route in most switches.
Example: a four-route switch
Example: a three-lawyer firm leaves a message-only service after a run of missed urgent calls. The inventory turns up four routes, not the two the office manager expected: daytime overflow, the night schedule, a partner's mobile set to forward unanswered calls years ago, and a toll-free number on bus-shelter ads that the old service supplied.
The firm ports the toll-free number first, during week one, while both services run. It moves daytime overflow on a Tuesday, nights and the mobile on Thursday, and checks the old service's call log the following Tuesday: two calls still arrived there, both forwarded from the partner's second mobile, which nobody had listed. That phone is fixed, the final export goes into the conflict system, and the old contract ends on Day 14 with a deletion letter on file.
In this example, the calls that would have been lost came through the forgotten second mobile. The inventory and the old service's call log are what found it.
Frequently asked questions
How long should the old and new answering services overlap?
About two weeks in most firms: long enough to move each route separately and still have the old service answering if one has to be rolled back. Time the old contract's notice so it ends after the last route has moved and the final export is in hand.
Can we keep our phone number when we switch answering services?
Yes. Usually the firm owns its number and only the forwarding changes. If the old service supplied a number you advertise, port it to your own carrier before cancelling; under FCC rules a simple port should be completed within one business day[1].
What should we get from the old service before we cancel?
The full message log, any recordings and transcripts, the instructions agents see on screen, any client or do-not-transfer lists, and a call log for the overlap weeks. Then ask for written confirmation that they have deleted your data[3].
Do we need to tell clients we changed answering services?
Not as a rule, but tell anyone whose instructions change, such as clients given an after-hours process. Clients may notice a different voice, which is a reason to keep the greeting in the firm's name and the wording as close as you can.
Should we switch during a busy month?
Avoid it if you can. Cut over midweek in an ordinary month with someone ready to change forwarding back. If the current service is failing and the switch can't wait, move daytime overflow first, where staff will catch problems quickly.
References
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 47 CFR § 52.35 - Porting intervals (opens in a new tab) ↑
Verizon (2026). Call Forwarding FAQs (opens in a new tab) ↑
The State Bar of California (2026). California Rules of Professional Conduct (2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Census Bureau (2023). County Business Patterns 2023: U.S. detail file (cbp23us), NAICS 561421 Telephone Answering Services (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑
The Florida Bar (2024). Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1 (opens in a new tab) ↑