Key takeaways
- A lawyer must not assist anyone in the unauthorized practice of law[1], which makes intake staff's words the firm's problem.
- A workable standard: staff identify themselves as nonlawyers, ask only factual questions, give no legal advice and pass legal questions to a lawyer[2].
- Never let staff answer legal questions with AI tools: Stanford researchers found leading legal research tools were wrong more than 17% of the time[3].
- Train with scripts for the questions callers actually ask, then review real calls.
Why intake is where UPL risk lives
Callers want answers. Do I have a case? Is it too late? Should I sign this? Will I go to jail? The person who answers the phone is usually a receptionist, an intake specialist or a paralegal, and the caller does not care about the difference. Wanting to help, staff say something reassuring that turns out to be legal advice. Under ABA Model Rule 5.5(a), a lawyer shall not practice law in violation of the regulation of the legal profession in a jurisdiction, or assist another in doing so[1]. When nonlawyer staff give legal advice in the firm's name, the lawyers who employ and supervise them are exposed.
States define the practice of law differently, and few definitions draw a bright line around a phone call. The safest approach is an operational one: decide in advance what staff may say, give them words for everything else and check that they use them.
Information versus advice
| Legal information (staff may share) | Legal advice (lawyers only) |
|---|---|
| The firm handles divorce and custody cases in these counties | You will probably get primary custody |
| Court filings generally have deadlines, and the attorney will check yours | You have 30 days, so you are fine |
| Here is the address of the courthouse and the clerk's phone number | File this form and the case will be dismissed |
| The consultation covers your options and the likely costs | You should not accept that settlement |
| The attorney can explain whether a claim may be worth pursuing | That sounds like a strong case |
| Bring the letter you received and any court papers | Ignore that letter; it is not valid |
The simplest test for staff is this: if the answer depends on the caller's particular facts, or tells them what to do, it is advice. General facts about the firm, the process and logistics are information.
A four-part standard for intake staff
Florida Ethics Opinion 88-6, which the Florida Bar's 2024 opinion on generative AI calls especially useful for intake chatbots, sets out a clear standard for nonlawyers conducting an initial interview: identify their nonlawyer status, limit questions to obtaining factual information, give no legal advice and refer legal questions to the lawyer[2]. Even outside Florida, it is a sensible house rule.
Identify yourself
“I'm the intake coordinator. I'm not an attorney, but I'll make sure an attorney reviews your situation.”
Ask facts, not opinions
Who, what, when, where and what documents exist. Never ask the caller what they think their legal position is and then agree with it.
Give no advice
Not even soft advice. “I wouldn't worry about it” and “you should be fine” are advice.
Hand legal questions to a lawyer
Write the question down word for word and promise a callback or a consultation where it will be answered.
Scripts for the questions callers really ask
- “Do I have a case?” — “That's exactly what the attorney will look at. I'll get the details so they can give you a real answer.”
- “Is it too late?” — “Deadlines can matter a lot, so I'm going to flag this as time-sensitive for the attorney today. When did this happen?”
- “Should I sign this?” — “Please don't sign anything until an attorney has looked at it. Can you send me a photo of it?”
- “Can they do that to me?” — “The attorney can explain your rights. Let me get what happened so they have the full picture.”
- “What would you do?” — “I really can't advise you, but I can get you in front of someone who can.”
- “How much is my case worth?” — “Only an attorney can assess that, and usually only after reviewing documents.”
- “Will I go to jail?” — “I understand that's frightening. I'm going to get an attorney to speak with you as soon as possible.”
Banned phrases: “I'm not a lawyer, but…”, “Off the record…”, “In my experience…”, “You'll be fine”, and any number of days or dollars applied to the caller's own situation.
Do not let staff answer with AI tools
A newer risk is staff quietly using a chatbot to answer a caller's legal question. Accuracy alone rules it out. Stanford researchers found that Lexis+ AI and Ask Practical Law AI produced incorrect information more than 17% of the time and Westlaw AI-Assisted Research more than 34% of the time on their benchmark, while an earlier study found general-purpose chatbots hallucinated between 58% and 82% of the time on legal queries[3].
Regulators also take a dim view of software that implies it can stand in for a lawyer. In 2025 the FTC finalized an order requiring DoNotPay, marketed as the world's first robot lawyer, to pay $193,000 and barring it from advertising that its service performs like a real lawyer without sufficient evidence[4]. Put a written rule in the staff handbook: no AI tool may be used to answer a caller's legal question, and no AI-generated text goes to a caller without a lawyer's review.
Callers in crisis
The pressure to advise is greatest when a caller is frightened: police are at the door, a child has not been returned after a visit, an eviction crew is outside. Staff should not try to solve the legal problem, but they should not freeze either. Give them a short escalation path they can follow without thinking.
- If anyone is in immediate danger, tell the caller to call 911 first.
- Get the caller's name, number and location, and the single most urgent fact.
- Interrupt an attorney or use the emergency on-call route your firm has set up.
- If no attorney can be reached quickly, say so honestly and tell the caller when someone will call back.
- Record the time of each step in the intake note.
An honest “I can't advise you, but I am getting an attorney right now” is far more useful to a caller in crisis than a confident guess.
Paralegals and experienced staff
The risk is often highest with the most experienced staff. A paralegal who has worked in family law for fifteen years may know the likely answer better than a new associate. That knowledge is valuable inside the firm, under a lawyer's supervision. It is not a license to advise callers. Encourage experienced staff to pass their read of a situation to the attorney in the intake note, where it helps, rather than to the caller, where it creates risk.
Training and quality checks
- Give every new staff member the information-versus-advice table and the scripts on day one.
- Role-play the seven common questions until the responses are automatic.
- Review a sample of calls or intake notes each month, where recording laws and consent allow, looking for advice language.
- Correct problems privately and quickly, and update the scripts when a new kind of question keeps coming up.
- Apply the same standard to answering services, chat tools and anyone else who speaks to callers for the firm.
Supervision obligations sit behind all of this; see supervising nonlawyer staff and vendors under Rule 5.3. The same habits support confidentiality, covered in Rule 1.6 confidentiality for front desk teams.
Example: a missed-deadline call
Example (fictional): a caller says she received a lawsuit by mail three weeks ago and asks the receptionist whether she still has time to respond. The receptionist, who has heard attorneys mention a thirty-day period, is tempted to say yes. Instead she uses the deadline script, records the date the papers arrived and the court named on them, marks the note urgent and asks an attorney to call back within the hour.
The attorney calls back, reviews a photo of the summons and finds that the response deadline in that court is shorter than the receptionist assumed. A reassuring guess would have cost the caller her chance to respond and exposed the firm. The script took twenty seconds.
Related guides
For the wider intake sequence, see the law firm client intake process step-by-step guide. Disclaimers for websites and chat tools are covered in attorney advertising disclaimers: when you need them. This article is general information, not legal advice; the definition of the practice of law varies by state.
Frequently asked questions
Can intake staff tell a caller whether they have a case?
No. Whether someone has a case applies law to their facts, which is legal advice. Staff should collect the facts and say that an attorney will assess the situation.
What is the difference between legal information and legal advice?
Information is general and factual, such as what the firm handles or where the courthouse is. Advice applies law to a person's situation or tells them what to do.
Is saying I'm not a lawyer, but enough to avoid UPL?
No. A disclaimer followed by advice is still advice. Staff should identify as nonlawyers and then not give advice at all.
Can staff use AI to answer callers' legal questions?
They should not. Benchmarks show high error rates for AI tools on legal questions, and the answer would still be advice given by a nonlawyer in the firm's name.
References
American Bar Association (2026). Rule 5.5: Unauthorized Practice of Law; Multijurisdictional Practice of Law, ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct (archived copy) (opens in a new tab) ↑
The Florida Bar (2024). Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Stanford Institute for Human-Centered Artificial Intelligence (HAI) (2024). AI on Trial: Legal Models Hallucinate in 1 out of 6 (or More) Benchmarking Queries (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (2025). FTC Finalizes Order with DoNotPay That Prohibits Deceptive 'AI Lawyer' Claims (opens in a new tab) ↑