Key takeaways
- Federal law lets one party consent to recording, but Pennsylvania requires prior consent from all parties and treats unlawful interception as a third-degree felony[1][2][3].
- Illinois focuses on surreptitious recording of a private conversation; recording openly, with every party's consent, keeps a firm outside the offense[4].
- Illinois' biometric privacy law adds a second layer: a voiceprint is a biometric identifier, with liquidated damages of $1,000 or $5,000 per violation[5][6].
- One announcement at the very start of every call, played on every line and itself recorded, satisfies the practical test in both states.
Two all-party states with different triggers
Federal wiretap law sets a low floor: a person who is a party to a call, or who has one party's consent, may record it, unless the purpose is criminal or tortious[1]. The same provision says nothing about state law, and states are free to demand more. Pennsylvania and Illinois both do, which matters for any firm with offices, clients or callers in either state.
The two statutes reach a similar practical answer by different routes. Pennsylvania asks whether all parties gave prior consent[3]. Illinois asks whether a private conversation was recorded in a surreptitious manner without the consent of all other parties[4]. A firm that announces recording before anything substantive is said, and lets the caller choose, satisfies both questions. A firm that relies on a line buried in its website terms satisfies neither.
Pennsylvania: prior consent from everyone on the line
Pennsylvania's Wiretapping and Electronic Surveillance Control Act makes it an offense to intentionally intercept a wire, electronic or oral communication, and separately to disclose or use the contents knowing they came from an interception. The offense is graded as a felony of the third degree[2]. The exception law firms rely on applies where all parties to the communication have given prior consent to the interception[3].
Two words in that exception do the work. All means the caller, anyone the caller has on speaker, the staff member or system answering, and anyone conferenced in later. Prior means before the recording captures their words, not after the fact in a follow-up email. The act also gives an injured person a civil claim, so the exposure is not only criminal.
- Play the notice before the first intake question, not after the caller has described the problem.
- When a third party joins, such as a family member or interpreter, repeat the notice and note who joined.
- Treat an objection as a choice, not a dead end: stop recording or offer a callback on an unrecorded line.
- Apply the same rule to outbound calls your staff make from the firm's phone system.
Illinois: secrecy is the trigger
Illinois rewrote its eavesdropping statute in 2014 after its supreme court struck down the earlier version as too broad. The current text makes it eavesdropping to use a device, in a surreptitious manner, to record all or part of a private conversation to which you are a party, unless you have the consent of all other parties[4]. A private conversation is one where a party reasonably expects privacy, which describes nearly every intake call.
The surreptitious element means an open, announced recording is outside the offense. Firms should not lean on that alone. Getting every party's consent through a clear announcement is simpler to prove than arguing later about what a caller should have expected, and it gives the same answer under the Pennsylvania test.
The Illinois extra: voiceprints under BIPA
Illinois' Biometric Information Privacy Act lists a voiceprint as a biometric identifier. A private entity may not collect one without first informing the person in writing and obtaining a written release[5]. A recording or transcript is not automatically a voiceprint, but speaker identification, voice authentication and some call analytics features build exactly that kind of template.
Source: Illinois General Assembly, 2025[6]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Negligent violation | $1,000 |
| Intentional or reckless violation | $5,000 |
The statute's liquidated damages are set per violation, which is why class actions follow quickly when a feature is switched on without the paperwork[6]. Before enabling any voice feature on Illinois calls, ask your phone or software provider these questions in writing:
- Does any feature create a voiceprint, speaker profile or voice match, even for internal routing?
- Can those features be switched off for the firm's account, and is that confirmed in the contract?
- How long are recordings and transcripts kept, and who can delete them?
- Is there a written retention and destruction policy we can publish if a biometric feature is ever used?
Side by side
| Question | Pennsylvania | Illinois |
|---|---|---|
| Consent standard | Prior consent of all parties | Consent of all other parties to a private conversation |
| What creates liability | Intentional interception, disclosure or use | Surreptitious recording of a private conversation |
| Criminal grade | Felony of the third degree | Criminal offense under the eavesdropping article |
| Extra privacy layer | None specific to voice | BIPA written notice and release for voiceprints |
| Practical safe course | Announce first, before substantive talk | Announce first, and keep voice biometrics off |
Interstate calls: plan for the stricter rule
Intake lines rarely stay inside one state. A Philadelphia firm takes calls from New Jersey and Delaware; a Chicago firm hears from Indiana and Wisconsin; national practices take calls from everywhere. Courts do not apply one uniform choice-of-law answer to interstate recordings, and a firm cannot know in advance which state's law a court will pick. The defensible position is to behave as if the strictest state touching the call applies.
For most firms that means a single all-party announcement on every line, in every office, for inbound and outbound calls. It costs a few seconds per call. Trying to detect the caller's location and switch scripts adds failure points: mobile numbers travel, callers relocate, and area codes say little about where someone is standing. One script, applied everywhere, is easier to train, audit and prove.
Keeping and using recordings
Consent to record is not the end of the analysis. Recordings of prospective clients hold confidential information even when the firm declines the matter, so the duties owed to prospective clients still apply to the file. Limit access to the people who handle intake and conflicts, set a retention period that matches your file-retention policy, and decide who may export or share a recording.
- Store recordings in the same system of record as the intake notes, not in personal email or chat threads.
- Set an automatic deletion date for declined inquiries, after any conflicts or limitations hold has passed.
- Review the access list each quarter, including any vendor support staff who can reach recordings.
A recording notice that works in both states
Put the notice first
The notice plays or is spoken before any intake question. If your greeting has a menu, the notice comes before the menu.
Use plain wording
Script: βThank you for calling the firm. This call is recorded so our team can review your inquiry accurately. If you would prefer not to be recorded, say so now and we will arrange a callback.β
Record the notice itself
Start recording before the notice plays so the file proves consent. A notice that sits outside the recording is hard to prove later.
Handle objections
Train staff to stop the recording, note the request and continue or schedule a callback. Never argue the caller into consenting.
Cover outbound calls
Staff calling a prospect back say the same notice at the start. Voicemail left for a caller is not a two-way conversation, but the callback that follows is.
Log it
Your intake record should show recording status: notice played, objection made, recording stopped.
If an SI Employee such as Ava answers your line, its greeting carries the same notice your firm approves, and because the notice plays first it is part of every recording. For a broader view of where else this matters, see the state-by-state consent guide.
Example: one call, two states
Example: a fictional employment firm in Pittsburgh receives a call from a warehouse worker in Rockford, Illinois. The firm's greeting announces recording, the caller agrees and begins describing a termination. Halfway through, the caller adds a former coworker on speaker. The intake specialist repeats the notice, the coworker agrees, and the record notes the time. Afterwards the firm's analytics vendor offers a speaker-identification feature to tag who said what. Because the caller is in Illinois, the firm declines until it has a BIPA notice and release process, and keeps plain transcription only.
Every decision in that call follows from two habits: announce before substance, and treat any new voice feature as a privacy decision rather than a settings toggle.
Mistakes that cause trouble
- Relying on website terms or an engagement letter for consent to calls that happen before the client signs anything.
- Starting the recording after the notice, so the file cannot show that consent was given.
- Assuming the firm's home state rule applies when the caller sits in a stricter state.
- Switching on voice analytics because it came bundled with the phone system.
- Keeping recordings indefinitely with no retention rule, which enlarges any later privacy claim.
Frequently asked questions
Is Pennsylvania a one-party or two-party consent state?
Pennsylvania requires the prior consent of all parties to record a call, so it is usually described as an all-party or two-party state. A clear announcement before the conversation starts is the standard way to obtain that consent.
Can a law firm record calls with Illinois residents?
Yes, if the recording is not surreptitious and all parties consent. Announce the recording at the start of the call. Avoid voiceprint or speaker-identification features unless you have a written BIPA notice and release process.
Does a recorded transcript count as a biometric identifier?
A transcript on its own is text, not a voiceprint. The risk comes from features that analyze the voice to identify or authenticate a speaker. Ask your provider in writing whether any feature does that.
What if the caller is in Pennsylvania but our office is in a one-party state?
Plan for the stricter rule. Firms that take calls from several states usually apply an all-party announcement to every call rather than trying to work out each caller's location.
References
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2025). 18 U.S. Code Β§ 2511 - Interception and disclosure of wire, oral, or electronic communications prohibited (opens in a new tab) β
FindLaw (Thomson Reuters), reprint of the Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes (2026). Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes, Title 18, Section 5703: Interception, disclosure or use of wire, electronic or oral communications (opens in a new tab) β
FindLaw (Thomson Reuters), reprint of the Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes (2026). Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes, Title 18, Section 5704: Exceptions to prohibition of interception and disclosure of communications (opens in a new tab) β
FindLaw (Thomson Reuters), reprint of the Illinois Compiled Statutes (2026). 720 ILCS 5/14-2: Elements of the offense; affirmative defense (eavesdropping) (opens in a new tab) β
Illinois General Assembly (2025). Biometric Information Privacy Act (740 ILCS 14) (opens in a new tab) β
Illinois General Assembly (2025). Biometric Information Privacy Act (740 ILCS 14) (opens in a new tab) β