Staffing and Training

Interview Questions for Law Firm Intake Candidates

A question bank for hiring law firm intake staff by competency, a live call simulation with caller scripts, a voicemail test and a scoring method.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. What you are really hiring for
  2. Question bank by competency
  3. Questions that test legal-intake judgment
  4. The live call simulation
  5. The voicemail and follow-up test
  6. Language and technology checks
  7. Scoring and keeping it fair
  8. Red flags that should end the process
  9. A sample 60-minute agenda
  10. Example: what the simulation revealed
  11. After the interview
  12. Frequently asked questions
  13. References
Staffing and Training: Interview Questions for Law Firm Intake CandidatesArticle coverSTAFFING AND TRAININGInterview Questions forLaw Firm IntakeCandidatesAva for LawyersInsightsStaffing and Training: Interview Questions for Law Firm Intake CandidatesArticle coverSTAFFING AND TRAININGInterview Questionsfor Law Firm IntakeCandidatesAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • Ask behavioral questions tied to six competencies, then test the same competencies in a live call simulation.
  • The simulation must include the hardest moment in intake: a caller asking for legal advice, which nonlawyers must decline[1].
  • Only 19% of US adults generally answer calls from unknown numbers, so a voicemail-writing test belongs in every intake interview[2].
  • Score with a written rubric and two interviewers, and keep every question job-related.

What you are really hiring for

Intake candidates often interview well, because the people drawn to the job are usually personable. The interview's task is to look past charm to the behaviors that decide whether a new client books with you: whether the candidate listens before talking, asks questions in a sensible order, keeps to factual questions, writes clearly, follows up without being told and stays steady with people in distress.

Build the interview around six competencies and test each twice: once by asking about past behavior and once by watching the candidate do it. The question bank below is long on purpose; pick two or three per competency and use the same ones for every candidate so the comparison is fair.

Question bank by competency

Behavioral questions mapped to intake competencies
CompetencyQuestionStrong answer includes
Listening and structureTell me about a time you had to get specific information from someone who was upset or rambling.Let them speak first, summarized back, then asked focused questions in order
BoundariesDescribe a time a customer asked you for something you weren't allowed to give. What did you say?Declined clearly, explained why, offered the right next step
ComposureWhat's the most difficult call or conversation you've handled at work? How did it end?Stayed calm, protected the person and the business, escalated appropriately
Written accuracyHow do you make sure a message you take is complete and correct?Repeats details back, uses a consistent format, checks numbers
Follow-upTell me about a time you kept chasing something that others had dropped.Set reminders, tried several channels, recorded attempts
ConfidentialityWhen have you had to keep information private at work? How did you handle questions about it?Gave nothing away, didn't overshare in the interview itself
Learning systemsWhat software have you learned on the job, and how did you get up to speed?Specific tools, self-directed practice, asked for help early

Listen for specifics. Vague answers such as I'm a people person or I always stay calm tell you little. Follow up with: What exactly did you say? What happened next? What would you do differently?

These are hypothetical, and there are firm-specific right answers to some of them. What you are listening for is whether the candidate pauses, protects the caller and the firm, and asks how the firm wants it handled.

  • A caller asks, Do I have a case? What do you say, word for word?
  • Someone calls and says the other side's lawyer is threatening them. They want to know what to do tonight. How do you respond?
  • A caller gives you details of a crime they say they committed. What do you do?
  • A caller is crying and says they don't feel safe at home. What are your first two questions?
  • You realize halfway through a call that the caller is suing one of the firm's clients. What now?
  • A caller speaks limited English. What do you do if you don't speak their language?

The first question is the most revealing. Nonlawyers conducting intake should identify their nonlawyer status, keep to factual questions, give no legal advice and refer legal questions to the lawyer[1]. Strong candidates say something like, I'm not an attorney, so I can't tell you that, but I can get your details to someone who can, and they say it kindly.

The live call simulation

Words in an interview are cheap; a ten-minute simulated call is not. Give the candidate the firm's intake form for one practice area and five minutes to read it. A colleague plays the caller from a script with set facts and set curveballs.

  1. Brief the candidate

    Explain the practice area, the form and that they should treat it as a real call. They may take notes.

  2. Caller opens with emotion

    Example script: I was in a crash on Saturday and my back is killing me and the other guy's insurance keeps calling me.

  3. Caller wanders

    Partway through, the caller starts describing an unrelated dispute with a neighbor. Does the candidate redirect politely?

  4. Caller asks for advice

    Should I talk to the insurance company? and What's my case worth? Watch for any opinion.

  5. Caller gives a vague date

    Sometime last month, I think. Does the candidate probe gently and record it as approximate?

  6. Close

    Does the candidate explain next steps, confirm the callback number and give a specific time?

Immediately afterward, give the candidate ten minutes to write a short summary for the attorney. Compare it with the scripted facts: anything missing, anything added, any opinion presented as fact.

The voicemail and follow-up test

Most follow-up in intake happens through voicemail. Only 19% of US adults say they generally answer when an unknown number calls, while 67% say they don't answer but check voicemail if one is left, and just 14% generally ignore voicemails[2]. A good voicemail is therefore one of the most valuable skills an intake candidate can bring.

How US adults handle calls from unknown numbers
How US adults handle calls from unknown numbersBar chart. Generally answer the call: 19%; Don't answer, but check voicemail if one is left: 67%; Generally ignore any voicemail left: 14%.Generally answer the callGenerally answer the call: 19%19%Don't answer, but check voicemail if one is leftDon't answer, but check voicemail if one is left: 67%67%Generally ignore any voicemail leftGenerally ignore any voicemail left: 14%14%How US adults handle calls from unknown numbersBar chart. Generally answer the call: 19%; Don't answer, but check voicemail if one is left: 67%; Generally ignore any voicemail left: 14%.Generally answer the callGenerally answer the call: 19%19%Don't answer, but check voicemail ifone is leftDon't answer, but check voicemail if one is left: 67%67%Generally ignore any voicemail leftGenerally ignore any voicemail left: 14%14%

Source: Pew Research Center, 2020[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
Generally answer the call19%
Don't answer, but check voicemail if one is left67%
Generally ignore any voicemail left14%

Ask the candidate to leave a recorded voicemail for a caller who filled in a web form an hour ago. Score it on five points: the candidate's name, the firm's name, the reason for the call without sensitive details, a callback number said slowly and twice, and a specific window when they'll try again. Then ask them to write the follow-up email. Both should take under five minutes.

Language and technology checks

If the role needs a second language, test it with a fluent assessor using the same simulation. More than 1 in 5 people aged 5 and older in the US (22%) speak a language other than English at home[3], so bilingual intake is often a real advantage, but it must be tested rather than taken from a resume.

For technology, have the candidate enter the simulated call into a practice form while talking. Watch for accuracy and whether they can type and listen at once. Training gaps with new tools are widespread: Thomson Reuters found 64% of professionals had received no training on using generative AI for their industry work[4]. Hire for willingness and aptitude, then train on your systems, including any automated intake the firm uses.

Scoring and keeping it fair

  • Use the same questions, simulation and scripts for every candidate.
  • Two interviewers score independently from 1 to 5 on each competency, then compare.
  • Write a one-line reason for each score while it is fresh.
  • Keep every question job-related. Do not ask about age, family plans, religion, national origin, health or disability. Ask whether the candidate can work the stated schedule, not about their personal circumstances.
  • If a language is required, test the language; don't ask where the candidate is from.
  • Weight the simulation and summary more heavily than conversational answers.

Red flags that should end the process

Some behaviors are hard to train out, and intake is the wrong place to discover them after the hire. If any of these show up in the interview, treat them as a strong signal, not a minor note.

  • Offering an opinion on the simulated caller's case, especially a reassuring one.
  • Sharing identifiable stories about past employers' customers or patients.
  • Blaming every past difficulty on colleagues or customers, with no account of what the candidate might have done differently.
  • Treating the written summary as an afterthought: late, incomplete or full of the candidate's own conclusions.
  • Leaving a voicemail with sensitive details, such as the caller's legal problem, on what might be a shared phone.

A candidate who shows one of these but is otherwise strong can be asked about it directly: In the simulation you told the caller the insurance company would probably settle. What made you say that? A thoughtful answer, and a clear change when you rerun that part of the call, is worth more than a polished first attempt.

A sample 60-minute agenda

  1. Five minutes: introductions and an honest description of the role, including the hard parts.
  2. Fifteen minutes: behavioral questions, two or three per competency.
  3. Ten minutes: legal-intake judgment questions.
  4. Fifteen minutes: live call simulation plus a written summary.
  5. Five minutes: voicemail and follow-up email test.
  6. Ten minutes: candidate questions, schedule and pay range.

Example: what the simulation revealed

Example (fictional): Two candidates for a criminal defense firm both answer the behavioral questions well. In the simulation, the caller's brother has just been arrested. Candidate one asks what the brother did and listens to a long account of the night. Candidate two asks for the brother's full name, date of birth and where he is being held, says she can't discuss what happened, and promises an attorney callback within the hour. Her written summary lists the facility, the caller's relationship and the callback number at the top. The firm hires candidate two and uses candidate one's answers to improve its training on what not to collect.

After the interview

Send every candidate a decision within the time you promised. Strong intake people judge employers by the same standard they will be held to: prompt, clear follow-up. For the new hire, carry the rubric into training; see the 30-day onboarding plan and role-play drills for intake calls. For the job description itself, see hiring a legal receptionist, and for pay, legal receptionist pay benchmarks.

Frequently asked questions

What is the single best interview question for intake staff?

Ask what they would say, word for word, to a caller who asks, Do I have a case? It tests boundaries, warmth and composure at once.

Is a role-play fair to nervous candidates?

Yes, if every candidate gets the same brief, script and time. Intake is a live-call job, so seeing a live call is the most relevant evidence you can collect.

How many interviewers should there be?

Two is enough for most firms: one runs the interview and plays the caller, the other observes and scores. Compare scores before discussing impressions.

Should we ask about salary history?

Many states and cities restrict asking about pay history. State your range and ask whether it works for the candidate instead.

References

  1. The Florida Bar (2024). Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. U.S. Census Bureau (2025). New Data on Detailed Languages Spoken at Home and the Ability to Speak English (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. Thomson Reuters (2025). Generative AI Adoption Nearly Doubles as Professional Services Reach Crossroads (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo