Key takeaways
- The Justice Manual defines a target as a person the prosecutor or grand jury has substantial evidence linking to a crime and who, in the prosecutor's judgment, is a putative defendant[1].
- About 97% of individuals sentenced in federal court in fiscal 2024 pleaded guilty, so the pre-charge window is often where representation matters most[2].
- Protect privilege from the first minute: a private line, a personal device, no third parties and no narrative of the conduct until conflicts clear.
- Search warrants and agent visits need an on-call attorney path, not a voicemail box.
Who calls, and what has usually just happened
Federal investigation calls rarely begin with an arrest. More often the caller has received a target letter, been served with a grand jury subpoena, had FBI or other agents knock on the door, watched a search warrant executed at home or work, or learned that their employer is under investigation. Some are calling for a spouse or a business partner. Almost all are frightened, and many want to explain at length why they have done nothing wrong.
Demand is rising. Filings for criminal defendants in US district courts grew 12% in the year ending March 31, 2025[3]. And the stakes of the early phase are high: of the 61,678 individual cases reported to the US Sentencing Commission in fiscal 2024, most sentenced individuals, 97%, pleaded guilty[2]. Because so few federal cases go to trial, the work done before and around charging decisions, including whether a person is charged at all and with what, often shapes the outcome.
- Pleaded guilty 97%
Source: United States Sentencing Commission, 2024[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Pleaded guilty | 97% |
Target, subject, witness: what intake needs to know
Callers often use these words loosely. The Justice Manual defines a target as a person as to whom the prosecutor or the grand jury has substantial evidence linking them to the commission of a crime and who, in the prosecutor's judgment, is a putative defendant; a subject is a person whose conduct is within the scope of the grand jury's investigation[1]. The manual encourages prosecutors, in appropriate cases, to notify a target a reasonable time before seeking an indictment, but not in routine clear cases or where notice might jeopardize the investigation[1].
Intake staff should not tell callers which category they fall into. They should record exactly what document the caller received, who sent it, its date and any response or appearance date, and ask the caller to send a copy of every page.
Triage by trigger
| Trigger | Urgency | What intake records |
|---|---|---|
| Search warrant being executed now | Immediate: on-call attorney | Location, agency, whether the caller is present, a callback number not likely to be seized |
| Agents at the door or just left | Immediate to same day | Agency, agent names from business cards, what was asked, whether a follow-up was scheduled |
| Target letter received | Same day | Date of letter, issuing office, prosecutor named, any meeting date offered |
| Grand jury subpoena for testimony | Same day | Court, return date, whether documents are also requested |
| Grand jury subpoena for documents only | Within one business day | Return date, the recipient (individual or company), the categories requested |
| Employer internal investigation | Within one business day | Employer, who contacted the caller, whether company counsel has offered to represent them |
| Family member arrested on federal charges | Same day | Full name, date of birth, where held, any initial appearance date |
Write these rules into the after-hours script. Search warrants are commonly executed early in the morning, and a firm that cannot reach an attorney until mid-morning has missed the most important hours.
Protecting privilege on the first call
Confidentiality starts before any engagement. Under Model Rule 1.18, a person who consults a lawyer about possibly forming a client-lawyer relationship is a prospective client, and the lawyer must not use or reveal what was learned even if no relationship follows, except as the rules permit[4]. But the firm also has to make sure the conversation is actually confidential.
- Ask whether anyone else is on the line or in the room. Family members, coworkers and friends should not be present.
- Ask whether the caller is using a work phone, work email or a company laptop. If so, arrange a callback on a personal device.
- Remember that federal law generally allows a party to a call to record it[5]. Ask callers not to forward the firm's emails or share call details with others.
- Do not take a narrative of the conduct on the first call. Collect what the conflict check needs and what the attorney needs to triage.
- If the caller is in custody, assume jail calls are recorded and keep to scheduling and identity details.
Conflicts are harder here than anywhere
Federal investigations often involve several people from the same company or family. The firm may already represent the company, a coworker, or someone who will become a cooperating witness. Run the conflict check on the caller, their employer, any co-owners or coworkers they name, and the government office involved, before hearing any substance.
When an employer's counsel has offered to represent the caller, record that and flag it. Whether one lawyer can represent both the company and an employee, or several employees together, is a judgment the attorney makes; intake should never suggest that a joint arrangement is fine or not.
When a family member makes the call
Spouses and parents often call first, especially after a search or an arrest. They can help with logistics, but the person under investigation is the prospective client, and anything the family member describes about the conduct is not protected in the same way. Keep these calls to identity, location, the trigger and the dates.
- Take the name and date of birth of the person under investigation, and the best way for the attorney to reach them directly.
- If the person is in custody, record the facility and any court date; the attorney will arrange a protected call or visit.
- Tell the family member, kindly, that the attorney needs to speak with the person directly, and ask them not to discuss the facts with others.
- Record who is paying, if the family raises it, and flag it. Third-party payment arrangements need the attorney's attention before the engagement.
A first-contact script
- I'm going to ask a few questions so an attorney can call you back quickly. I'm not an attorney. Please don't tell me what happened yet.
- Are you somewhere private, on your own phone?
- What did you receive or what happened: a letter, a subpoena, a visit from agents, a search? On what date?
- Which agency or office is involved, and is any person named on the paperwork?
- Is there a date by which you are supposed to respond, appear or produce documents?
- For our conflict check: your full name, your employer, and anyone else you know is involved.
- Do you have a lawyer already, or has anyone offered you one?
- What is the safest number and time to reach you? An attorney will call you by [time].
If the caller asks whether they should talk to agents, staff use only attorney-approved wording, for example: That's exactly what the attorney will discuss with you on the callback, which will be by [time].
Documents to request immediately
- Every page of any target letter or subpoena, including attachments and schedules of documents requested.
- The search warrant and the inventory of items taken, if one was left.
- Agents' business cards, front and back.
- Any letters or emails from the employer or company counsel about the investigation.
- Any prior correspondence with a government agency on the same subject.
Ask the caller not to create new documents describing events and not to delete anything, using the firm's approved wording. Send the request through a secure channel and confirm receipt by phone.
Example: a controller with a document subpoena
Example (fictional): A controller at a medical billing company calls at 6:40 p.m. She has been handed a grand jury subpoena for testimony with a return date in three weeks, and the company's general counsel has told her the company's outside firm can represent her. She starts to explain the billing practices. The specialist stops her politely, confirms she is on her personal phone at home, records the court, return date, the company name and its outside firm, and the names of two colleagues she says also received subpoenas, for the conflict check. The check clears. Because a subpoena for testimony is a same-day trigger, the on-call attorney calls her at 8:00 p.m. The file notes the company-counsel offer for the attorney to address.
Building the after-hours path
Name an on-call attorney every night and weekend
Publish the rota to whoever answers calls outside business hours.
Script the immediate triggers
Search warrants in progress and agents at the door go straight to the on-call attorney, with a callback within minutes.
Capture a safe callback number
During a search, the caller's phone may be seized. Ask for a second number.
Log every call
Time of call, trigger, time of attorney callback. Review the log weekly.
Related reading: screening for limitation deadlines covers safe wording on timing questions, and high-asset divorce intake uses the same conflict-first discipline. Firms that also handle elder abuse referrals can compare the evidence-preservation steps in nursing home abuse intake.
Frequently asked questions
Should intake ask the caller whether they did what the government suspects?
No. The first call collects the trigger, dates, agency and conflict details. The substance waits for the attorney, after conflicts clear, on a private line.
Is a target letter the same as being charged?
No, but the caller should hear that from the attorney. Intake records the letter's date, issuing office and any meeting date and sends it to the attorney the same day.
What if the employer's lawyer has offered to represent the caller?
Record the offer and the lawyer's name, and flag it. Whether that arrangement is appropriate is for the attorney to assess.
Can we take these calls after hours?
You should. Searches and agent visits often happen early in the morning. Set up an on-call attorney and a script that routes immediate triggers straight through.
References
U.S. Department of Justice (2026). Justice Manual 9-11.000 - Grand Jury (sections 9-11.151 and 9-11.153) (opens in a new tab) โ
United States Sentencing Commission (2024). Annual Report 2024 (opens in a new tab) โ
United States Courts (Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts) (2025). Federal Judicial Caseload Statistics 2025 (opens in a new tab) โ
American Bar Association (2025). Rule 1.18: Duties to Prospective Client, ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct (archived copy) (opens in a new tab) โ
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2025). 18 U.S. Code ยง 2511 - Interception and disclosure of wire, oral, or electronic communications prohibited (opens in a new tab) โ