Key takeaways
- Contingency intake asks whether the case can recover money; hourly intake asks whether the client can pay for the work and whether the scope is clear.
- A contingent fee agreement must be in a writing signed by the client, and Model Rule 1.5(d) bars contingent fees in criminal defense and for securing a divorce or support[1].
- Attorney time costs several times staff time in law firms, so qualification should happen before the consultation, not in it[2].
- Firms that offer both models need routing rules that decide the fee path in the first two minutes.
The core difference in one sentence
A contingency practice is investing in the case, so its intake screens the case: liability, damages, a defendant who can pay, and time left to act. An hourly practice is selling time, so its intake screens the client and the scope: is the problem one the firm handles, can the client fund it, and can the firm explain what the work will involve. The questions overlap, but the order and the knock-outs differ, and a multi-practice firm that uses one form for both ends up asking injured callers about retainers and business clients about insurance.
Side-by-side comparison
| Intake element | Contingency practice | Hourly practice |
|---|---|---|
| Main question | Can this case recover enough to justify the firm's investment? | Is this work the firm does, and can the client fund it? |
| First facts | Incident date, injuries, treatment, the other party and insurance | The problem, the deadline, the other parties and the desired outcome |
| Typical knock-outs | No clear liability, minor injury, no collectible defendant, time likely expired | Outside practice area, conflict, unrealistic budget, client wants a guaranteed result |
| Money conversation | No fee unless recovery; costs and percentage explained in the written agreement | Retainer or deposit, billing rate, estimate ranges set by the attorney |
| Documents before consult | Police report, medical records list, photos, insurance letters | Contracts, court papers, correspondence, financial statements |
| Speed pressure | Evidence and records age quickly; competitors call back fast | Deadlines in court papers or contracts set the pace |
| Who decides acceptance | Attorney, often after records review | Attorney, often at the consultation |
Neither column is easier. Contingency intake rejects more callers, because the firm carries the risk. Hourly intake must handle the money conversation earlier and more directly, because the client carries it.
Contingency qualification logic
The supply of potential cases is large. NHTSA estimates 39,345 people died in US motor vehicle crashes in 2024[3], and private employers reported 2.5 million nonfatal workplace injuries and illnesses the same year[4]. Because volume is high, the risk is spending attorney time on cases the firm will not take. Use a scored set of questions.
- Liability: In a sentence, how did it happen, and who does the caller believe was at fault? Is there a police or incident report?
- Injury: What injuries, and what treatment so far? Emergency care, follow-up visits, surgery, time off work?
- Defendant: Who was the other party, and do they have insurance or a business behind them?
- Timing: When did it happen? Record the date; the attorney applies any limitation period.
- Representation: Has the caller signed with or spoken to another lawyer about this?
- Prior claims: Has the caller already given a recorded statement or signed anything for an insurer?
Give the attorneys a simple grading scale, such as accept for review today, review within one business day, or decline with a referral. Grade on the facts recorded, not on how persuasive the caller sounded.
Hourly qualification logic
For hourly work, the honest early question is about budget, asked respectfully. The Legal Services Corporation found that 46% of low-income Americans who did not seek legal help cited cost concerns[5], and only 63% of US adults would cover a $400 emergency expense entirely with cash in 2025[6]. Callers who cannot fund an hourly matter are better served by learning that on the first call, with a referral to legal aid, a limited-scope option or a flat-fee service if the firm has one.
- Fit: What is the matter, and is it one of the firm's practice areas?
- Urgency: Are there court papers, a hearing date or a contract deadline?
- Parties: Who else is involved, for the conflict check?
- Outcome: What does the caller want to happen?
- Funding: The firm works on an hourly basis with an advance deposit. Is that something you're able to consider for this matter?
- Decision-maker: Who will sign the engagement and pay the invoices? A business, a family member, the caller?
Do not quote rates or estimates unless the attorneys have written them down for staff to use. A wrong number on the first call is worse than no number.
What to collect before the consultation, by model
The document request after intake also differs. A contingency file needs evidence of liability and damages: the police or incident report number, a list of every provider who treated the caller, photographs, and any letters from insurers. Records authorizations usually follow once the attorney decides to investigate. An hourly file needs the papers that define the scope: the contract, the court papers, the correspondence with the other side, and for business clients, the entity's name and who has authority to engage the firm.
In both models, ask the caller to send documents rather than summarize them, and to bring originals of anything signed. Set a deadline before the consultation and send one reminder. A consultation where the attorney reads the key document for the first time with the client watching is slower and less useful for everyone.
Rules that restrict the fee path
Some matters cannot be taken on contingency at all. Model Rule 1.5(d) bars any fee in a domestic relations matter that is contingent on securing a divorce or on the amount of alimony, support or a property settlement, and bars a contingent fee for representing a defendant in a criminal case[1]. State versions vary, so ask the attorneys for the firm's own list. Rule 1.5(c) also requires a contingent fee agreement to be in a writing signed by the client, stating how the fee is determined, including the percentages on settlement, trial or appeal, and which expenses are deducted[1].
Intake staff do not interpret these rules. They need a one-line routing note: family law and criminal defense matters go to the hourly or flat-fee path, always.
Why the order of questions saves money
In law firms, attorney time is the most expensive input. In May 2023, lawyers employed in legal services earned a mean of $87.51 an hour, against $30.90 for paralegals and legal assistants, $27.21 for legal secretaries and $18.86 for receptionists and information clerks[2]. Wages are not the full cost of employment, but the ratio is the point: every unqualified consultation costs several times what it would have cost to screen it out earlier.
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2023[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Lawyers | $87.51 |
| Paralegals and legal assistants | $30.9 |
| Legal secretaries and admin assistants | $27.21 |
| Receptionists and information clerks | $18.86 |
The fix is not to make intake longer. It is to put each model's knock-out questions first, so callers who will not qualify learn that quickly and get a useful referral, and callers who do qualify reach an attorney with the file already built.
Routing in a firm that does both
Ask what happened, in one sentence
Let the caller describe the matter before choosing a path.
Apply the fee-path rule
Injury, wrongful death and similar matters go to contingency intake; family, criminal, business and estate matters go to hourly or flat-fee intake.
Check for a mixed matter
If the caller has two problems, such as a crash and a business dispute, open two intakes and tell the caller each will be reviewed separately.
Run that path's knock-outs
Use the model-specific questions above before collecting the full story.
Book or decline with a reason code
Record why, so the firm can see which marketing channels bring which kind of caller.
Example: one caller, two paths
Example (fictional): A delivery driver calls a two-practice firm. He was rear-ended while working last month and has been in physical therapy, and separately his ex-wife has filed to change their custody schedule. The specialist opens two linked intakes. On the injury intake, she records the crash date, the police report number, the employer, the other driver's insurer and his treatment so far, then flags it for attorney review because it may involve both a third-party claim and workers' compensation. On the custody intake, she records the court, the hearing date three weeks out, and the other party's name for the conflict check, explains that family matters are handled on an hourly basis with a deposit, and books a consultation.
Common mistakes
- Asking injured callers about payment before explaining that the firm works on contingency. They hang up thinking they can't afford you.
- Promising that there is no cost at all. Costs and how they are handled belong in the written agreement, explained by the attorney.
- Letting hourly callers book without a funding question, then losing an hour to a consultation that ends at the first mention of a deposit.
- Using one generic form for both, so staff skip questions that matter for one model and ask irrelevant ones for the other.
For the paperwork side of injury intake, see medical records authorizations. For a fixed-price alternative to hourly billing, see the flat-fee intake path.
Frequently asked questions
Should intake staff mention the contingency percentage?
Only if the attorneys have approved wording for it. The safer script is that the firm does not charge a fee unless there is a recovery, and that the attorney will explain the percentage and costs in the written agreement.
Can a family law matter ever be on contingency?
Model Rule 1.5(d) bars fees contingent on securing a divorce or on the amount of alimony, support or a property settlement. Some related matters may be treated differently under state rules, so the attorney decides; intake should route family matters to the hourly path by default.
How do we handle callers who can't afford hourly work?
Tell them early and kindly, and offer a referral to legal aid, a bar referral service, or the firm's limited-scope or flat-fee services if they fit.
Who decides whether a contingency case is accepted?
An attorney, always. Intake grades the facts and routes the file; it never tells a caller their case has been accepted.
References
American Bar Association (2025). Rule 1.5: Fees, ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct (archived copy) (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2023). May 2023 National Industry-Specific Occupational Employment and Wage Estimates: NAICS 541100 - Legal Services (opens in a new tab) โ
National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (2024). Early Estimate of Motor Vehicle Traffic Fatalities in 2024 (DOT HS 813 710) (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2024). Employer-Reported Workplace Injuries and Illnesses, 2024 (opens in a new tab) โ
Legal Services Corporation (2022). The Justice Gap Report: Executive Summary (opens in a new tab) โ
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2025). Report on the Economic Well-Being of U.S. Households: Unexpected expenses (data table) (opens in a new tab) โ