Key takeaways
- About 19% of US residents aged 16 or older, 49.2 million people, had contact with police in 2022, so even a small share of disputed encounters produces steady call volume[1].
- Section 1983 claims borrow the state's general or residual personal injury limitation period, while claims against cities and counties may carry separate notice requirements; record every date and let the attorney apply the rules[2].
- Video, 911 audio and jail records can be overwritten under agency retention schedules, so evidence questions belong on the first call.
- Ask early whether the caller has an open criminal case and who represents them.
Why this intake is different from an ordinary injury call
A police misconduct call looks like a personal injury call at first: someone was hurt, someone else was responsible. Three things make it harder. The defendant is usually a government body or its employees, which brings notice rules and immunities that ordinary defendants don't have. The caller may also be a criminal defendant arising from the same incident. And the best evidence is often held by the agency being accused.
Volume is real. The Bureau of Justice Statistics reports that about 19% of US residents aged 16 or older, 49.2 million people, had contact with police in 2022[1]. Most of those contacts are routine. The small fraction that go wrong generate calls that are emotional, time-sensitive and easy to mishandle on the phone.
The legal basis for most federal claims is 42 U.S.C. 1983, which makes every person acting under color of state law liable for depriving someone of rights secured by the Constitution and federal law[3]. Intake staff do not need to analyze that statute. They need to collect the facts that let an attorney do so quickly.
Two or more clocks, captured separately
Section 1983 has no limitation period of its own. The Supreme Court held in Owens v. Okure that courts considering these claims should borrow the state's general or residual statute for personal injury actions[2]. State-law claims against a city or county, such as battery or negligence, may have a different and much shorter notice requirement. A pending criminal case adds its own dates. Your form should keep each clock in its own field rather than one box marked deadline.
| Clock | What usually starts it | What intake records |
|---|---|---|
| Federal civil rights claim | The date of the incident or the date the injury was known | Exact incident date, time and place; date of any later discovery |
| State-law claim against a public body | The incident, under state or local notice rules | Which agency, city or county; whether any notice or claim form has been filed and when |
| Open criminal case | Arrest, charging and court dates | Case number, court, next hearing date, defense attorney's name |
| Internal or civilian complaint | The agency's own complaint process | Whether a complaint was filed, when, and any reference number |
Staff never say you still have time or it's too late. They say: I've recorded those dates for the attorney, who will review the timing with you.
Evidence that disappears first
Agencies keep recordings and logs for limited periods under their own retention schedules, which vary widely. Bystander videos get deleted, phones get replaced and witnesses move. Ask about every item below on the first call, and record who has it now.
- Body-worn camera or dash camera footage: did officers appear to be recording? Which agency and which officers, by name or badge number if known?
- 911 and dispatch audio: who called police, and roughly when?
- Bystander or doorbell video: who recorded, and do they still have it? Get contact details.
- Photos of injuries: taken when, by whom? Ask the caller to keep taking dated photos while injuries are visible.
- Medical records: which emergency room, clinic or jail medical unit treated the caller, and on what dates?
- Booking and jail records: was the caller booked? Where, and for how long?
- Clothing and property: anything torn, bloodied or damaged should be kept as it is.
- Witnesses: names, phone numbers and what each one saw.
Whether to send preservation letters, and to whom, is an attorney decision. Intake's job is to make that decision possible within a day of the call by having the agency names, dates and locations already in the file.
A structured script for the incident
- Before details: Are you safe right now? Are you currently in custody, on bond or on probation?
- Criminal case: Were you arrested or charged because of this incident? Do you have a defense lawyer, and what is their name?
- When and where: What date and time did this happen, and at what address or intersection?
- Who: Which department or agency? Do you know any officer names or badge numbers? How many officers were there?
- What happened: In your own words, what did the officers do? Let the caller speak, then summarize back in a sentence.
- Injuries: Were you hurt? Did you get medical care, where and when?
- Evidence: Do you know of any video, photos or witnesses? Who has them now?
- Prior steps: Have you filed a complaint with the agency, a claim with the city, or talked to another lawyer?
- Close: The attorney will review this. Please keep any photos, video, clothing and paperwork exactly as they are.
Use neutral words in the notes. Write what the caller reports, attributed to them, rather than conclusions such as officer assaulted client. The notes may be read by others later, and the attorney needs to see the caller's account separated from staff interpretation.
When the caller has an open criminal case
Many callers were arrested during the encounter they want to complain about. Anything they say about the facts can matter in the criminal case. Record whether they have defense counsel and the next court date, keep the factual narrative short, and flag the file so the attorney can decide how to coordinate with the defense lawyer before a detailed interview. Staff should not suggest that the civil claim will help the criminal case or the reverse.
If the caller is calling from a jail phone, assume the call may be recorded and keep to scheduling and contact details. Offer a legal visit or attorney call instead of taking the full story on that line.
Expect skepticism, and earn the second conversation
People who feel mistreated by the state often doubt that the legal system will help them. The Legal Services Corporation found that higher-income Americans are more likely than low-income Americans to believe they can use the civil legal system to protect their rights, 59% versus 39%[4].
Source: Legal Services Corporation, 2022[4]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Higher-income Americans | 59% |
| Low-income Americans | 39% |
Reliability on small promises builds trust. Say exactly when the attorney will call and from which number, then do it. Eight in ten Americans say they don't generally answer calls from unknown numbers[5], so tell the caller the number to expect and leave a clear voicemail if they don't pick up.
Example: a traffic stop that ended at the emergency room
Example (fictional): A woman calls on a Monday about a traffic stop the previous Friday night. She says she was pulled from her car and taken to the ground, and she was treated for a wrist fracture at a county hospital. She was charged with resisting and released on bond, and her public defender's name is on her paperwork.
The intake specialist records the incident date, time and intersection, the police department, the hospital and the treatment date, the criminal case number, the next court date and the public defender's name. A neighbor's doorbell camera faces the intersection; the specialist records the neighbor's address. She asks the caller to keep her clothing and photograph her wrist daily. The file is flagged for same-day attorney review because doorbell systems often overwrite footage and a court date is ten days away. She takes no detailed account of what the caller said to officers.
Screening outcomes and decline letters
- Attorney review today: recent incident, serious injury, video at risk, or an approaching court date.
- Attorney review within one business day: older incidents with documents already in hand.
- Refer out: matters outside the firm's practice, such as prison conditions cases if the firm does not handle them, with a referral list ready.
- Decline: in writing, without opinions on the merits, stating that time limits may apply and that the person should speak to another lawyer promptly.
Log every outcome with a reason code, such as outside practice area, no injury reported, defendant not a government actor, or caller chose another firm. Reviewed monthly, these codes show whether marketing is attracting the right cases and whether staff are applying the routing rules consistently. They also help the attorney spot cases that were declined too quickly, which matters in a practice where a single strong case can be worth many weaker inquiries.
Because many civil rights firms work on contingency, it helps to align these routing rules with the fee-model qualification logic the firm already uses. Firms with an education practice will also see overlap with special education intake, for example when a student is restrained or arrested at school.
Frequently asked questions
Should intake staff tell callers to file a complaint with the police department?
No. Whether and when to file an internal complaint, a notice of claim or anything else is a strategic decision for the attorney. Staff should record whether anything has already been filed.
Can we take the call if the person is still in custody?
Yes, but keep it to identity, contact details, the facility, the criminal case number and how to reach family. Arrange a legal visit or protected attorney call for the substance.
What if the caller doesn't know which agency was involved?
Record the location, the uniform or vehicle description and any paperwork they received. The attorney or an investigator can usually identify the agency from those details.
Do we need different questions for jail injury cases?
Add questions about the facility, the housing unit, medical requests made and refused, and grievances filed, with dates. Keep the same separation of clocks.
References
Bureau of Justice Statistics (2024). Contacts Between Police and the Public, 2022 (opens in a new tab) โ
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (1989). Owens v. Okure, 488 U.S. 235 (1989) (opens in a new tab) โ
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 42 U.S. Code ยง 1983 - Civil action for deprivation of rights (opens in a new tab) โ
Legal Services Corporation (2022). The Justice Gap Report: Executive Summary (opens in a new tab) โ
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) โ