Client Intake

How to Audit Your Law Firm's Intake in One Week

A five-day intake audit for law firms: data pulls, test calls and forms, a review scan, staff interviews and a one-page findings report.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing6 min read

On this page
  1. What the audit answers
  2. The five-day plan
  3. Monday: what to pull and what it tells you
  4. Tuesday and Wednesday: why callbacks matter as much as live answers
  5. Thursday: interview questions
  6. Checking reviews and reputation
  7. Reading the results: common patterns
  8. Friday: the one-page report
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References
Client Intake: How to Audit Your Law Firm's Intake in One WeekArticle coverCLIENT INTAKEHow to Audit Your LawFirm's Intake in OneWeekAva for LawyersInsightsClient Intake: How to Audit Your Law Firm's Intake in One WeekArticle coverCLIENT INTAKEHow to Audit Your LawFirm's Intake in OneWeekAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • Spend Monday on data, Tuesday and Wednesday on test contacts, Thursday on staff interviews and Friday on a one-page report with three fixes.
  • Test callbacks as well as live answers: 67% of Americans let unknown numbers ring through and check the voicemail instead[1].
  • Scan reviews for access complaints, but never offer incentives for reviews, which the FTC's rule prohibits[2].
  • Measure time between steps, not just whether each step happened.

What the audit answers

An intake audit answers three questions with evidence rather than opinion. How quickly does a new inquiry get a real response on each channel? What happens to it between first contact and a signed engagement or a written decline? And where do inquiries get stuck or lost? You do not need software or a consultant to answer them. You need a week, access to the phone system and inbox, a spreadsheet, and one person with the authority to ask awkward questions.

Pick an auditor who does not run intake day to day: a partner, an office manager from another team, or a trusted outside contact. The person who owns the process will find it hard to see its gaps, and staff speak more freely to someone who is not their direct supervisor.

  • Tell staff an audit is happening this week and why. The aim is to fix the process, not to catch individuals.
  • Do not change anything during the audit week. You want a baseline.
  • Agree in advance who sees the findings and when.

The five-day plan

  1. Monday: pull the data

    Export the last 60 days of call logs, voicemail records, web form submissions, intake emails and consultation bookings. Put them in one sheet with a row per inquiry and columns for channel, time received, time of first human response, consult date, outcome and source. Where data is missing, note it; a missing timestamp is itself a finding.

  2. Tuesday: test the phones

    Make six test calls at different times: mid-morning, lunch, late afternoon, just after closing, early evening and a weekend morning. Use a plausible fictional scenario for each of your main practice areas. Record whether a person answered, how many rings, what was asked, whether you were offered a time, and how long any callback took.

  3. Wednesday: test every other channel

    Submit three web forms, send two emails to the published address, try the website chat if you have one, and leave two voicemails asking for a callback. Track the first reply time and what each reply said. Check whether a form confirmation arrives and whether it tells the person what happens next.

  4. Thursday: interview the people

    Spend 20 to 30 minutes with each person who touches intake: receptionists, coordinators, paralegals and at least two attorneys. Use the same questions with everyone so answers can be compared.

  5. Friday: write the findings

    Turn the week into a one-page report with the baseline numbers, the five worst moments a prospect experienced, and three fixes ranked by effort and impact. Present it to the partners the following Monday.

Monday: what to pull and what it tells you

Monday data pull. If a source cannot be exported, record that as a finding.
DataWhere it livesWhat it tells you
Call log with missed and abandoned callsPhone system or carrier portalWhen callers fail to reach a person and whether the pattern clusters by hour or day
Voicemail timestamps and callback timesVoicemail system, call logReal callback speed, as opposed to the policy
Form submissions with first-reply timeWebsite form inbox, CRMSpeed and consistency of written replies
Consultation bookingsCalendar, practice management systemDays from first contact to consult, and no-show rate
Engagement letters sent and signedDocument system, e-sign platformWhere the loop closes or stalls after the consult
Lead source fieldIntake notes, CRMWhether source is captured at all

Calculate four baseline numbers from the sheet: share of office-hours calls answered live, median callback time for voicemails, median first-reply time for forms and emails, and median days from first contact to consultation. Those four numbers will be the yardstick for every change you make afterwards.

Tuesday and Wednesday: why callbacks matter as much as live answers

A firm that misses a call has a second chance only if the callback works, and phone habits make that harder than it sounds. Pew found that only 19% of US adults generally answer calls from unknown numbers, while 67% let them go and check any voicemail left[3][1]. A callback with no voicemail, or with a vague one, often gets nowhere.

What US adults say they usually do when an unknown number calls
What US adults say they usually do when an unknown number callsBar chart. Do not answer, but check the voicemail if one is left: 67%; Generally answer: 19%; Ignore any voicemail left: 14%.Do not answer, but check the voicemail if one is leftDo not answer, but check the voicemail if one is left: 67%67%Generally answerGenerally answer: 19%19%Ignore any voicemail leftIgnore any voicemail left: 14%14%What US adults say they usually do when an unknown number callsBar chart. Do not answer, but check the voicemail if one is left: 67%; Generally answer: 19%; Ignore any voicemail left: 14%.Do not answer, but check the voicemailif one is leftDo not answer, but check the voicemail if one is left: 67%67%Generally answerGenerally answer: 19%19%Ignore any voicemail leftIgnore any voicemail left: 14%14%

Source: Pew Research Center, 2020[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Do not answer, but check the voicemail if one is left67%
Generally answer19%
Ignore any voicemail left14%

So when you leave test voicemails, judge the callback on three things: did it come on the same business day, did the caller leave a clear voicemail with the firm's name and a reason to call back, and was there a written follow-up by email or form reply. Only 14% of Americans say they generally ignore voicemails[4], so a good message is worth the effort.

Compare your own results with a published benchmark. In a 2024 secret-shopper study of 500 US firms, 48% neither answered the phone nor returned the call[5]. If your test calls beat that easily, look harder at speed and quality instead.

Thursday: interview questions

  1. Walk me through what you do when a new caller reaches you. What do you ask first?
  2. What do you do when you cannot take a call or a form arrives while you are busy?
  3. Who decides whether a new matter is urgent, and how do you reach them?
  4. What information do attorneys most often ask you for that you did not collect?
  5. When do you run the conflict check, and what names do you collect for it?
  6. What happens to an inquiry the firm decides not to take?
  7. What part of intake would you change first if you could?

Ask attorneys a shorter version: what they know before a first consult, how often they repeat questions intake already asked, and how long after the consult the engagement letter goes out. Listen for disagreements between what staff say happens and what attorneys say happens; the gap is often the most useful finding of the week.

Keep the interviews about process. If a person admits to skipping a step because they are overloaded, the finding is the overload.

Checking reviews and reputation

Add a short review scan to Wednesday afternoon. Most US adults at least sometimes read online reviews before a first purchase[6], and reviews about access describe intake directly. Search your profiles for phrases such as "call back", "voicemail", "couldn't reach" and "never heard". Note dates and channels.

Do not use the audit as a reason to solicit reviews with incentives. The FTC rule prohibits compensation or other incentives conditioned on writing consumer reviews[2]. Ask satisfied clients through your normal process, without strings.

Reading the results: common patterns

  • Good live answers, slow callbacks. The firm staffs the phone well but nobody owns voicemail. Fix: a named callback owner and a same-day rule.
  • Fast replies, long waits to consult. Staff respond quickly but the earliest consult slot is a week out. Fix: hold back a few short consultation slots each week for new matters.
  • Different questions from different people. Two staff members collect different fields for similar matters. Fix: one written question set per practice area.
  • Clean data for calls, none for forms. The phone system reports well, but form replies have no timestamp. Fix: route forms to a shared inbox that records first reply.
  • Strong daytime, empty evenings. Test calls after closing reach voicemail with no clear message. Fix: an after-hours greeting that tells callers exactly when they will hear back, or overflow coverage.

Friday: the one-page report

  • Baseline: the four numbers from Monday, plus test-call and test-form results.
  • Five moments: short, specific descriptions of the worst experiences a prospect had during the week, without naming staff.
  • Root causes: for each moment, the process gap behind it (no owner, no script, no backup, missing data).
  • Three fixes: one you can do this week, one this month, one this quarter, each with an owner.
  • Re-audit date: the same tests in 30 days.

Example: A fictional six-lawyer firm found that four of six test calls reached a person, but the two after-hours voicemails got callbacks the next afternoon with no message left. Forms got a reply in a median of 19 hours. The quick fix was a voicemail script and same-day callback rule; the monthly fix was a shared intake inbox; the quarterly fix was overflow coverage for evenings.

Intake staff should collect facts, not offer views on the merits. If a test call shows staff telling callers whether they have a case, add that to the findings; Florida's guidance on nonlawyer intake limits questions to facts and refers legal questions to a lawyer[7]. For the next step after the audit, see writing an intake policy manual.

Frequently asked questions

How long does an intake audit take?

A useful baseline audit fits in one working week: one day of data, two days of test contacts, one day of interviews and one day to write a short report.

Who should run the audit?

Someone who does not run intake every day, such as a partner or an office manager from another team, with authority to ask questions and access to the phone and inbox data.

Should staff know the audit is happening?

Yes. Tell them the purpose is to fix the process. Test calls still show the real experience, and interviews are more honest when nobody feels ambushed.

What should we measure after the audit?

Repeat the four baseline numbers monthly: live-answer rate, callback time, first written reply time and days to consultation.

References

  1. Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. Federal Trade Commission (2024). Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  5. Illinois Supreme Court Commission on Professionalism (2Civility) (2024). Phone Calls Ignored, Emails Unanswered: Fixing the First Impression Problem for Law Firms (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  6. Pew Research Center (2016). Online reviews and ratings (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  7. The Florida Bar (2024). Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo