Phones and Call Handling

How to Answer the Phone at a Law Firm

How to answer the phone at a law firm: greeting wording that works, the first thirty seconds step by step and how to route each type of caller.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Who actually answers law firm phones
  2. Greeting wording that works
  3. The first thirty seconds, step by step
  4. Routing each type of caller
  5. Wording for the moments that go wrong
  6. When you can't give the call your full attention
  7. Example: the first thirty seconds in practice
  8. Practice until it is automatic
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References
Phones and Call Handling: How to Answer the Phone at a Law FirmArticle coverPHONES AND CALL HANDLINGHow to Answer the Phoneat a Law FirmAva for LawyersInsightsPhones and Call Handling: How to Answer the Phone at a Law FirmArticle coverPHONES AND CALL HANDLINGHow to Answer thePhone at a Law FirmAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • In US legal services, receptionists are a small share of staff; paralegals, secretaries and attorneys answer many calls, so the greeting must work for anyone[1].
  • Use a short greeting: time of day, firm name, your first name and an offer of help. Leave out slogans.
  • In the first thirty seconds, find out who the caller is, whether they are new or existing, and whether anything is urgent.
  • Before taking facts, nonlawyers say they are not attorneys and check whether the caller already has a lawyer on the matter[2].

Who actually answers law firm phones

Picture the person answering your firm's phone and you probably picture a receptionist. The occupational data say otherwise. In May 2023, US legal services employers had 445,110 lawyers, 273,590 paralegals and legal assistants, 124,060 legal secretaries and administrative assistants, 28,470 general office clerks and 25,530 receptionists and information clerks[1]. Receptionists were a small slice of the workforce.

Employment in US legal services by occupation, May 2023
Employment in US legal services by occupation, May 2023Bar chart. Lawyers: 445,110; Paralegals and legal assistants: 273,590; Legal secretaries and administrative assistants: 124,060; General office clerks: 28,470; Receptionists and information clerks: 25,530.LawyersLawyers: 445,110445,110Paralegals and legal assistantsParalegals and legal assistants: 273,590273,590Legal secretaries and administrative assistantsLegal secretaries and administrative assistants: 124,060124,060General office clerksGeneral office clerks: 28,47028,470Receptionists and information clerksReceptionists and information clerks: 25,53025,530Employment in US legal services by occupation, May 2023Bar chart. Lawyers: 445,110; Paralegals and legal assistants: 273,590; Legal secretaries and administrative assistants: 124,060; General office clerks: 28,470; Receptionists and information clerks: 25,530.LawyersLawyers: 445,110445,110Paralegals and legal assistantsParalegals and legal assistants: 273,590273,590Legal secretaries and administrativeassistantsLegal secretaries and administrative assistants: 124,060124,060General office clerksGeneral office clerks: 28,47028,470Receptionists and information clerksReceptionists and information clerks: 25,53025,530

Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2023[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Lawyers445,110
Paralegals and legal assistants273,590
Legal secretaries and administrative assistants124,060
General office clerks28,470
Receptionists and information clerks25,530

Firm size explains part of it. Census data show 71.8% of US law offices had fewer than five employees in 2023[3]. In those offices, the person who answers might be the paralegal, the office manager or the attorney. A greeting and first-thirty-seconds routine that anyone can follow is worth more than a polished script only one person knows.

Greeting wording that works

A good greeting does four things in about five seconds: confirms the caller reached the right place, tells them who they are speaking to, sounds human and invites them to talk. Anything more delays the caller's first sentence, which is the part that matters.

Greeting options by situation; Marsh & Cole is a fictional firm
SituationGreetingWhy it works
Main line, business hours"Good morning, Marsh & Cole, this is Nina. How can I help?"Firm name first, first name, open question
Practice-specific line"Marsh & Cole injury team, this is Nina. How can I help?"Confirms the caller picked the right line
Attorney's direct line"Dana Cole's office, this is Nina."Signals the caller reached the attorney's team
Attorney answering own mobile"Dana Cole, Marsh & Cole."Short, professional, no personal greeting
After hours, live answer"Marsh & Cole, this is Nina. Our office is closed, but I can take your details."Sets expectations immediately

Leave out taglines ("where justice comes first"), long welcomes and anything that sounds recorded. Say the firm name the way clients say it; if everyone calls you "Marsh" rather than "Marsh, Cole and Associates, PLLC", the short form is fine on the phone.

Smile while you say it; callers can hear it. And answer within three rings. A greeting delivered after six rings has already lost some of its warmth.

The first thirty seconds, step by step

After the greeting, the next half-minute decides where the call goes. The goal is not to start intake. It is to sort the call correctly so the caller ends up with the right person or the right next step.

  1. Let them speak first

    After your greeting, wait. Most callers will explain why they called in one or two sentences. Do not interrupt to ask for their name.

  2. Get the name and a number

    "May I have your name, and the best number in case we get cut off?" Ask for the number early; mobile calls drop.

  3. New or existing

    "Have you worked with our firm before, or is this a new matter?" This one question decides most routing.

  4. Check for urgency

    "Is there a court date, deadline or anything happening in the next few days?" Urgent calls follow the escalation rule straight away.

  5. State your role before facts

    For new matters, nonlawyers say: "I'm not an attorney, but I'll take the details so an attorney can review them."

  6. Route or begin intake

    Transfer, take a message or start the intake questions, and tell the caller which you are doing.

The role statement follows guidance Florida's Bar draws from its Ethics Opinion 88-6: nonlawyers conducting intake identify their nonlawyer status, limit questions to facts, give no legal advice and refer legal questions to the lawyer[2]. Florida's 2024 opinion also suggests screening whether the person is already represented by another lawyer[2]. Add that question early in new-matter calls.

Routing each type of caller

Most calls fall into a handful of types. Decide in advance what happens to each so nobody improvises.

  • New prospective client: role statement, represented check, then intake or a booked consultation. Never put them on a long hold to find an attorney.
  • Existing client: verify identity with two details, then route to the assigned team member or take a detailed message with a callback window.
  • Court clerk or judge's chambers: put through to the attorney or their assistant immediately, or interrupt if needed. Never leave the court waiting.
  • Opposing counsel: take name, firm, matter and purpose; route to the responsible attorney's assistant. Do not discuss the matter.
  • Referral source or another lawyer: treat like a priority client call; they are often the source of your best matters.
  • Vendors and sales calls: take a name and email and offer to pass it on; do not transfer to attorneys.

Write the routing list on a single page beside every phone and in the phone app's notes, with the extension or name for each type. New staff should be able to route correctly on their first day.

Wording for the moments that go wrong

Three situations trip up people who answer phones infrequently. Prepare a line for each.

The caller asks for an attorney by name and won't explain why: "Of course. She's with a client right now. So I can get her the right file before she calls you back, can you tell me if this is about an existing matter or something new?"

The caller starts telling their story before you have their name: "I want to hear all of this, and I'll write it down. Before you go on, may I get your name and number in case the call drops?"

The caller asks what it will cost: "The attorney can explain fees at the consultation, and it depends on the matter. What I can do now is get you booked so you can ask her directly."

Callers of every age still pick up the phone for something important. In Pew's smartphone study, 93% of owners aged 18 to 29 used voice or video calling during the study period[4]. A younger caller who phones rather than emails is often signaling that the matter feels urgent to them.

When you can't give the call your full attention

Sometimes the phone rings while you are mid-task: a client at the counter, another line blinking, a filing due in ten minutes. Answering distracted is worse than a short, honest pause, because the caller hears it and their first impression of the firm is someone typing while they talk.

  • If a visitor is at the counter, answer, greet, and ask the caller for permission to hold for a moment: "May I put you on a brief hold while I finish with someone here?"
  • If a second line rings during a call, let it go to overflow or the next person rather than putting a caller mid-story on hold.
  • If you cannot focus because of a deadline, ask a colleague to take the phones for that window before it starts, not after the third missed call.
  • Close other screens before taking intake details, so you are not tempted to multitask while the caller describes something painful.

Full attention is also the best defense against errors that cause trouble later: a misheard surname that defeats the conflict check, a wrong callback number, a deadline written down as the wrong day. The first thirty seconds set the quality of everything that follows in the file.

Example: the first thirty seconds in practice

Example (fictional): the office manager answers on the second ring. "Good afternoon, Marsh & Cole, this is Nina. How can I help?" The caller says his mother was hurt in a fall at a grocery store last week. Nina asks for his name and number, then whether the family has worked with the firm before. They have not. She asks whether anything is happening soon; he mentions the store's insurer has asked his mother for a recorded statement on Friday.

Example (fictional), the routing: Nina says she is not an attorney and asks whether his mother has spoken to any other lawyer about the fall. She has not. Because of the Friday statement, Nina follows the urgent rule, books a same-day call with the intake attorney and tells the caller exactly when to expect it. The whole sort took under a minute; intake happened on the attorney's call.

Practice until it is automatic

  1. Print the greeting table and routing list and keep them at every desk and in the phone app.
  2. Role-play five call types with each new hire before they take live calls.
  3. Have anyone who answers only occasionally, including attorneys, practice the first thirty seconds once a quarter.
  4. Listen to two recorded calls per person each month and check the greeting, the four sorting questions and the role statement.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best way to answer the phone at a law firm?

Greet with the time of day, the firm name and your first name, then offer help: "Good morning, Marsh & Cole, this is Nina. How can I help?"

Should staff say they are not attorneys?

Yes, before taking facts about a new matter. It is part of the nonlawyer intake standard Florida's Bar describes[2].

What should I ask in the first thirty seconds?

The caller's name and number, whether they are new or existing, and whether there is a court date or deadline soon.

How should I handle a call from a court clerk?

Put it through to the attorney or their assistant right away, interrupting if needed.

References

  1. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2023). May 2023 National Industry-Specific Occupational Employment and Wage Estimates: NAICS 541100 - Legal Services (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. The Florida Bar (2024). Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. U.S. Census Bureau (2023). County Business Patterns 2023: U.S. detail file (cbp23us) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. Pew Research Center (2015). U.S. Smartphone Use in 2015 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo