Key takeaways
- Start with two facts: the petitioner's status (citizen or permanent resident) and the exact relationship. Together they decide which category applies.
- Spouses, unmarried minor children and parents of adult US citizens are immediate relatives and are not subject to the annual numerical limits[1].
- Preference categories are capped by statute, from 23,400 visas a year for some categories to 114,200 for spouses and children of permanent residents[2].
- Send a short document list before the consultation and a longer one after engagement; asking for everything up front makes people cancel.
- Screen for prior removals, unlawful entries, criminal history and prior marriages at intake, then leave the analysis to the attorney.
What this checklist is for
Family-based cases look simple on the phone. A caller says they want to bring a spouse or parent to the United States, or help a relative who is already here get a green card. Whether that takes months or many years, and whether it is possible at all, depends on facts the caller may not think to mention. A good consultation checklist gets those facts in front of the attorney before the meeting so the time is spent on advice, not on discovering that the petitioner is a permanent resident rather than a citizen.
The list below is written for intake staff and paralegals preparing a consultation. It does not decide eligibility. Every item that suggests a problem becomes a flag for the attorney, not a conclusion for the caller.
Step one: the petitioner and the relationship
The first two questions are who will file and how they are related to the person who wants status. Under federal law, immediate relatives are the children, spouses and parents of a US citizen, and a citizen must be at least 21 to petition for a parent[1]. Immediate relatives are not counted against the annual family preference limits[1]. Everyone else falls into a preference category with a statutory cap.
The family-sponsored worldwide level starts from 480,000 and is adjusted each year, but it can never fall below 226,000[1]. Within that, the statute sets the preference caps shown above[2]. For intake, the lesson is that the category drives the timeline, so record the relationship exactly: married or unmarried, over or under 21, half-sibling or full sibling, stepchild and the date of the marriage that created the step relationship.
Eligibility questions to ask before the consultation
| Topic | Ask the petitioner | Ask about the beneficiary | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|---|
| Status | Are you a citizen or a permanent resident? How did you get it, and when? | What is their current status, if they are in the US? | Sets the category and whether adjustment inside the US may be an option |
| Relationship | Date of marriage or birth; any prior marriages for either spouse | Age today and marital status | Category, and whether age-outs or marriages change it |
| Location | Where do you live? | Are they in the US or abroad? Which country? | Consular processing or adjustment, and which forms follow |
| Entry history | Did you ever file for anyone before? | How and when did they last enter? Any visa overstays? | Admissibility and bars the attorney must review |
| Immigration history | Any past petitions withdrawn or denied? | Any prior removal order, deportation or voluntary departure? | Prior orders can block or delay the case |
| Criminal history | Any arrests, anywhere? | Any arrests or convictions in any country? | Admissibility review needs certified records |
| Support | Rough household size and whether you file tax returns | Will anyone else help support them? | Financial sponsorship requirements |
Script for sensitive questions: These questions are routine. The attorney asks everyone about past immigration problems and arrests because they can change the plan. You don't need to explain anything now; a yes or no is enough.
Red flags that change the consultation
Some answers change how long the consultation should be, which attorney should take it, or whether it needs to happen this week rather than next month. Teach staff to recognize these and mark them clearly at the top of the prep note, without explaining their legal effect to the caller.
- Any prior removal order, deportation or voluntary departure for the beneficiary. These can bar or delay status and the attorney will need the dates and the paperwork.
- Entries without inspection, especially more than one. The attorney will want approximate dates and places for each entry and exit.
- Any arrest anywhere, even if the caller says it was dismissed. Record the country, the year and whether records exist.
- Prior marriages that may not have been legally ended, or a marriage that happened while removal proceedings were pending.
- A beneficiary close to turning 21, or about to marry. Age and marital status changes can move a relative into a different category.
- A petitioner who obtained status through marriage to a previous spouse within the last few years.
- Anything the caller says the beneficiary was told at a consulate or a border, such as a refusal or a ban.
When a flag appears, staff should book the longer consultation slot and ask the caller to bring or upload every paper related to that event. They should not reassure the caller that the issue is minor or warn them that it is serious. Both are legal judgments.
Documents: the short list and the long list
Two lists work better than one. Before the consultation, ask only for what the attorney needs to give an opinion. After the client signs, send the full list with a deadline and a secure upload link.
Short list, before the consultation
Proof of the petitioner's status (passport, naturalization certificate or green card), the beneficiary's passport biographic page, the marriage or birth certificate that proves the relationship, and any immigration notice either person has ever received.
Long list, after engagement
Divorce decrees for every prior marriage, birth certificates for all children, evidence of a genuine marriage for spousal cases, tax returns and pay records for the sponsor, police and court records for any arrest, and translations of anything not in English.
Prepare translations early
Foreign-language documents need full English translations with a translator's certification. Ask which documents are not in English during intake so the firm can quote and schedule translation.
Confirm names match
Ask whether either person has used different names or spellings on documents. Record every version. Mismatches are common and easy to explain when the attorney knows about them early.
Language and scheduling
Family-based consultations often include relatives with different language preferences. About 22% of US residents aged 5 and older speak a language other than English at home, and roughly 61% of them speak Spanish[3]. Ask at intake which language each attendee prefers and whether the firm needs an interpreter, rather than discovering it in the meeting.
Scheduling is usually easier than with other practice areas because nothing is due tomorrow. Many petitioners are working adults: 57% of US workers have a flexible schedule that lets them vary their start and end times[4], but many others do not. Offer at least one early, late or video slot each week so a working petitioner and a relative abroad can both attend.
Example: a spouse and a stepdaughter
Example (fictional). A permanent resident calls about his wife, who lives abroad, and her 19-year-old daughter from a prior marriage. Intake records that he is a permanent resident, not a citizen, that he married the mother when the daughter was 15, that the daughter is unmarried, and that the mother had one prior marriage that ended in divorce. Neither has been to the US. The short list goes out: his green card, both passports, the marriage certificate, the mother's divorce decree and the daughter's birth certificate.
The attorney's prep note now shows the likely category, flags the stepchild relationship and the date it began, and notes that the daughter's age and marital status must be tracked. The consultation starts with advice instead of fact-finding, and the petitioner leaves knowing what to bring next.
A 45-minute consultation agenda
- Confirm identities, relationship and status from the documents received (5 minutes).
- Attorney reviews history flags from intake with the petitioner (10 minutes).
- Attorney explains the category, the general process and what could change it (15 minutes).
- Discuss evidence, sponsorship and what the client must gather (10 minutes).
- Next steps, engagement terms and who on the team will be the contact (5 minutes).
Send a written summary afterward, in the client's preferred language where possible, with the long document list attached if they engaged the firm. If they did not, a short note restating what was discussed protects both sides.
After the consultation: the handoff to the case team
Once the client engages the firm, the intake record becomes the first page of the case file. Before the paralegal starts on forms, check that the record shows the category the attorney chose, the reasons for any flags, the document list sent and its deadline, the preferred language for each family member, and who the client has authorized the firm to speak with. Families often call in for updates through a sibling or adult child, so that authorization line saves the team from guessing later.
Set a first follow-up date for missing documents within two weeks, and schedule a short status call for the client at the same time. Clients who hear from the firm early are more likely to send what is needed on time.
Frequently asked questions
Can staff tell a caller how long their case will take?
No. Timelines depend on category, country and individual history, and an estimate given at intake can be taken as advice. Staff can say the attorney will explain timing at the consultation.
What if the petitioner is a permanent resident who plans to naturalize soon?
Record it. Naturalization can change the category for some relatives, and the attorney will want to consider timing when advising.
Do we need originals before the consultation?
Usually not. Clear photos or scans are enough for the attorney to review. Originals or certified copies matter later, when the firm prepares filings.
Should both the petitioner and the relative attend?
Where possible, yes, by video if the relative is abroad. Both have facts the attorney needs, and both may have questions. Confirm languages first.
References
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 8 U.S. Code 1151 - Worldwide level of immigration (opens in a new tab) โ
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 8 U.S. Code 1153 - Allocation of immigrant visas (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Census Bureau (2025). New Data on Detailed Languages Spoken at Home and the Ability to Speak English (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Job Flexibilities and Work Schedules (2024-25 data) (opens in a new tab) โ