Client Intake

Email Templates for New Legal Inquiries

Six email templates for new legal inquiries: first reply, scheduling, missing details, follow-up, after-hours acknowledgment and a polite decline.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing6 min read

On this page
  1. Why email replies deserve templates
  2. Rules that apply to every template
  3. Template 1: first reply
  4. Template 2: offering consultation times
  5. Template 3: asking for missing information
  6. Template 4: follow-up when there is no reply
  7. Template 5: after-hours acknowledgment
  8. Template 6: polite decline with a referral
  9. When to send each one
  10. Example: one inquiry, three emails
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References
Client Intake: Email Templates for New Legal InquiriesArticle coverCLIENT INTAKEEmail Templates for NewLegal InquiriesAva for LawyersInsightsClient Intake: Email Templates for New Legal InquiriesArticle coverCLIENT INTAKEEmail Templates forNew Legal InquiriesAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • Only a third of US firms replied to a prospective client's email in a 2024 secret-shopper study, so a fast, specific reply already sets you apart[1].
  • Every template ends with one clear next step: a time to choose, a question to answer or a referral to use.
  • Keep first replies factual and short; ask for names for the conflict check before inviting a detailed story.
  • Mention cost early in plain words: 46% of low-income Americans who did not seek legal help cited cost concerns[2].

Why email replies deserve templates

Email is where intake often goes quiet. A form submission or message lands in a shared inbox, someone means to answer after the next meeting, and by the following day the prospect has hired someone else. In Clio's 2024 Legal Trends secret-shopper study, summarized by the Illinois Supreme Court Commission on Professionalism, just 33% of the 500 US firms contacted responded to the emails, down from 40% in 2019[1].

Share of US law firms that replied to a secret-shopper email
Share of US law firms that replied to a secret-shopper emailComparison. 2019: 40%; 2024: 33%.40%20192019: 40%33%20242024: 33%Share of US law firms that replied to a secret-shopper emailComparison. 2019: 40%; 2024: 33%.40%20192019: 40%33%20242024: 33%

Source: Illinois Supreme Court Commission on Professionalism (2Civility), 2024[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
201940%
202433%

Templates fix two problems at once. They remove the blank-page delay, because the reply is mostly written, and they keep replies inside the firm's boundaries, because the wording has been approved in advance. Personalize the first line and the specific details every time; a reply that reads like a form letter undermines the speed you gained.

Rules that apply to every template

  • Reply from a named person, with a direct phone number, not a no-reply address.
  • Use the prospect's own words for their issue in the first line, so they know a person read the message.
  • One next step per email. If you need two things, ask for the more important one first.
  • No opinions on the merits. Florida Ethics Opinion 88-6 says nonlawyers handling intake should limit questions to factual information and refer legal questions to the lawyer[3]; the same discipline belongs in writing.
  • Keep detail out of email until conflicts clear. Ask for names of other parties, not the full story.
  • Short: under 150 words for a first reply. People read these on a phone.

The detail rule matters because a prospective client's information is protected even if they never hire you. California's Rule 1.18, for example, says a lawyer who has communicated with a prospective client must not use or reveal information learned in the consultation, even when no lawyer-client relationship follows[4]. Collecting less before the conflict check protects the firm and the prospect.

Template 1: first reply

Subject: Your message to [Firm] about [their words]. Hi [First name], thank you for contacting [Firm] about [their words]. I'm [Name], and I help new clients get started. To check that we can help, I need two things: the names of anyone else involved (for example, the other driver, your employer or your spouse), and a good number and time to reach you today. Once I have those, I can offer you a consultation time with [Attorney]. You can reply here or call me directly at [number]. [Name], [title], [Firm]

Send within your same-day target, faster if the message mentions a deadline. If the message names an emergency or a court date this week, skip the email and call immediately, then send this as a written follow-up.

Template 2: offering consultation times

Subject: Consultation times with [Attorney]. Hi [First name], thanks for sending those details. [Attorney] can meet with you by [video / phone / in person] at either of these times: [Day, date, time] or [Day, date, time]. The consultation lasts about [length]. [One plain sentence on how the firm handles the consultation fee, approved by the firm.] Reply with the time that suits you and I'll send a calendar invitation with everything you need. If neither works, tell me your best times this week.

Offer two specific times, not a link to a calendar alone. A choice between two options is easier to answer than an open question, and it keeps a person in the loop for matters that need screening first.

Do not leave out the cost sentence. Among low-income Americans who did not seek legal help for a problem, 46% cited concerns about cost[2]. A prospect who does not know whether the first meeting is free, paid or credited toward a later fee may simply not reply. One approved sentence, such as how the consultation is charged and that the attorney will explain fees for the matter itself, removes the doubt without turning intake into a quote.

Template 3: asking for missing information

Subject: One quick question before we book. Hi [First name], before I can confirm a consultation I need [the one missing item, e.g. the county where this happened / the date of the hearing / the name of the company involved]. This helps us make sure we're the right firm and that [Attorney] is prepared. A short reply is fine. Thank you.

Ask for one thing. A list of five questions by email looks like homework and gets put off. If you need a document, say exactly which one and offer a simple way to send it.

Template 4: follow-up when there is no reply

Subject: Checking in about [their words]. Hi [First name], I wanted to follow up on your message about [their words]. If you'd still like to talk with [Attorney], the earliest times available are [time] and [time]. If you've found help elsewhere or this is no longer needed, no reply is necessary, and I wish you the best. [Name], [direct number]

Send one follow-up after two business days and a final one after a week, then close the record with a note. Silence is not a decline, but repeated chasing is not service either.

Template 5: after-hours acknowledgment

Subject: We received your message. Thank you for contacting [Firm]. Our office is closed now, and a member of our team will reply by [specific time, e.g. 10 am on the next business day]. If you are in danger, call 911. If you have a court deadline in the next 24 hours, call [after-hours number if you have one]. Please don't send detailed information about your matter by email until we have spoken.

This is the one template that can go out automatically. Give a real time, not "as soon as possible", and then meet it.

Template 6: polite decline with a referral

Subject: About your inquiry to [Firm]. Hi [First name], thank you for reaching out about [their words]. After reviewing the information you provided, we are not able to take on this matter. This is not a judgment about the merits of your situation. Legal matters can have deadlines, so please contact another lawyer promptly. You may find these resources helpful: [state or local bar lawyer referral service], [legal aid organization, if relevant]. We have not agreed to represent you, and we will not be taking any action on your behalf.

Have an attorney approve the decline wording once, then use it consistently. The final sentence matters: it makes clear the firm is not representing the person. Many callers worry about cost and access, and 53% of low-income Americans do not know whether they could find and afford a lawyer if they needed one[5], so a decline that points somewhere specific is a real service.

When to send each one

A send schedule for intake emails. Put your own targets in the intake manual.
TemplateSend whenTargetSent by
First replyNew form or email arrivesSame business day; within the hour if urgentIntake coordinator
Consultation timesConflict names received and clearSame day as the clearanceIntake coordinator
Missing informationOne fact is needed to route or bookAs soon as the gap is spottedIntake coordinator
Follow-upNo reply after two business days, then after a weekTwo attempts, then closeIntake coordinator
After-hours acknowledgmentMessage arrives outside office hoursAutomaticSystem
Decline with referralAttorney decides not to take the matterWithin one business day of the decisionCoordinator, attorney-approved wording

Example: one inquiry, three emails

Example: At 3:40 pm a fictional prospect writes that her landlord has kept her deposit and is now threatening to sue. The coordinator sends Template 1 at 4:05 pm asking for the landlord's name and a callback time. The prospect replies that evening. The conflict check clears the next morning, and Template 2 offers two consultation times by 10 am. She picks one. No legal advice was given in writing, the firm learned only what it needed, and the whole exchange took less than a day.

For the full policy behind these templates, see writing an intake policy manual, and for form submissions specifically, responding to website contact form leads.

Frequently asked questions

How quickly should a law firm reply to an email inquiry?

Set a target you can meet every day, such as the same business day, and reply faster when the message mentions a deadline. Measure it from the time the email arrived to the first personal reply.

Should the first reply ask for details of the case?

Ask for the names of other parties and a callback time first. Detailed facts can wait until the conflict check clears and an attorney is involved.

Can we send a decline by email?

Yes. Use attorney-approved wording that says the firm is not taking the matter, is not judging the merits, mentions that deadlines may apply and points to specific referral resources.

Can these emails be automated?

Only the after-hours acknowledgment should go out automatically. The others need a person to read the inquiry and personalize the reply.

References

  1. Illinois Supreme Court Commission on Professionalism (2Civility) (2024). Phone Calls Ignored, Emails Unanswered: Fixing the First Impression Problem for Law Firms (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. Legal Services Corporation (2022). The Justice Gap Report: Executive Summary (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. The Florida Bar (2024). Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. The State Bar of California (2026). California Rules of Professional Conduct (2026) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  5. Legal Services Corporation (2022). The Justice Gap Report: Executive Summary (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo