Key takeaways
- Tell the client promptly and personally; Rule 1.4 requires keeping clients informed of significant developments[1].
- Use a fixed structure: warn, state the news plainly, pause, explain what it means, set out the options and agree next steps.
- Never deliver serious bad news by text or voicemail; use a short message to book a call, since only 19% of adults generally answer unknown numbers[2].
- Follow every hard conversation with a short written summary, because people remember little of what they hear in a stressful moment.
Bad news is part of the job
Every practice delivers bad news: a motion lost, an offer lower than hoped, a judge who rules on custody the other way, a conviction, a deadline the case cannot meet. Lawyers often dread these conversations and delay them, soften them until the message disappears, or bury them in an email. Clients notice. How a firm delivers bad news shapes whether the client trusts it for the rest of the case.
Delivered well, bad news can strengthen a relationship. The client sees that the lawyer is honest, present and already thinking about what comes next. That matters in a profession that starts with low public trust: only 20% of Americans rate lawyers' honesty and ethical standards as high or very high[3].
The duty to tell, and to tell promptly
California's Rule 1.4, like the ABA Model Rule, requires a lawyer to keep the client reasonably informed about significant developments and to explain matters to the extent reasonably necessary for the client to make informed decisions[1]. Bad news is almost always significant. California's version also allows a lawyer to delay transmitting information only where the lawyer reasonably believes the client would be likely to react in a way that may cause imminent harm to the client or others[1], a narrow exception rather than a general permission to wait.
Some bad news comes with a decision attached. The decision whether to settle belongs to the client, and in criminal cases so does the decision about a plea, whether to waive a jury and whether to testify[1]. The conversation has to give the client what they need to make that choice.
Choose the channel
| Type of news | Channel | Timing |
|---|---|---|
| Adverse ruling on a major motion | Phone or video call, then written summary | Same day |
| Settlement offer well below expectations | Call or meeting | Within a day, well before any response deadline |
| Conviction, adverse verdict or custody decision | In person at court, then a follow-up meeting | Immediately, and again within days |
| Hearing continued or trial date moved | Call or short email, depending on impact | Same day |
| Case weaker than first thought | Meeting | As soon as the assessment changes |
| Firm error affecting the case | Meeting with the responsible partner | Promptly, after taking appropriate advice |
Reaching the client is part of choosing the channel. Pew Research Center found that only 19% of US adults generally answer calls from unknown numbers, 67% don't answer but check a voicemail, and 14% ignore voicemails altogether[2]. Text messaging is the most widely used smartphone feature[4], so a short text or voicemail that asks the client to call or book a time, without stating the news, is often the right first step.
- Generally answer 19%
- Don't answer, but check voicemail 67%
- Ignore voicemails too 14%
Source: Pew Research Center, 2020[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Generally answer | 19% |
| Don't answer, but check voicemail | 67% |
| Ignore voicemails too | 14% |
Prepare before you call
- Know the news exactly: read the ruling or offer in full, not a summary.
- Decide the one-sentence headline you will say first.
- Work out what it means for the client in practical terms: money, time, family, liberty.
- List the realistic options, with the main advantage and risk of each.
- Check deadlines that affect the options, such as appeal periods or offer expirations.
- Find a private time and place for the client, and ask whether they want anyone with them.
- Have the written summary drafted so it can go out the same day.
A structure for the conversation
Give a warning
Signal that difficult news is coming: I have some news about the motion, and it isn't what we hoped. This gives the client a second to prepare.
State the news plainly
Say it in one or two sentences, in plain words. Do not lead with procedural detail or hide the result in qualifications.
Pause
Stop talking. Let the client react. Silence is uncomfortable for lawyers and necessary for clients.
Acknowledge the reaction
Name what you hear: I can hear how disappointing this is. Do not rush to reassure.
Explain what it means
Once the client is ready, explain the practical effect on their case and their life.
Set out the options
Describe the realistic paths, including doing nothing, with the main trade-offs and any deadlines.
Leave the decision with the client
Give your recommendation if asked or if it helps, and make clear that decisions such as settlement are theirs.
Agree next steps
Say what you will do, what they need to do and when you will speak again.
Scripts for common bad news
Adverse ruling: βI have news on the summary judgment motion, and it isn't good. The judge ruled for the defendant on the main contract claim. β¦ I know this is hard to hear. What it means is that the case can't go to trial on that claim as things stand. There are two realistic options, and I'd like to walk you through both. You don't need to decide today.β
Low settlement offer: βThe insurer has made an offer, and it's lower than we'd hoped. I'll give you the number, then what I think it means and what we can do. β¦ The offer is open for 14 days, so we have time to talk it through properly.β
After a conviction: βI'm so sorry. This is not the outcome we fought for. Right now the most important things are what happens at sentencing and whether there are grounds to appeal. I'll come to see you tomorrow to go through both.β
Handling the reaction
- Anger at the lawyer: listen, do not defend, and return to the facts once the client has finished.
- Silence: wait, then ask a simple question such as what's going through your mind?
- Tears: give time; offer to pause or continue later.
- Denial: restate the news gently and plainly; do not agree that it might not be true.
- Immediate decisions: discourage rushed choices and remind the client of the time available.
What not to do
- Deliver serious bad news by email, text or voicemail.
- Leave the client to discover it from a court website or the other side.
- Blame the judge, the jury or the client in the first conversation.
- Over-reassure with promises about an appeal or a better offer.
- Pile on detail before the client has absorbed the headline.
- End without a next step and a date.
Follow up in writing
- Send a short summary the same day: what happened, what it means, the options and any deadline.
- Attach or link the ruling or offer, with a one-line explanation of where to find the key part.
- Restate the next steps and the date of the next conversation.
- Invite questions in writing as well as by phone.
- Record the conversation and the summary in the file.
Brief the team before the client calls back
After a hard conversation, clients often call the office again within hours, with a question they forgot to ask or simply to hear a voice. If the receptionist or paralegal does not know what happened, the client has to explain it, which is painful, and may get an answer that contradicts the attorney.
- Tell the paralegal and front desk the headline and the agreed next steps as soon as the call ends.
- Agree what staff may say and what must wait for the attorney.
- Flag the matter so any call from the client is put through or returned the same day.
- Add the written summary to the file before the end of the day, so anyone can read it.
When the bad news is the firm's mistake
The hardest conversation is telling a client that something went wrong on the firm's side, such as a missed deadline. Do not delay or disguise it. Get advice first from the firm's ethics counsel or malpractice carrier as your policy requires, then tell the client promptly and honestly, explain what can be done to repair the harm, and tell them they may wish to seek independent advice. Handling this badly turns a recoverable problem into a far larger one.
Example: a lost custody motion
Example (fictional): a father's motion to change a custody schedule was denied. The attorney read the order in full, then texted the client asking whether he was free to talk in the next hour. On the call, she warned him the news was disappointing, gave the result in one sentence and waited. When he was ready, she explained that the existing schedule would stay in place, that the judge had pointed to the lack of evidence about school attendance, and that there were two options: gather that evidence and refile later, or negotiate a modest change with the other parent. She emailed a summary that afternoon. The client was upset, but he stayed with the firm and chose to gather the evidence.
Related guides: managing client expectations about outcomes, client communication during long cases and video updates and explainers for clients.
Frequently asked questions
How should a lawyer deliver bad news to a client?
Promptly and personally, by phone or in person. Warn the client, state the news plainly, pause, explain what it means, set out the options and agree next steps, then follow up in writing.
Can I tell a client bad news by email?
Not for serious news. Use email or text only to arrange a call without revealing the news, and send a written summary after the conversation.
Can a lawyer delay telling a client bad news?
Only in narrow circumstances. California's rule allows delay where the lawyer reasonably believes the client would react in a way that may cause imminent harm. Otherwise, inform the client promptly.
What if the client wants to decide immediately?
Encourage them to take the time available, explain any deadlines, and make sure they understand the options before deciding.
References
The State Bar of California (2026). California Rules of Professional Conduct (2026) (opens in a new tab) β
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) β
Gallup (2025). Nurses Continue to Lead in Honesty and Ethics Ratings (opens in a new tab) β
Pew Research Center (2015). U.S. Smartphone Use in 2015 (opens in a new tab) β