Phones and Call Handling

Call Routing for Multi-Practice Law Firms

Routing rules for law firms with several practice areas: a routing matrix by practice, language and urgency, triage questions, backups and testing.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Why routing gets harder with every practice area
  2. Who is actually there to take routed calls
  3. The four routing signals
  4. Build a routing matrix
  5. Identify the practice area in one question
  6. Language routing
  7. Urgency overrides and the represented-party check
  8. Routing existing clients and professional callers
  9. After-hours routing
  10. Build and test the routing
  11. Example: a firm with three practice groups
  12. Keeping routing current
  13. Frequently asked questions
  14. References
Phones and Call Handling: Call Routing for Multi-Practice Law FirmsArticle coverPHONES AND CALL HANDLINGCall Routing forMulti-Practice LawFirmsAva for LawyersInsightsPhones and Call Handling: Call Routing for Multi-Practice Law FirmsArticle coverPHONES AND CALL HANDLINGCall Routing forMulti-Practice LawFirmsAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • Route on four signals: caller type, practice area, language and urgency. Urgency always overrides the others.
  • Write the rules as a matrix with a backup and a no-answer step for every row, so no route ends in a dead mailbox.
  • Receptionists are scarce in legal services, with roughly 17 lawyers for every receptionist, so most routed calls land on people with other work[1].
  • Spanish is spoken at home by about 61% of US residents who speak a language other than English, making it the first language route most firms need[2].

Why routing gets harder with every practice area

A one-practice firm can send every new call to the same intake person. Add a second practice and someone has to decide where each call goes. Add a third, a Spanish-speaking attorney and an on-call rota, and routing becomes a set of rules that has to work at 9 am on a Monday and at 4:55 pm on a Friday before a holiday weekend.

The goal is simple to state: every caller reaches someone who can move their matter forward, in their language, at the speed their situation needs, without being passed around. The difficulty is that callers rarely describe their problem in the firm's practice-area terms. Nobody calls to say they need help with a premises liability matter; they say they slipped in a grocery store.

Who is actually there to take routed calls

Employment in US legal services by occupation, May 2023
Employment in US legal services by occupation, May 2023Bar chart. Lawyers: 445,110; Paralegals and legal assistants: 273,590; Legal secretaries and administrative assistants: 124,060; General office clerks: 28,470; Receptionists and information clerks: 25,530.LawyersLawyers: 445,110445,110Paralegals and legal assistantsParalegals and legal assistants: 273,590273,590Legal secretaries and administrative assistantsLegal secretaries and administrative assistants: 124,060124,060General office clerksGeneral office clerks: 28,47028,470Receptionists and information clerksReceptionists and information clerks: 25,53025,530Employment in US legal services by occupation, May 2023Bar chart. Lawyers: 445,110; Paralegals and legal assistants: 273,590; Legal secretaries and administrative assistants: 124,060; General office clerks: 28,470; Receptionists and information clerks: 25,530.LawyersLawyers: 445,110445,110Paralegals and legal assistantsParalegals and legal assistants: 273,590273,590Legal secretaries and administrativeassistantsLegal secretaries and administrative assistants: 124,060124,060General office clerksGeneral office clerks: 28,47028,470Receptionists and information clerksReceptionists and information clerks: 25,53025,530

Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2023[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Lawyers445,110
Paralegals and legal assistants273,590
Legal secretaries and administrative assistants124,060
General office clerks28,470
Receptionists and information clerks25,530

In May 2023, US legal services employers had about 445,110 lawyers on payroll but only 25,530 receptionists and information clerks[1], roughly 17 lawyers for every receptionist. Paralegals, legal assistants and legal secretaries far outnumber front-desk staff. In practice, most routed calls land on someone who is also drafting, filing or preparing for a hearing, which is why each route needs a backup and a time limit.

Firm size makes the same point. 86.8% of US law offices have fewer than ten employees[3], so a practice group is often one attorney and one paralegal. A route that depends on that pair being free will fail several times a day.

The four routing signals

  • Caller type: new client, existing client, professional caller such as opposing counsel, a court or a referral source, or a vendor.
  • Practice area: inferred from what the caller describes, not from what they call it.
  • Language: the caller's preferred language and whether the route can serve it.
  • Urgency: liberty, safety or a deadline within a day or two.

Ask about caller type and urgency first, because they change the route regardless of practice area. A current client calling about tomorrow's hearing goes to their matter team, not to new-client intake, even if they describe a new problem.

Build a routing matrix

Example routing matrix for a three-practice firm
Caller signalRoute toBackupIf no answer in 30 seconds
Urgent: arrest, detention, protective order, deadline in 48 hoursOn-call attorney for that practiceManaging partnerTake details, escalate by text, call back within 30 minutes
New client: injury or accidentPI intake specialistParalegal, PI teamOverflow intake with PI questions
New client: divorce, custody, supportFamily intake specialistFamily paralegalOverflow intake with family questions
New client: wills, trusts, probateEstate planning paralegalReceptionistOverflow intake; book consultation
New client: Spanish preferredSpanish-speaking intake staffInterpreter lineSpanish voicemail and same-day callback
Existing clientMatter paralegalMatter attorney's assistantMessage to matter queue
Opposing counsel, court, referral sourceMatter attorney's assistantReceptionistMessage with a callback deadline
Vendor or salesReceptionistNoneGeneral voicemail

Every row has a backup and a no-answer step. If you cannot fill in the last column for a row, that route currently ends in a voicemail box someone checks when they remember.

Identify the practice area in one question

Phone menus that ask callers to choose a practice area mis-route many calls, because callers do not know the categories. A live or automated triage question works better:

โ€œSo I can get you to the right person, can you tell me in a sentence what happened or what you need help with?โ€

Then map common phrases to routes. Keep the map in the intake guide and update it whenever a call is mis-routed.

  • Accident, crash, fell, hurt, insurance company called: injury.
  • Divorce, separation, custody, child support, visitation: family.
  • Will, trust, my mother passed, probate, power of attorney: estate planning.
  • Fired, not paid overtime, harassed at work: employment, or decline and refer if you do not practice it.
  • Arrested, charged, court date, warrant: criminal, which is usually urgent.

For a deeper version of this logic, see building an intake decision tree for multi-practice firms.

Language routing

About 22% of US residents aged five and older speak a language other than English at home, and about 61% of them speak Spanish[2]. If you serve those communities, route by language before practice area: a Spanish-speaking caller routed to an English-only injury specialist will often hang up before an interpreter joins.

Offer the language choice in the first few seconds of the greeting, in that language. Route to bilingual staff where you have them, to an interpreter line where you do not, and never route a caller in their own language to a voicemail recorded only in English.

Urgency overrides and the represented-party check

Write a short list of urgent triggers and train everyone who answers to listen for them. When one appears, the call jumps to the urgent row regardless of practice area or caller type. Urgent routes should end with a person or a guaranteed callback window, never with a general mailbox.

Before routing a new caller into intake, ask whether they already have a lawyer on this matter. Florida Bar guidance suggests screening questions that limit intake communications when a person is already represented[4]. A represented caller is routed to an attorney to decide on next steps, not into a full intake conversation.

Routing existing clients and professional callers

Existing clients should never go through new-client intake. Give them a fast path: a menu option for current clients, a separate number printed on engagement letters, or a first question that asks whether they already work with the firm. Route them to the paralegal or assistant on their matter, with the matter attorney's assistant as backup, and log every message against the matter so the history is in one place.

Professional callers, such as opposing counsel, court staff, mediators, experts and referral sources, need a different route again. They usually know whom they want, and they need a reliable message and a callback deadline rather than a conversation. Send them to the matter team's assistant and make sure the message records the case name and the deadline, if any, they mention.

After-hours routing

The matrix changes shape when the office closes. Most rows collapse into one after-hours answer that captures details and books or requests consultations, while the urgent row stays live and points to the on-call attorney for each practice. Configure this with the phone system's schedule rather than manual forwarding, so the switch happens on time every evening and every holiday. Test the after-hours version of each row at least once a quarter, since that is the version nobody sees during the working day.

Build and test the routing

  1. List every caller type and practice

    Include practices you decline, so callers in those areas get a polite referral instead of a transfer.

  2. Fill in the matrix

    One row per signal, with route, backup and no-answer step. Get each practice lead to sign off on their rows.

  3. Configure the phone system

    Create ring groups for each route, set the 30-second timeout and point no-answer steps to overflow or a monitored queue.

  4. Write the triage guide

    The one-question opener, the phrase map, the urgent triggers and the represented-party question on one page.

  5. Test every row

    Place a test call for each row, during and after hours, and record where it ended up and how long it took.

  6. Review mis-routes monthly

    Ask staff to flag any call they had to transfer twice. Each one is a gap in the matrix or the phrase map.

Example: a firm with three practice groups

Example (fictional): a nine-person firm with injury, family and estate planning groups used a phone menu with three options. Staff noticed that people who had been in car accidents often pressed the family option because they assumed it covered insurance for the household. The firm replaced the menu with a single triage question answered live during office hours and by an overflow intake option afterwards, using the phrase map above. Transfers between groups dropped noticeably within a month, and the injury team stopped receiving calls about custody.

Keeping routing current

Routing decays as people change roles, go on leave or leave the firm. Every staffing change should trigger a check of the matrix and a round of test calls. Pair routing with clear rules for warm transfers and a phone menu callers won't hang up on, and decide when a menu or live answer suits your volume. Since only 19% of adults answer calls from unknown numbers[5], a caller lost to a bad route is unlikely to pick up when you try to call back.

Frequently asked questions

Should a multi-practice firm use a phone menu to route calls?

A short menu can separate existing clients from new callers, but asking callers to pick a practice area often mis-routes them. A single triage question, answered live or by an intake option, usually routes more accurately.

How long should a routed call ring before it moves on?

Around 30 seconds, or four to five rings, is a common limit. After that the call should move to a backup or overflow, not to a personal voicemail box.

How do we route callers who need Spanish?

Offer the language choice early in the greeting, in Spanish, and route to bilingual staff or an interpreter line before routing by practice area. Make sure every Spanish route ends with a Spanish voicemail and a callback.

What do we do with callers in practice areas we do not handle?

Add them to the matrix as their own row. Give staff a short, polite decline and a list of referral resources, such as the local bar association's lawyer referral service.

References

  1. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2023). May 2023 National Industry-Specific Occupational Employment and Wage Estimates: NAICS 541100 - Legal Services (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. U.S. Census Bureau (2025). New Data on Detailed Languages Spoken at Home and the Ability to Speak English (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. U.S. Census Bureau (2023). County Business Patterns 2023: U.S. detail file (cbp23us) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. The Florida Bar (2024). Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  5. Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo