Metrics and Firm Finance

Succession Planning for Law Firm Owners

Succession planning for law firm owners: an emergency plan, Rule 1.17 sale conditions and state rules, a five-year transition timeline and client notice.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Why small firms in particular need a plan
  2. Plan one: the emergency plan
  3. Plan two: transition or sale
  4. Rule 1.17: the sale conditions
  5. A five-year transition timeline
  6. Example: a solo estate planning practice
  7. Insurance, tax and money questions
  8. Talking to staff
  9. Keep the client base transferable
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References
Metrics and Firm Finance: Succession Planning for Law Firm OwnersArticle coverMETRICS AND FIRM FINANCESuccession Planning forLaw Firm OwnersAva for LawyersInsightsMetrics and Firm Finance: Succession Planning for Law Firm OwnersArticle coverMETRICS AND FIRM FINANCESuccession Planningfor Law Firm OwnersAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • Every owner needs two plans: an emergency plan for sudden death or disability, and a planned transition or sale.
  • Model Rule 1.17 allows the sale of a practice if the seller stops practicing in the area, sells the practice or area as a whole, gives clients written notice and does not raise fees because of the sale[1].
  • States vary: Minnesota's version, for example, bars the buyer from raising fees because of the sale for at least one year[2].
  • Minnesota's comment to Rule 1.3 says the duty of diligence may require a sole practitioner to have a plan naming another lawyer to review files and notify clients[3].

Why small firms in particular need a plan

Most US law practices are small. In 2023, 71.8% of offices of lawyers had fewer than five employees[4], and another 274,000 legal services businesses had no paid employees at all[5]. In a practice that size, the owner is usually the main relationship with every client, the signatory on the trust account and the only person who knows where everything is. If that person retires without a plan, or dies or becomes disabled suddenly, clients are left without counsel, deadlines are missed and the value built over a career can disappear in months.

US offices of lawyers by employee count, 2023
US offices of lawyers by employee count, 2023Comparison. Fewer than 5 employees: 118,754; 5 or more employees: 46,737.118,754Fewer than 5 employeesFewer than 5 employees: 118,75446,7375 or more employees5 or more employees: 46,737US offices of lawyers by employee count, 2023Comparison. Fewer than 5 employees: 118,754; 5 or more employees: 46,737.118,754Fewer than 5 employeesFewer than 5 employees: 118,75446,7375 or more employees5 or more employees: 46,737

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2023[4]

Show the data
ItemValue
Fewer than 5 employees118,754
5 or more employees46,737

Succession planning protects three things: clients, whose matters must continue or be transferred safely; the owner and their family, who should receive fair value for the practice; and staff, who need to know what happens to their jobs. It is also a professional duty, not just a business choice.

Plan one: the emergency plan

Minnesota's comment to Rule 1.3, for example, says that to prevent neglect of client matters in the event of a sole practitioner's death or disability, the duty of diligence may require each sole practitioner to prepare a plan that designates another competent lawyer to review client files, notify each client and determine whether immediate protective action is needed[3]. The ABA Model Rules carry a similar comment, and many states have adopted it. Even where it is phrased as advice rather than a requirement, the plan is the only thing that protects clients if the owner is suddenly unavailable.

  1. Name a designated successor lawyer, and a backup, in a signed written agreement that sets out their authority and how they will be paid.
  2. Give the successor access arrangements for the office, files, practice management system, email and calendar, held securely and released only on a defined trigger.
  3. Arrange trust account access through a co-signatory or a court-approved mechanism allowed in your state, so client funds can be returned or applied.
  4. Keep a current matter list with next deadlines, court dates and client contact details.
  5. Record passwords and system access in a password manager with emergency access, not on paper in a desk drawer.
  6. Tell your staff, your malpractice insurer and your family who the successor is and where the plan is kept.

Review the emergency plan every year and whenever you change software, bank, office or key staff. An out-of-date plan with old passwords and a retired successor is not a plan.

Plan two: transition or sale

For a planned exit, owners usually choose one of four routes: bring in a partner or associate who buys in over time, merge with another firm, sell the practice under Rule 1.17, or wind down and refer clients out. The right route depends on the practice's transferable value, the owner's timeline and whether there is a lawyer inside the firm who wants to take over.

Four exit routes for a law firm owner, when each fits, a typical timeline and the main risk.
RouteBest whenTypical timelineKey risk
Internal successor buys inA capable associate wants to own the firm3 to 7 yearsSuccessor leaves before transfer completes
MergerA compatible firm wants your clients and staff1 to 2 yearsCulture and conflicts
Sale under Rule 1.17Transferable client base, owner ready to stop practicing6 to 18 monthsClient attrition after the sale
Wind down and referLittle transferable value or no buyer6 to 12 monthsLoss of value; files and trust balances to resolve

Rule 1.17: the sale conditions

ABA Model Rule 1.17 allows a lawyer or law firm to sell a practice, or an area of practice, if four conditions are met[1]:

  1. The seller stops practicing

    The seller ceases private practice in the jurisdiction or geographic area, or in the area of practice being sold.

  2. The whole practice or area is sold

    The entire practice, or the entire area of practice, is sold; a seller cannot keep the best matters and sell the rest.

  3. Clients receive written notice

    Each client gets written notice of the proposed sale, the identity of the buyer, the client's right to retain other counsel or take possession of the file, and the fact that consent to the transfer will be presumed if the client does not object within 90 days. If a client cannot be given notice, the representation may be transferred only by court order.

  4. Fees do not increase because of the sale

    Clients' fees may not be raised by reason of the sale.

States have adopted different versions. Minnesota, for example, requires the notice to include a statement that the practice has been sold, a summary of the buyer's professional background and a statement that the client may continue with the buyer under the same fee arrangement, and it bars the buyer from increasing fees because of the sale for at least one year[2]. Minnesota also ties the 90-day presumed-consent period to notice delivered by personal service or certified mail[2]. Read your own state's rule before drafting anything.

A five-year transition timeline

  • Five years out: decide the route, document systems and procedures, and start introducing a successor to key clients.
  • Three years out: get a valuation, clean up financial records and normalize owner pay, rent and family wages so the firm's true profit is visible.
  • Two years out: agree terms with an internal successor or begin talks with buyers or merger partners; check conflicts early.
  • One year out: sign the agreement, prepare client notices under your state's rule, and plan staff communication.
  • Transition: send notices, transfer files and trust balances properly, and stay available to the buyer for an agreed handover period where the rule allows.

Example: a solo estate planning practice

Example, fictional. A solo estate planning lawyer, aged 64, plans to stop practicing at 68. She has around 1,100 past clients with estate plans and 40 open matters. She signs an emergency plan with a colleague down the street, then spends a year cleaning up her client database so every plan is linked to a current contact record. At 66 she gets a valuation and agrees a sale to a younger two-lawyer firm, with a handover period during which she introduces the buyers to clients at plan reviews. Notices go out under her state's version of Rule 1.17, fees stay unchanged and three clients ask for their files. The rest move to the buyer.

Insurance, tax and money questions

  • Malpractice cover: ask your insurer about extended reporting, often called tail coverage, so claims made after you stop practicing are still covered.
  • Sale structure: payment up front, payment over time, or a share of future fees from transferred clients each carry different tax treatment; get advice from an accountant who knows law practice sales.
  • Fee sharing: if the price depends on future fees, check that the arrangement fits your state's version of Rule 1.17 and its rules on dividing fees.
  • Disability cover: an owner's personal disability insurance can fund the transition if the owner cannot work for a long period.
  • Records retention: agree who keeps closed files, for how long, and who pays for storage.

Talking to staff

Staff usually guess that something is happening long before they are told. Decide early what you will share and when, and tell key staff before clients hear anything. The people who answer the phone and manage files are often the reason clients stay after a transition, so a buyer will want them, and they will want to know their jobs are secure. Consider retention bonuses for key staff tied to staying through the handover period, and involve them in planning the client notices and calls.

Keep the client base transferable

Buyers pay for clients who will stay. Practices with clean records, documented procedures and clients who know more than one person at the firm transfer far better than practices where everything lives in the owner's head. Answer the phone consistently, log every client contact in one system and introduce associates or staff to clients long before any sale, so the relationship belongs to the firm rather than to one lawyer.

For how buyers and sellers put a number on the practice, see valuing a law practice. For combining with another firm instead, see merging two small law firms: operational checklist.

Frequently asked questions

Can a lawyer sell a law practice?

Yes, under Rule 1.17 in states that have adopted it. The Model Rule requires the seller to stop practicing in the area, sell the whole practice or area, give clients written notice and not raise fees because of the sale[1].

Does a sole practitioner need a succession plan?

Comments to Rule 1.3 in many states, such as Minnesota, say the duty of diligence may require a sole practitioner to have a plan naming another lawyer to review files and notify clients[3]. It is strongly advisable everywhere.

How long does it take to sell a law practice?

A sale under Rule 1.17 often takes six to eighteen months from first talks to handover. Internal buy-ins usually take several years.

What happens to client trust funds when a practice is sold?

Trust balances must be transferred or returned according to your state's trust account rules and each client's instructions. Plan this with your accountant and check your state bar's guidance.

References

  1. FindLaw (Thomson Reuters) (n.d.). Ethical Considerations for Selling Your Law Practice (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. Minnesota Office of the Revisor of Statutes (n.d.). Minnesota Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 1.17: Sale of Law Practice (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. Minnesota Office of the Revisor of Statutes (n.d.). Minnesota Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 1.3: Diligence (with comments) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. U.S. Census Bureau (2023). County Business Patterns 2023: U.S. detail file (cbp23us) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  5. U.S. Census Bureau (2023). Nonemployer Statistics 2023: U.S. file (nonemp23us) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo