Key takeaways
- Judge both products on the documents you produce every week, not on feature lists.
- Smokeball leans on Word-based templates and automatic time capture; Clio leans on a wide app ecosystem and separate products for intake and drafting[1][2].
- Most US law offices have fewer than five employees, so the buyer is usually also the person who will build the templates[3].
- Run the same three documents through both trials, time them, and score the output before you look at contracts.
What makes a practice document-heavy
A family, estate planning or personal injury practice can run on a handful of document types that are drafted again and again with different facts: petitions, financial disclosures and parenting plans; wills, trusts and powers of attorney; records requests, lien letters and demand packages. The time drain is not the legal thinking. It is retyping names, dates, children, assets and providers into the same documents, then checking that nothing was missed.
That makes the choice between Smokeball and Clio less about which product has more features and more about where each one puts its effort. Both sell full practice management. The question for a document-heavy firm is narrower: which one gets a correct first draft out of your matter data faster, with fewer places for an error to hide?
The buyer is usually close to the work. In 2023, 71.8% of US law offices had fewer than five employees[3], and 86.8% had fewer than ten[4]. In firms that size the lawyer choosing the software is often the person who will build and maintain the templates, so set-up effort counts as much as finished features.
- Fewer than 5 71.8%
- 5 to 9 15%
- 10 to 19 7.4%
- 20 or more 5.8%
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2023[3]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Fewer than 5 | 71.8% |
| 5 to 9 | 15% |
| 10 to 19 | 7.4% |
| 20 or more | 5.8% |
How each vendor describes its document tools
The table below sticks to what each company says on its own features page, then adds the test that tells you whether the claim holds up for your work. Vendors change packaging often, so confirm names and inclusions in writing.
| Area | Smokeball (its features page) | Clio (its features page) | What to verify in the demo |
|---|---|---|---|
| Template library | TemplateLab, described as 20,000+ templates that fill straight from the matter | 900+ free legal templates; document automation listed under Clio Work | Are your state court forms included, and how quickly are revised forms pushed out? |
| Microsoft Office | Describes deep Word and Outlook integration | Ask which Word and Outlook add-ins come with your plan | Draft in Word, save to the matter and file an email without retyping anything |
| Practice-area tools | Lists a FamilyPro feature | Relies on templates plus 300+ app integrations | Ask for a family or estate workflow demo built on one of your own forms |
| Time capture | Lists AutoTime | Ask how drafting time is captured | Compare captured time with a manual log for one working day |
| AI drafting | Lists Archie AI | Lists Clio Work for AI legal drafting | Who reviews AI output, and is matter data used to train anything? |
| Intake | Lists intake and lead management | Sells Clio Grow for intake and CRM | Does intake data land in the matter without re-entry? |
Fit by practice area
- Family law: court forms change, and a single matter can need the same financial data in several forms. Test whether a change to the client's income updates every form that uses it, and ask each vendor who maintains the forms for your state and how you are notified of revisions.
- Estate planning: the work is conditional logic. Married or single, minor children or none, a guardian named or not, a trust funded now or later. Build one will with three conditions in each trial and check that removed clauses leave no stray headings or numbering gaps.
- Personal injury: the same provider, insurer and claim numbers appear in records requests, lien letters and the demand. Check that contacts and roles (treating provider, adjuster, lienholder) can be merged by role, so a new provider added mid-case flows into the next letter.
- Mixed practices: if you handle two of these areas, give the most weight to the one with the most documents per matter. That is where a weak template engine costs you every week.
Run a three-document bake-off
Pick three real documents
Choose the three you produce most often, including one with conditional clauses. Strip client data and keep a clean finished copy as the answer key.
Load the same fictional matter
Create one test matter with identical names, dates, children or assets, and providers in both trials. Use the same data for every run.
Build each template once
Time how long it takes you, not the sales engineer, to build or adapt each template. Note every point where you needed support.
Generate and compare
Produce each document and compare it to your answer key line by line. Count errors: wrong merge field, broken numbering, leftover placeholder text, formatting drift in Word.
Change something
Edit one clause and one data point, regenerate, and confirm both changes appear everywhere they should. This is where weak automation shows itself.
Score and decide
Weight set-up time, error count and regeneration time. Price and contract terms come after the scores, not before.
Where AI drafting fits
Both vendors now market AI drafting tools alongside classic templates[1][2]. Templates and AI solve different problems. A template produces the same structure every time from structured data, which is what court forms and estate documents need. AI drafting is better suited to first drafts of letters or summaries that a lawyer will rewrite.
Among legal professionals who use generative AI, the top uses are document review (74%), legal research (73%) and document summarization (72%)[5], so expect staff to try these tools whether or not you plan for it. Training is the gap: 64% of professionals surveyed by Thomson Reuters had received no training on using generative AI for their work[6]. Whichever product you choose, budget time to train staff on when to use a template and when an AI draft is acceptable.
Example: a three-lawyer estate planning firm
Example (fictional): a three-lawyer estate planning firm produces about 40 plans a month, each with a will, a revocable trust, two powers of attorney and a funding letter. In the bake-off, the paralegal builds the trust template in both trials. One product produces a clean first draft but needs a support call to set up the conditional guardian clause; the other is faster to build but leaves a numbering gap when the clause drops out. The firm weights error count above build time, because every numbering gap means a lawyer reviewing a 30-page trust line by line, and chooses on that basis.
The lesson is not which product won. It is that the deciding fact only appeared when the firm changed one condition and regenerated the document.
Decision criteria
- Lean toward the product whose templates gave you fewer errors after a change, even if the first build took longer.
- If your staff live in Word and Outlook all day, give extra weight to the Office test in the table above.
- If you depend on several outside tools (accounting, e-signature, a phone system), list them and confirm each connection exists before the demo ends.
- If intake is a weak spot, compare the intake option each vendor offers and check whether it is a separate product with its own contract.
- Ask for data export in a documented format and a copy of your templates if you leave. Templates are firm property; make sure the contract says so.
A useful rule: if you cannot rebuild your most common document in the trial without vendor help, you will not maintain it after go-live either.
Plan the set-up effort honestly
Template work is front-loaded. Expect the first month after go-live to be spent converting your highest-volume documents, testing them on closed matters and fixing merge fields that pulled the wrong contact. Firms that skip this step end up with a new system and the old habit of copying last month's document and editing it by hand, which is the exact problem they paid to solve.
Assign one owner for templates, give them protected hours each week, and agree a naming convention before anyone builds anything: practice area, document type, jurisdiction and version date. When a court form changes, the owner updates the master, notes the change and retires the old version so nobody generates from it by mistake.
- Convert documents in order of volume, not in order of how annoying they are.
- Test every converted template on two closed matters with different fact patterns before staff use it live.
- Keep a short change log for each template: what changed, who changed it, and why.
- Review the full template set at least twice a year, and whenever your state revises its forms.
Questions to settle before you sign
- Which templates and court forms for our state are included, and who keeps them current?
- Can we export every template in an editable format if we leave, and do we own the ones we build?
- What migration help is included for matters, contacts and documents from our current system?
- How many hours of training are included, and is it live or recorded?
- Do any AI features send matter data outside the platform, and is it used to train models?
- What does it cost to add the intake, payments or drafting add-on we will probably want within a year?
Get the answers in writing, attached to the order form. A sales call summary in your notes is not enough if the question comes up during a renewal two years from now.
Frequently asked questions
Is Smokeball or Clio better for family law?
It depends on your state forms and how much of your work is form-driven. Smokeball lists a FamilyPro feature and a large template library; Clio relies on its template library and app integrations[1][2]. Build one financial disclosure form in each trial and compare the output.
Can I move my existing Word templates into either product?
Usually yes, but expect to rebuild merge fields and conditional clauses. Ask each vendor whether template conversion is included, and test one of your own documents before signing.
Should a document-heavy firm rely on AI drafting instead of templates?
Not for court forms or estate documents that need a fixed structure. Use templates for those and keep AI drafting for letters and summaries a lawyer will edit and check.
What should I get in writing before signing?
What is included in your plan, data and template export on exit, migration help, and how matter data is handled by any AI features.
References
Smokeball (2026). Smokeball features (opens in a new tab) โ
Clio (2026). Clio features (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Census Bureau (2023). County Business Patterns 2023: U.S. detail file (cbp23us) (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Census Bureau (2023). County Business Patterns 2023: U.S. detail file (cbp23us) (opens in a new tab) โ
Thomson Reuters Institute (2025). 2025 GenAI report: Executive summary for legal professionals (opens in a new tab) โ
Thomson Reuters (2025). Generative AI Adoption Nearly Doubles as Professional Services Reach Crossroads (opens in a new tab) โ