Key takeaways
- 82% of US adults at least sometimes read online reviews before a first purchase, and 40% always or almost always do[1].
- Lawyers may answer a negative review, but only with a proportional, restrained reply that reveals no confidential information[2].
- Never buy reviews, reward reviews for their sentiment or threaten reviewers without grounds; the FTC's 2024 rule targets all three[3].
- Run a 30-minute weekly routine: check sources, reply, log themes, and fix the operational problems that reviews reveal.
Where a firm's reputation lives now
A law firm's reputation used to travel mostly by word of mouth among clients, other lawyers and judges. It still does, but it now also sits in public: map listing reviews, legal directories, social media, news coverage, court records and bar discipline databases. Prospective clients check those sources before they call, and referrers often check them before they pass your name on. Reputation management is the habit of knowing what those sources say, responding appropriately and fixing the problems they reveal.
Reviews carry the most weight. Pew Research Center found that 82% of US adults at least sometimes read online ratings or reviews before buying something for the first time, including 40% who always or almost always do[1]. Yet 48% of review readers say it is often hard to tell whether reviews are truthful and unbiased[1], so readers look for patterns and for how the business responds, not just the star average.
Set up monitoring once
| Source | What to watch | How often |
|---|---|---|
| Map listing reviews | New reviews, questions, edits to your listing | Weekly, with alerts on |
| Legal directories | Reviews and profile accuracy | Monthly |
| Social media | Mentions of the firm and lawyers by name | Weekly |
| News and web | Name alerts for the firm and each lawyer | Alerts, reviewed weekly |
| Bar records | Public discipline records and profile details | Quarterly |
| Your own intake data | Complaints from callers and clients | Monthly |
Give one person ownership of monitoring and make sure they have logins for every listing and profile. Keep the list of accounts in a shared document so access does not depend on one employee's inbox.
The 30-minute weekly routine
Check every source
Open each listing and profile and note new reviews, questions or mentions since last week.
Reply to new reviews
Thank positive reviewers briefly; draft careful replies to negative ones for a lawyer to approve.
Answer listing questions
Public questions on map listings are often from prospective clients. Answer factually and invite them to call.
Log the themes
Record what reviews mention, good and bad: responsiveness, clarity on fees, staff courtesy, outcomes.
Flag operational issues
If two reviews in a quarter mention unreturned calls, that is an intake problem, not a marketing problem. Send it to the person who can fix it.
Replying to positive reviews
Keep replies short, warm and generic. Thank the reviewer, mention the firm's commitment in a sentence, and stop. Do not confirm that the reviewer was a client or mention their matter, even when the review itself is detailed. A reviewer's decision to talk about their case does not give the firm permission to do the same.
- Example: Thank you for taking the time to write this. We are glad our team could help, and we appreciate your trust.
- Example: Thank you for the kind words about our staff. We will share them with the team.
Replying to negative reviews within the ethics rules
Negative reviews are where lawyers get into trouble. The Professional Ethics Committee for the State Bar of Texas concluded in Opinion 662 that a lawyer may not publish a response to a former client's negative review if the response reveals confidential information, but may post a proportional and restrained response[2]. Other states have reached similar conclusions: the duty of confidentiality does not disappear because a client complained in public.
- Wait a day before replying, and have a lawyer who was not involved review the draft.
- Do not confirm or deny that the reviewer was a client, and do not mention any facts of a matter.
- Acknowledge the concern in general terms and offer a private channel.
- Example reply: We take all feedback seriously. Our professional obligations prevent us from discussing any client matter online, but we would welcome the chance to talk directly. Please call our office manager at the main number.
- If the reviewer is not a client and the facts are wrong, you may say the firm has no record of representing them, after checking your records carefully and only if that disclosure itself reveals nothing confidential.
Fake, mistaken or defamatory reviews
Some reviews are posted about the wrong firm, by competitors or by people who were never clients. Use the platform's reporting process, explain why the review breaches its policies, and keep a record. Be careful with legal threats. The FTC's 2024 rule on reviews and testimonials bars businesses from suppressing reviews through groundless legal threats or intimidation, and prohibits incentives conditioned on reviews expressing a particular sentiment, positive or negative[3]. A lawsuit over a review can also draw far more attention to it than the review itself.
When a review is genuine but unfair, resist the urge to correct the record in detail. A calm, short reply aimed at future readers, not at the reviewer, usually does the most good. Readers who see a firm respond with restraint to a harsh review often trust it more than a firm with no criticism at all. Keep a private file of the review, your reply and any platform correspondence, in case the matter resurfaces in a bar inquiry or fee dispute.
Getting more reviews the right way
The best defense against a single bad review is a steady flow of honest ones. The FTC's rule bans the sale or purchase of fake reviews and lets the agency seek civil penalties against knowing violators[3]. Lawyer advertising rules add their own limits on testimonials in some states. Within those limits, a simple, consistent process works.
- Ask every client at the same point, such as the closing letter or final meeting, not only the happy ones.
- Send a short email with a direct link to the review page; make it easy.
- Offer nothing in return, not even a small gift or a discount.
- Never write reviews for clients or have staff post them.
- Do not use software to generate review text; 76% of Americans say it is extremely or very important to be able to tell whether text was made by AI or by people[4].
- Spread requests across platforms that prospective clients actually use.
Reputation beyond reviews
Reviews reflect experiences, and experiences are built in the office. Trust in the profession starts low: only 20% of Americans rated lawyers' honesty and ethics as high or very high in Gallup's December 2025 survey[5]. Every returned call, clear fee explanation and courteous decline of a case that does not fit builds the opposite impression. Look at how the firm treats people who do not become clients, because they leave reviews too.
- Return every call and message within a stated time, including callers you will not represent.
- Explain fees in writing at the start and avoid surprises on invoices.
- Train staff to decline politely and offer a referral.
- Close matters with a clear final letter and the return of original documents.
A short crisis plan
Pause automated posts
Stop scheduled social posts and ads while the situation is assessed.
Gather the facts
Find out what happened before anyone comments publicly.
Name a single spokesperson
One lawyer handles all media and public statements; staff refer inquiries to them.
Check professional obligations
Confidentiality, any pending matter and any duty to report apply before any public statement.
Respond once, briefly
A short, factual statement is usually better than a series of replies.
Measuring reputation over time
Track four numbers each month: average rating on your main platform, number of new reviews, median time to reply, and the share of new clients who mention reviews when asked how they found you. A rising review count with a stable rating matters more than a perfect score. Readers distrust perfect scores, and a handful of thoughtful replies to criticism can build more confidence than a wall of five-star ratings.
Frequently asked questions
Can a lawyer respond to a bad online review?
Yes, with a proportional, restrained reply that reveals no confidential information, as the Texas ethics committee concluded in Opinion 662[2]. Do not confirm the person was a client or discuss any matter.
Can we offer clients a gift for leaving a review?
Avoid it. The FTC's 2024 rule prohibits incentives conditioned on reviews expressing a particular sentiment[3], and many states restrict lawyers giving anything of value to promote the firm. Ask without offering anything.
Should we sue over a false review?
Rarely. Report it to the platform first. Groundless legal threats to suppress reviews are prohibited by the FTC rule, and litigation can amplify the review[3].
References
Pew Research Center (2016). Online reviews and ratings (opens in a new tab) โ
Professional Ethics Committee for the State Bar of Texas (2016). Opinion 662: Responding to a former client's negative internet review (opens in a new tab) โ
Federal Trade Commission (2024). Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (opens in a new tab) โ
Pew Research Center (2025). How Americans View AI and Its Impact on Human Abilities, Society (opens in a new tab) โ
Gallup (2025). Nurses Continue to Lead in Honesty and Ethics Ratings (opens in a new tab) โ