Marketing and Lead Generation

Replying to Positive Reviews Without Breaching Confidentiality

Safe reply patterns for law firm reviews: what a thank-you can and cannot say, templates that confirm nothing, and a simple approval workflow for staff.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing6 min read

On this page
  1. Why a thank-you can be a problem
  2. What ethics guidance says about review replies
  3. Why replies are still worth writing
  4. Unsafe and safe versions side by side
  5. Six reply patterns you can rotate
  6. Tricky situations
  7. The red-flag phrase list
  8. When not to reply at all
  9. A simple approval workflow
  10. Example: tightening a firm’s replies
  11. Where this fits
  12. Frequently asked questions
  13. References
Marketing and Lead Generation: Replying to Positive Reviews Without Breaching ConfidentialityArticle coverMARKETING AND LEAD GENERATIONReplying to PositiveReviews WithoutBreachingConfidentialityAva for LawyersInsightsMarketing and Lead Generation: Replying to Positive Reviews Without Breaching ConfidentialityArticle coverMARKETING AND LEAD GENERATIONReplying to PositiveReviews WithoutBreachingConfidentialityAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • A reviewer sharing their own story does not give the firm permission to add to it; confidentiality duties are broad[1].
  • The safest reply thanks the person for their words without confirming they were a client, the matter type or any outcome.
  • Texas ethics guidance allows only a proportional, restrained response to reviews that reveals no confidential information[2]; apply the same restraint to praise.
  • Google recommends short, professional, personalized replies[3]; personal does not have to mean specific.

Why a thank-you can be a problem

Most guidance on law firm reviews focuses on negative ones, where the temptation to defend yourself is obvious. Positive reviews carry a quieter risk. A friendly reply such as “Thank you, Maria, it was a pleasure helping you get custody of your kids after such a hard divorce” feels warm. It also confirms in public that Maria was a client, what the matter was, and how it turned out. Maria chose to share some of that. The lawyer has now added to it.

Lawyers’ confidentiality duties reach well beyond privileged conversations. California’s rules describe the duty, drawn from its Business and Professions Code, as maintaining inviolate the confidence and preserving the secrets of a client[1]. In many states, information relating to the representation is broad enough to include the fact that someone is or was a client and the kind of matter involved. A reviewer’s own disclosure does not usually amount to informed consent for the lawyer to disclose more.

What ethics guidance says about review replies

The clearest opinions concern negative reviews, but their logic applies to any reply. The Professional Ethics Committee for the State Bar of Texas concluded in Opinion 662 (August 2016) that a lawyer may not publish a response to a former client’s negative review that reveals confidential information, and may post only a proportional and restrained response that reveals none[2]. If a lawyer cannot reveal confidential information to defend their reputation against criticism, there is no stronger case for revealing it to say thank you.

Rule of thumb: write every reply as if the reviewer might later withdraw the review, and ask yourself whether your reply would then be revealing anything they had not said themselves. Better still, reveal nothing at all.

Why replies are still worth writing

Silence is not the answer either. Google encourages businesses to reply to reviews and advises keeping replies professional, short and personal rather than pasting the same thank-you everywhere[3]. Prospective clients read replies to judge how a firm treats people. That matters in a profession where only 20% of Americans rate lawyers’ honesty and ethics as high or very high[4], and in a review environment where many readers doubt what they see.

Review readers who say it is often hard to tell whether reviews are truthful and unbiased
Review readers who say it is often hard to tell whether reviews are truthful and unbiasedDonut chart. Often hard to tell: 48%.Often hard to tell: 48%48%
  • Often hard to tell 48%

Source: Pew Research Center, 2016[5]

Show the data
ItemValue
Often hard to tell48%

With 48% of review readers saying it is often hard to tell whether reviews are truthful[5], thoughtful, restrained replies help a profile look like what it is: real people, answered by real professionals.

Unsafe and safe versions side by side

Common review replies that disclose too much, and safe rewrites
Unsafe replyWhat it revealsSafe alternative
“Glad we could get your DUI dismissed, James!”Client relationship, charge, outcome“Thank you for taking the time to share this, James. We appreciate it.”
“It was a pleasure helping you through your divorce.”Client relationship, matter type“Thank you for your kind words. Our whole team appreciates them.”
“Congratulations on your settlement!”Matter type and that money was recovered“We’re grateful you took a moment to write this.”
“Your mother’s estate was complicated, but we got there.”Matter, family details, difficulty“Thank you. Reviews like this mean a great deal to us.”
“Thanks for choosing us over [other firm].”That the person shopped around; disparages another firm“Thank you for the thoughtful review.”

Notice that the safe versions still use the reviewer’s first name where the platform shows it, still sound human, and still vary. They simply avoid confirming anything about a legal matter.

Six reply patterns you can rotate

  1. Gratitude: “Thank you for taking the time to write this. We truly appreciate it.”
  2. Team credit: “Thank you. I’ll make sure the whole team sees your kind words.”
  3. Values: “We’re grateful for your review. Treating every person with care is what we aim for.”
  4. Open door: “Thank you so much. If you ever need anything in the future, you know where to find us.”
  5. Brief and warm: “This made our day. Thank you.”
  6. For reviews in another language: reply in the same language with the same restraint, written or checked by a fluent speaker.

Avoid phrases that imply a legal relationship or outcome, such as “helping you”, “your case”, “your matter”, “we’re glad it worked out” or “congratulations”. They feel harmless and are the most common slips.

Tricky situations

  • The reviewer shares a lot of detail: reply with a plain thank-you only. Consider contacting them privately to check they are comfortable with what they posted, especially if it could affect an ongoing matter or another person.
  • The review names the opposing party or a judge: do not repeat or engage with the names. A short thank-you is enough; if the content is inappropriate, consider flagging it under the platform’s policies.
  • The review praises a staff member by name: you can thank them by role without confirming anything else (“I’ll pass this on to Dana”).
  • The reviewer was not a client, such as a caller you referred elsewhere: the same rule applies; reply without confirming who they are.
  • A current client posts mid-matter: thank them, say nothing about the matter, and talk to them privately about the risks of discussing a live case online.

The red-flag phrase list

Give whoever drafts replies a short list of words that should stop them and send the reply to a lawyer. Most accidental disclosures contain at least one of these:

  • Matter words: case, matter, claim, lawsuit, settlement, charge, hearing, trial, divorce, custody, estate, will, visa, bankruptcy.
  • Outcome words: won, dismissed, approved, recovered, resolved, got you, congratulations.
  • Relationship words: representing you, your lawyer, working on your file, our client.
  • People: the other party, the judge, the insurer, family members, children.
  • Time references that date a matter: “after two years”, “since your accident”, “before the trial”.

When not to reply at all

Sometimes the most careful reply is none. If a review describes a current matter in detail, mentions a minor, or names the other side in a pending dispute, a public reply of any kind can draw attention to it. In those cases, contact the reviewer privately, thank them and explain the risks of discussing a live matter online, and leave the public review unanswered. A profile where nearly every review has a short, kind reply will not look neglected because a few do not.

The same applies to reviews that are clearly not about your firm or that break platform rules. Flag them through the platform’s reporting tools rather than replying.

A simple approval workflow

  1. Monitor daily

    One person checks Google and the main directories each working day and logs new reviews.

  2. Draft from the approved patterns

    The monitor drafts a reply using one of the approved patterns, varying wording so replies do not look automated.

  3. Check against the red-flag list

    Before posting, confirm the reply contains none of the phrases that imply a relationship, matter or outcome.

  4. Approve

    The responsible lawyer, or a designated partner, approves replies. For any review that mentions a live matter or names other people, the lawyer writes the reply personally.

  5. Post within a few days

    Timely replies look attentive; there is no need to reply within minutes.

  6. Keep a record

    Log the review, the reply and who approved it, in case questions arise later.

Example: tightening a firm’s replies

Example (fictional): an injury firm’s receptionist has been replying to reviews with details she remembers from the file, such as the client’s injuries and the insurer involved. A partner notices, deletes the most detailed replies and replaces them with short thank-yous. The firm adopts the six patterns above, adds a red-flag phrase list to the reply procedure and has the partner approve replies twice a week. Prospective clients still see a firm that responds to every review warmly; they no longer see anyone’s medical history.

Where this fits

Safe replies are the last step of a review process that starts with an honest request. For the request itself, see getting more Google reviews and review request templates. Many of the same confidentiality instincts apply when past clients send referrals, covered in getting referrals from past clients.

Frequently asked questions

Can a lawyer reply to a Google review at all?

Yes. Replies are generally fine as long as they reveal no confidential information. Keep them short and professional, and avoid confirming the person was a client or describing any matter.

If the client posted details themselves, can I mention them?

It is safest not to. A client’s own disclosure usually does not amount to informed consent for the lawyer to disclose more. Thank them without repeating or adding to what they wrote.

Should a law firm use the reviewer’s name in replies?

Using the first name the platform already displays is generally fine. Do not add surnames, matter details or anything else that identifies them further.

Can staff reply to reviews on behalf of the firm?

Yes, using approved patterns, with a lawyer approving replies and writing any reply that touches on a live matter or other people.

References

  1. The State Bar of California (2026). California Rules of Professional Conduct (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Texas Center for Legal Ethics (Professional Ethics Committee for the State Bar of Texas) (2016). Opinion 662 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Google Business Profile Help (2026). Tips to get more reviews (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Gallup (2025). Nurses Continue to Lead in Honesty and Ethics Ratings (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Pew Research Center (2016). Online reviews and ratings (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo