Key takeaways
- Forecast contingency fees by case stage: each stage gets a probability of resolving with a fee and a typical time to resolution.
- Expected fee per case is expected gross recovery times the fee percentage times the stage probability; sum by quarter of expected resolution.
- Intake is seasonal: US traffic deaths in July to September 2024 were about 23% higher than in January to March[1].
- Keep mass-tort or MDL inventory in a separate forecast; federal personal injury and product liability filings fell 73% in one year as an MDL wound down[2].
Why contingency firms need a forecast
A contingency practice can have an excellent year on paper and still struggle to make payroll. Fees arrive when cases resolve, often a year or more after the work began, while salaries, rent and case costs are paid every month. A forecast turns the case list into an expected cash calendar. It tells you when to draw on a line of credit, when you can afford another hire and how much marketing spend the next two years of fees can support.
The model below fits in one spreadsheet. It needs four inputs per case, and it gets more accurate each quarter as you compare forecasts with what actually resolved.
The four inputs per case
Stage
Pick five or six stages that every case passes through, such as signed and treating, treatment complete, demand sent, negotiation, suit filed and trial set. Use the same definitions for every attorney.
Expected gross recovery
A conservative range set by the handling attorney, using the low end of the range in the forecast. Update it at each stage change, not only at signing.
Fee percentage
From the signed fee agreement, including any step-up if suit is filed. Rule 1.5(c), as adopted in Idaho for example, requires a contingent fee agreement to be in a writing signed by the client and to state the method by which the fee is determined[3].
Stage probability and timing
The share of cases at that stage that historically resolved with a fee, and the median months from that stage to resolution. Build both from your own closed cases.
Expected fee for one case = expected gross recovery x fee percentage x stage probability. Place it in the quarter that matches the stage's median time to resolution.
Build stage probabilities from closed cases
Pull every case closed in the last three years. For each, record the stages it reached and whether it ended with a fee. The probability for a stage is the number of cases that reached it and later produced a fee, divided by all cases that reached it. The timing figure is the median months from entering that stage to the fee being received. If you have fewer than 30 closed cases at a stage, borrow the figure from the stage before and adjust it with partner judgment, and say so in the forecast notes.
- Count withdrawals, declinations after investigation and lost trials as no-fee outcomes.
- Count referred-out cases separately; the fee is a referral share and the timing depends on another firm.
- Exclude mass-tort and MDL inventory from the main model; settle programs follow their own calendar.
- Recalculate probabilities once a year, and timing every six months, since court backlogs move.
Example: a 140-case personal injury inventory
Example, fictional figures. A four-lawyer personal injury firm has 140 open cases. Its fee is one third before suit and 40 percent after filing. Using its own closed-case history, it builds the table below.
| Stage | Open cases | Average expected gross (low end) | Fee % | Probability of fee | Median months to fee | Expected fees |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Signed, treating | 52 | $30,000 | 33% | 55% | 16 | $283,140 |
| Treatment complete | 28 | $35,000 | 33% | 70% | 10 | $226,380 |
| Demand sent | 24 | $40,000 | 33% | 80% | 6 | $253,440 |
| Negotiation | 18 | $45,000 | 33% | 88% | 3 | $235,224 |
| Suit filed | 14 | $90,000 | 40% | 65% | 14 | $327,600 |
| Trial set | 4 | $150,000 | 40% | 60% | 5 | $144,000 |
Example, continued. Total expected fees are about $1.47 million, but timing matters more than the total. Negotiation and trial-set cases, about $379,000, land in the next two quarters. Demand-sent cases add about $253,000 around month six. The large suit-filed group sits more than a year out. The firm's fixed costs are $95,000 a month, so the next six months look thin unless negotiation cases settle on time. The partners arrange a line of credit now rather than in a crisis.
Add case costs and cash timing
Contingency firms usually advance case costs: records, filing fees, depositions and experts. Those costs leave the account long before the fee arrives. Add a second line to the forecast for expected case cost outflows by quarter, using average cost by stage from your closed files, and a third for reimbursements expected at settlement.
- Expert-heavy cases can consume more cash than an entire quarter of smaller settlements.
- Track case costs per open case by stage; a rise usually means more cases moving into litigation.
- Set a cap on unreimbursed case costs as a share of the line of credit, and review it monthly.
Feed the top of the funnel
A forecast built only from open cases runs out after about two years. Add expected new signings by month, using intake history. Seasonality matters here: in 2024, the third quarter had 10,565 US traffic deaths against 8,595 in the first quarter, about 23% more[1], and the third quarter has had more traffic deaths than the first in every year from 2013 to 2024[1]. Serious crashes, and the calls that follow, cluster in the same months.
Source: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 2024[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Jan to Mar | 8,595 |
| Jul to Sep | 10,565 |
Workplace injuries feed workers' compensation and some third-party claims. Private industry employers reported 2.5 million nonfatal workplace injuries and illnesses in 2024[4]. Use your own call logs to see how much of that reaches your phones, and plan staffing for the months when intake peaks.
Keep mass torts separate
Mass-tort inventories can swamp a forecast and then vanish. Federal civil filings fell 22% to 271,802 in the year to March 2025, largely because 3M Combat Arms earplug cases dropped away, and personal injury and product liability filings fell 73%[2]. If your firm holds docket-wide inventory, forecast it on the settlement program's published schedule, apply a heavy discount for uncertainty, and never let it fund fixed costs on its own.
Low, base and high scenarios
A single forecast number invites false confidence. Run three versions every quarter. The base case uses your historical stage probabilities and median timing. The low case cuts expected gross recovery by a fifth and pushes every resolution back one quarter, which is roughly what happens when an insurer changes its claims posture or a court's civil calendar slows. The high case uses the attorneys' upper estimates and current timing.
Fixed costs should be covered by the low case. Discretionary spending, such as a new marketing channel or a bonus pool, can be tied to the base case and released only when actual fees reach it. Hiring decisions should look at the low case two years out, because a new lawyer's salary is a commitment that outlasts a good quarter.
What the forecast tells you about growth
- If the signed-and-treating stage is shrinking, fees will fall in about a year and a half; act on intake and marketing now.
- If cases pile up at demand sent, the bottleneck is attorney or paralegal time to prepare demands, not lead volume.
- If suit-filed inventory grows faster than trial capacity, consider co-counsel or a trial-focused hire.
- If case costs per open case rise steadily, check whether more cases are moving to litigation than the model expects.
- If actual fees keep beating the base case, your probabilities are too conservative; update them at the annual review.
Review the forecast every month
- Update stage and expected gross for every case that moved.
- Compare fees received this month with what the forecast expected, by case.
- Record why each miss happened: delay, lower settlement or no fee.
- Adjust stage probabilities only at the annual review, unless the misses show a clear pattern.
- Share the next two quarters of expected cash with the partners, with the low and high case.
Over time the forecast becomes a management tool rather than a guess. It shows which attorneys over-estimate case values, which stages stall and how intake volume translates into fees two years later. For budgeting against the forecast, see law firm budgeting and annual financial planning, and for how marketing for contingency work differs from hourly work, see marketing contingency fee vs hourly practices.
Frequently asked questions
How accurate can a contingency fee forecast be?
Individual cases are unpredictable, but a portfolio of dozens of cases forecast by stage usually lands within a reasonable range by quarter once probabilities come from your own closed files. Track the error each month and adjust.
Should I use the attorney's expected settlement or a conservative figure?
Use the low end of the attorney's range in the base forecast and show the high end separately. Optimistic forecasts lead to hiring and spending the firm cannot sustain.
How do I forecast cases that go to trial?
Give trial-set cases their own stage, probability and timing based on your history, and model a no-fee outcome explicitly. A single verdict should never be the basis for fixed costs.
How far ahead should the forecast run?
At least eight quarters for open cases, plus expected new signings by month so the forecast does not appear to fall off after two years.
References
National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (2024). Early Estimate of Motor Vehicle Traffic Fatalities in 2024 (DOT HS 813 710) (opens in a new tab) โ
United States Courts (Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts) (2025). Federal Judicial Caseload Statistics 2025 (opens in a new tab) โ
Idaho State Bar (n.d.). Idaho Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 1.5: Fees (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2024). Employer-Reported Workplace Injuries and Illnesses, 2024 (opens in a new tab) โ