Metrics and Firm Finance

Per-Call vs Per-Minute Answering Service Pricing

Which answering service billing unit costs a law firm less depends on call length, intake depth and spam. Two worked call mixes show where the line falls.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing10 min read

On this page
  1. Two invoices for the same month of calls
  2. The break-even is one division
  3. What a law firm's call mix looks like
  4. Spam, hang-ups and calls you should not pay for
  5. Worked example: two firms, 400 calls each
  6. Price the same calls in staff time
  7. Choosing the unit, then the plan
  8. Questions to put to every vendor
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References
Metrics and Firm Finance: Per-Call vs Per-Minute Answering Service Pricing68%: of US adults get scam calls at least weekly; on some plans each one that reaches you is billedMETRICS AND FIRM FINANCEPer-Call vs Per-MinuteAnswering Service Pricing68%of US adults get scam calls at least weekly; on some planseach one that reaches you is billedAva for LawyersInsightsMetrics and Firm Finance: Per-Call vs Per-Minute Answering Service Pricing68%: of US adults get scam calls at least weekly; on some plans each one that reaches you is billedMETRICS AND FIRM FINANCEPer-Call vsPer-Minute AnsweringService Pricing68%of US adults get scam calls at leastweekly; on some plans each one thatreaches you is billedAva for Lawyers
Figure source: Pew Research Center, 2025[1]

Key takeaways

  • Divide the effective price per call by the effective price per minute to get your break-even call length; on two published national price lists it lands near five minutes[2][3].
  • Full intake pushes average call length up and favors per-call billing; lines that mostly take messages favor per-minute billing.
  • Robocalls and hang-ups cost seconds on a per-second plan but a whole call on a per-call plan, unless the contract excludes them[3][4].
  • Rounding every call up to a whole minute, which one provider calls the industry's most common method, adds billable time to every short call[5].

Two invoices for the same month of calls

Put the same month of law-firm calls through a per-minute plan and a per-call plan and the two invoices can differ by several hundred dollars, in either direction. Which one comes out lower has little to do with the headline rate. It turns on three things you can measure from your own phone records before talking to a single vendor: how long your calls run, how much of each call is intake, and how many calls are not real callers at all.

The units are simple enough. Per-minute services sell a bundle of talk time: one national price list runs from 50 minutes for $99 to 1,000 minutes for $1,499, with extra minutes at $1.69 to $2.29 depending on the plan[2]. Per-call services sell a bundle of calls: one publishes 90 calls for $810 and 300 calls for $2,100, with extra calls at $10.50 and $8.50[3]. On the second list a three-minute message and a fourteen-minute injury intake cost the same. On the first, the intake costs nearly five times as much.

This guide finds where the line falls for a law firm, then runs two Example call mixes through both price lists. Minimums, auto-renewals and exit terms are covered in answering service contract terms. The question here is narrower: which unit fits the way your phones actually ring.

The break-even is one division

Every comparison between the two models comes down to one figure, the break-even call length: the effective price per call divided by the effective price per minute. If your average billable call runs longer than that, per-call billing is cheaper. If it runs shorter, per-minute wins.

  1. Work out the effective price per call

    Divide the per-call plan's monthly fee by its included calls. Example: $810 for 90 calls is $9.00 a call[3].

  2. Work out the effective price per minute

    Divide the per-minute plan's fee by its included minutes. Example: $349 for 200 minutes is about $1.75 a minute[2].

  3. Divide the first by the second

    Example: $9.00 divided by $1.75 is about 5.1 minutes. Calls averaging longer than that are cheaper on the per-call list.

  4. Repeat at the overage rates

    Busy months are billed at overage. Example: $10.50 per extra call against $1.99 per extra minute gives about 5.3 minutes, so the answer holds when you run over[2][3].

Example: the break-even on two published price lists
  • $9.00

    effective price per call on a 90-call plan[3]

  • $1.75

    effective price per minute on a 200-minute plan[2]

  • 5.1 min

    average call length where the two bills match

  • 2.5 min

    call length the per-minute list assumes (200 minutes, about 80 calls)[2]

Example arithmetic from two national price lists. Redo it with the quotes in front of you.

The per-minute list hints at the customer it expects: its 200-minute plan is described as about 80 calls, which assumes calls of roughly two and a half minutes[2]. That is a fair average for a business that takes messages. It is short for a law firm whose service runs a conflict check, collects the incident date and facts, and asks the screening questions a partner signed off.

What a law firm's call mix looks like

Law firm calls are not one population. Each type has its own typical length, and the blend sets your average. Before pricing anything, sort four weeks of calls into groups like these, using your carrier's call detail or a call log template.

Example lengths for illustration. Time a sample of your own calls before relying on them.
Call typeWhat the agent doesExample length
New matter, full intakeScreening questions, names for the conflict check, incident date and facts, consultation request7 to 12 minutes
New matter, message onlyName, number, matter type and a good time to call back2 to 3 minutes
Existing clientTakes a message or transfers to the assigned paralegal1.5 to 3 minutes
Court clerk, opposing counsel, adjusterMessage with matter name and deadline, or a transfer1 to 2 minutes
Sales pitch or robocallRecognizes it and ends the callUnder a minute
Hang-up or wrong numberGreeting, then silence or a quick redirectUnder 30 seconds

Intake depth moves the average more than anything else on that list. Switch new-matter calls from message-only to full intake and each one runs three or four times longer, which drags the whole line toward per-call pricing. Message-only vs full-intake services covers what each level collects. For billing, the rule is simple: the deeper you ask the service to go on each call, the more a per-minute meter costs you.

Transfers stretch calls too. When the agent rings the assigned attorney while the caller waits, that hold time usually runs on the meter, and some per-minute services also price the connected portion separately: one lists patching, the time a caller spends connected to you through its line, at $0.10 a minute and voicemail at $0.15[4]. A practice that transfers most existing-client calls adds a line to every invoice that a message-taking practice never sees.

Spam, hang-ups and calls you should not pay for

The calls that are not callers swing the comparison more than most firms expect. In a 2025 survey, 68% of US adults said they get scam phone calls at least weekly and 31% at least daily[1]. An FCC order the same year cited an industry estimate of 13 spam or fraud calls a month for the average consumer[6]. Firm numbers printed on court filings, bar profiles and directory listings attract their share, and each one that reaches a forwarded line costs either a few seconds or a whole call, depending on the unit.

How often US adults get scam phone callsShare of US adults reporting scam calls that try to obtain personal information, 2025.
How often US adults get scam phone callsBar chart. At least weekly: 68%; At least daily: 31%; Several times a day: 21%.At least weeklyAt least weekly: 68%68%At least dailyAt least daily: 31%31%Several times a daySeveral times a day: 21%21%How often US adults get scam phone callsBar chart. At least weekly: 68%; At least daily: 31%; Several times a day: 21%.At least weeklyAt least weekly: 68%68%At least dailyAt least daily: 31%31%Several times a daySeveral times a day: 21%21%

Source: Pew Research Center, 2025[1]

Show the data
FrequencyShare of adults
At least weekly68%
At least daily31%
Several times a day21%

On a plan billed by the second, a robocall the agent ends in 20 seconds costs a third of a minute; one national service bills every plan that way[4]. Rounded up to a whole minute, the same call costs a full minute, and one provider describes whole-minute rounding as the most common billing method in the industry[5]. On a per-call plan it costs a full call unless the contract carves it out. One per-call service says it does not bill spam or unsolicited sales calls, provided the lines you forward pass caller ID[3].

Write the exclusions into the order form: which calls are not billable (spam, sales calls, hang-ups under a set number of seconds, wrong numbers, your own test calls), who decides, and how you dispute a call that slipped through. Screening sales calls and robocalls covers keeping many of them off the line in the first place.

Worked example: two firms, 400 calls each

Example. Two fictional firms each send 400 calls a month to an outside service. Firm A is a general practice where most calls are existing clients and short messages. Firm B is a personal injury practice running ads, so half its calls are new-matter intakes. Both get 60 robocalls and 60 hang-ups. Talk time is counted by the second, and the durations are illustrative.

Example call mixes for two fictional firms, not survey data.
Call typeFirm A: calls ร— minutesFirm B: calls ร— minutes
New-matter intake80 ร— 9 = 720200 ร— 10 = 2,000
Existing clients140 ร— 2.5 = 35040 ร— 2.5 = 100
Courts, counsel, adjusters60 ร— 2 = 12040 ร— 2 = 80
Sales calls and robocalls60 ร— 0.75 = 4560 ร— 0.75 = 45
Hang-ups and wrong numbers60 ร— 0.5 = 3060 ร— 0.5 = 30
Total400 calls, 1,265 minutes (3.2 average)400 calls, 2,255 minutes (5.6 average)

Now price both months on the two published lists. On the per-minute list, Firm A's 1,265 minutes fit the 1,000-minute plan at $1,499 plus 265 extra minutes at $1.69, about $1,947 in all[2]. Firm B's 2,255 minutes fit the 2,000-minute plan at $2,899 plus 255 extra minutes at $1.64, about $3,317[2].

On the per-call list, both firms land on the 300-call plan at $2,100 with extra calls at $8.50[3]. If every call is billable, that is 100 extra calls and $2,950. If the 60 robocalls and sales calls are excluded, as that service says it does when caller ID passes, the count drops to 340 and the bill to $2,440[3]. Whether hang-ups count is a question for the contract.

Example result: Firm A pays about $500 less on the per-minute plan ($1,947 against $2,440). Firm B pays about $880 less on the per-call plan ($2,440 against $3,317). Same call count, same robocalls, opposite answers. The difference is intake depth: Firm B's average call runs 5.6 minutes, past the break-even, while Firm A's runs 3.2.

Billing increments move Firm A's figure as well. If its per-minute plan rounded each call up to a whole minute instead of billing by the second, the hang-ups and robocalls alone would add 45 billed minutes, before the partial last minute of every other call is counted. Get the increment and any minimum charge per call in writing. One provider bills in 30-second steps, so a call of 1 minute 5 seconds is billed as 1 minute 30 seconds rather than 2 minutes[5].

Price the same calls in staff time

Before either bill looks expensive or cheap, set it against the in-house alternative for the same calls. Talk time is only part of what a call costs a staff member. Add the message entry, the callback attempt and the minute it takes to get back into the brief that was interrupted.

ExampleExample: Firm A's calls taken by its own staff
Example: worked figures
InputExample
Calls a day (about 400 a month)18
Minutes per call, incl. message entry6
Share your own staff would take100%
Hourly cost of whoever answers$36.73
Calls a month391
Staff hours on these calls39
Hours handed off39
Monthly value of that staff time$1,435

How it is worked out: Calls a day ร— 21.7 working days ร— minutes per call รท 60 ร— share handled = hours; hours ร— hourly cost.

Assumptions

  • Hourly cost of $36.73: private employers' total compensation cost per hour worked for office and administrative support staff, June 2026.[7]
  • Six minutes per call combines about three minutes of talk time from the Firm A example with message entry and a callback attempt. Time your own.

Example only. Uses Firm A's volume; change the inputs to match your own call log.

In this Example the in-house figure, roughly $1,435 a month, sits below either outside bill. That is normal, and it is not the whole comparison. The staff-time number assumes someone is free every time the phone rings, including at lunch, during a deposition and after 5:30. In Clio's 2024 secret-shopper study, 48% of law firms neither answered nor called back[8]. Whatever unit it bills in, an outside service is mostly paying for the hours when nobody in the office can pick up; in-house versus outsourced answering works through that coverage question.

Choosing the unit, then the plan

  • Lean per-call when new-matter intake is a large share of calls, the intake script is long, or callers often wait through a transfer.
  • Lean per-minute, billed by the second or in short steps, when most calls are messages, existing clients or quick routing.
  • Check either model hard if robocalls are a big share of volume: per-second billing keeps them cheap, and a per-call plan needs a written spam exclusion.
  • Rerun the division whenever the mix changes: a new ad campaign, a new practice area, or a move from message-taking to full intake.

Volume spikes push one way or the other too. A seminar, a TV spot or a mass-tort campaign brings a burst of short logistics calls one week and long intakes the next. The estate planning example models a firm that takes 35 or more calls on each of the two days after a seminar. On a per-call plan, those days eat into included calls quickly. On a per-minute plan, the short what-time-does-it-start calls cost little and the consult requests cost more.

Software changes the shape of the question rather than removing it. An SI Employee answers the forwarded line, asks the intake questions your firm approves, follows your escalation tree for urgent calls and leaves a recording, transcript and summary for every call, so the call-length audit above can be run from the call history in the first week. What it does sets out how it handles a call. Whichever route you take, insist on call-level detail before signing: a billing unit only helps you once you can count it.

Questions to put to every vendor

  1. What is the billing unit, and what exactly starts and stops the clock or counts as a call?
  2. What is the billing increment, and is there a minimum charge per call?
  3. Which calls are not billable: spam, sales calls, hang-ups, wrong numbers, our own test calls?
  4. Are transfers, hold time and voicemail billed, and at what rate?
  5. Is after-call work, such as typing the message, billed as talk time? One per-minute service says it does not bill after-call notes, message entry or wrap-up[2].
  6. Can we export call-level detail with durations every month?
  7. Is overage billed above or below the plan's own rate, and are unused calls or minutes lost at month end?

Put the answers beside your call mix and redo the division. The quote that sounds cheapest on the phone is often the one whose unit suits the vendor's typical customer rather than your firm. How to choose a legal answering service has the rest of the buying checklist, and what a legal answering service costs covers the other lines on the quote.

Frequently asked questions

Is per-minute or per-call billing cheaper for a small law firm?

It depends on average call length. Divide the effective price per call by the effective price per minute; on two published national price lists the break-even is about five minutes[2][3]. Firms whose service runs full intake tend to sit above it, and firms that only take messages tend to sit below.

Do answering services charge for spam calls?

Some do and some do not. One per-call service says it does not bill spam or unsolicited sales calls when forwarded lines pass caller ID[3]. On per-minute plans a robocall costs only the seconds, or rounded minutes, it lasts. Get the rule written into the contract.

What billing increment should we ask for?

Per-second billing is the most precise. One provider bills in 30-second steps and says rounding up to the next whole minute is the industry's most common method[5]. Short increments matter most when many of your calls are brief.

Are transfers to an attorney billed separately?

Often. One per-second service lists patching, connecting the caller to you, at $0.10 a minute and voicemail at $0.15 a minute[4]. Also ask whether the agent's time ringing the attorney while the caller holds counts as talk time.

How do we find our average call length?

Export four weeks of call detail from your carrier or phone system, drop internal and outbound calls, and sort the rest by type. If you already use a service, ask it for call-level durations rather than monthly totals.

References

  1. Pew Research Center (2025). Online Scams and Attacks in America Today (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. PATLive (2026). Pricing: Live Call Answering plans (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. Smith.ai (2026). Pricing (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. Specialty Answering Service (2026). Simple Answering Service Pricing (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  5. Moneypenny (2026). Moneypenny pricing overages explained: how answering service billing really works (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  6. Federal Communications Commission (2025). Advanced Methods to Target and Eliminate Unlawful Robocalls, Eighth Report and Order (FCC 25-15) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  7. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Employer Costs for Employee Compensation, Table 4: Private industry workers by occupational and industry group (June 2026) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  8. Illinois Supreme Court Commission on Professionalism (2Civility) (2024). Phone Calls Ignored, Emails Unanswered: Fixing the First Impression Problem for Law Firms (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo