Key takeaways
- Only 20% of legal professionals surveyed by Thomson Reuters measure the ROI of generative AI[1].
- Capture a 30-day baseline before switching anything on, or you will have nothing to compare.
- Count value in two places: staff time saved, valued by role, and additional signed matters.
- Control for seasonality and marketing changes before crediting the tool.
Why most firms cannot say whether it worked
Firms buy intake tools to answer more calls, book more consultations and free staff time. A few months later, most cannot say whether any of that happened. Thomson Reuters found only 20% of legal professionals are measuring the return on investment of generative AI[1]. The usual reason is not lack of interest. It is that nobody wrote down the starting numbers before the tool went live.
- Measuring ROI 20%
Source: Thomson Reuters Institute, 2025[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Measuring ROI | 20% |
A useful measurement plan is short. It defines a few metrics, records them for a month before launch, records them again after, and accounts for the obvious reasons numbers change on their own.
Define the question first
"Is the tool worth it?" is too vague to measure. Make it specific: "Does answering after-hours calls with an AI intake tool increase signed matters from phone inquiries, and how much staff time does it save or cost?" A specific question tells you which numbers to collect, which period to compare and what result would make you keep, change or drop the tool.
Capture a baseline before switch-on
Pick the period
Use the 30 days before launch, and note anything unusual, such as a holiday or a marketing campaign.
Count inquiries by channel and hour
From the phone system and web forms: total new inquiries, and how many arrived outside office hours.
Count missed and abandoned calls
Calls that went to voicemail or hung up, especially from new numbers.
Record conversion steps
Consultations booked, consultations held and matters signed from those inquiries.
Measure response time
Median time from first contact to first meaningful response.
Log staff time
Ask intake staff to log time spent on calls, callbacks and voicemail for two typical weeks.
The metrics to track
| Metric | How to measure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| New inquiries | Count by channel and by hour | Phone system, forms, CRM |
| Missed new-inquiry calls | Calls to voicemail or abandoned | Phone system |
| Median time to first response | First contact to first real reply | CRM or call logs |
| Consultations booked per inquiry | Bookings divided by new inquiries | Calendar and CRM |
| Matters signed per consultation | Signed engagements divided by consultations held | Practice management |
| Staff intake time | Hours per week on calls, callbacks and voicemail | Time log |
| Review time for AI records | Hours per week reviewing summaries | Time log |
| Errors and complaints | Material summary errors and caller complaints | Review log |
The cost side
- The tool's subscription and any usage-based charges, as quoted to your firm.
- Set-up time: writing scripts, testing and approvals, valued at the rates of the people who did it.
- Ongoing review time: the daily check of summaries and the monthly supervision review.
- Phone system changes, if any.
- Training time for staff who use the outputs.
Review time is the cost most often left out. A tool that saves ten hours of answering calls but adds eight hours of checking summaries is a smaller win than it looks.
Value staff time by role
Time saved is worth what the person's time costs. The median hourly pay was $76.76 for US lawyers and $18.27 for receptionists in May 2025[2][3], and paralegals and legal assistants earned a median of $62,890 a year[4]. Employer costs run higher than wages: benefits made up 30.0% of private employer compensation costs in June 2026[5]. Use your own payroll figures where you can, and value each hour saved at the rate of the person who no longer spends it. An hour a lawyer no longer spends returning voicemails is worth several times an hour of receptionist time.
Value additional signed matters
The larger value is usually in matters you would otherwise have lost. Reachability is part of the reason: Pew found 67% of Americans generally do not answer calls from unknown numbers but will check a voicemail[6], so callbacks to people who reached voicemail often fail. The formula is simple: additional signed matters equals the change in signed matters per inquiry multiplied by inquiries, and value equals additional matters multiplied by your average fee per matter in that practice area. Use net fees after referral fees and costs, and be conservative.
A worked example
Example (fictional): a three-lawyer injury and employment firm records a baseline month: 120 new phone inquiries, 30 missed after hours, 36 consultations and 12 signed matters. Staff log 22 hours a week on calls and voicemail. After launching an AI intake tool for evenings, weekends and overflow, a comparable month shows 124 inquiries, 4 missed, 45 consultations and 15 signed matters. Staff log 14 hours a week on calls plus 4 hours reviewing summaries, a net saving of 4 hours a week. The firm credits the tool with about 3 additional signed matters a month, values them at its conservative average net fee, adds the staff time saved at payroll cost, and compares the total with the tool's cost plus set-up and review time.
Example check: before crediting the tool, the firm compares the same month a year earlier and confirms no marketing campaign started during the test. Signed matters in the prior-year month were flat, which supports the comparison.
Traps that distort the result
- Seasonality. Injury intake rises in summer; family law has its own peaks. Compare like months or use a control period.
- Marketing changes. A new ad campaign during the test will raise inquiries regardless of the tool.
- Counting calls instead of clients. More answered calls only matter if they become consultations and signed matters.
- Ignoring quality. A tool that books more consultations that should never have been booked adds cost.
- Short tests. One week is noise; a month is a minimum for most small firms.
- Forgetting review time on the cost side.
Measures that are not money
Some benefits do not show in fees. Ask staff whether the work is more manageable, track caller complaints and compliments, and note whether lawyers are interrupted less during focused work. Watch for negatives too: callers who dislike speaking to an AI, summaries that need heavy correction, or escalations that failed. A tool that makes the numbers look good while staff quietly redo its work is not a success.
When several things changed at once
Real firms rarely change one thing at a time. If you launched the tool in the same month you redesigned the website or hired a new intake person, you cannot cleanly separate the effects. Two simple techniques help. Compare channels the tool touches with channels it does not, such as after-hours calls against daytime web forms. Or switch the tool on for one practice area or one phone line first, and compare it with the others for a month.
Questions partners will ask
- How many more matters did we sign, and how sure are we the tool caused it?
- What did it cost in total, including staff time to set it up and review it?
- Did anything go wrong, such as a missed escalation or a complaint?
- What would happen if we switched it off tomorrow?
- What would we change to get more from it?
Answer them in the one-page report before anyone asks. It shortens the meeting and makes the decision easier to revisit later.
Review at 30, 60 and 90 days
Day 30
Compare with the baseline. Fix configuration problems: scripts, escalations, booking rules. Do not judge value yet.
Day 60
Compare again. Check the trend in signed matters and staff time. Reduce review time if error rates are low.
Day 90
Decide: keep, change or stop. Write down the reason and the numbers behind it.
Report it in one page
Give partners a single page: the question, the baseline and after numbers for each metric, the cost, the value of time saved and additional matters, the main caveats, and a recommendation. Keep the raw logs in case anyone wants to check. Repeat the measurement whenever you change the tool's scope, such as adding a practice area or a new language, because the answer for one use does not automatically carry over to the next.
Frequently asked questions
How do I measure the ROI of an AI intake tool?
Record a 30-day baseline of inquiries, missed calls, bookings, signed matters and staff time, then compare a similar period after launch, counting the tool's full cost including review time.
How many firms measure AI ROI?
Only 20% of legal professionals surveyed by Thomson Reuters said they measure the return on generative AI[1].
How long should the test run?
At least a month after launch, with reviews at 30, 60 and 90 days, and a comparison with a similar baseline period.
What is the most common mistake?
Not capturing a baseline before launch. Without one, there is nothing reliable to compare.
References
Thomson Reuters Institute (2025). 2025 GenAI report: Executive summary for legal professionals (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Lawyers: Occupational Outlook Handbook (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Receptionists: Occupational Outlook Handbook (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Paralegals and Legal Assistants: Occupational Outlook Handbook (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Employer Costs for Employee Compensation - June 2026 (opens in a new tab) โ
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) โ