Client Experience

Measuring Net Promoter Score at a Law Firm

How to run Net Promoter Score at a law firm: the question, the math, when to ask, small-sample pitfalls and the follow-up that turns a score into fixes.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. What NPS measures, and what it doesn't
  2. The method, step by step
  3. A worked example
  4. When and how to ask at a law firm
  5. Small samples and other traps
  6. Segment before you conclude anything
  7. The follow-up matters more than the score
  8. What tends to drive law firm scores
  9. Share the results with the whole team
  10. Benchmark against yourself
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References
Client Experience: Measuring Net Promoter Score at a Law FirmArticle coverCLIENT EXPERIENCEMeasuring Net PromoterScore at a Law FirmAva for LawyersInsightsClient Experience: Measuring Net Promoter Score at a Law FirmArticle coverCLIENT EXPERIENCEMeasuring NetPromoter Score at aLaw FirmAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • NPS asks one question on a 0 to 10 scale and subtracts the share of detractors (0 to 6) from the share of promoters (9 to 10)[1].
  • At a small firm, a handful of answers moves the score a lot; track rolling quarters and read every comment.
  • The follow-up question, what is the main reason for your score, is where the useful information is.
  • Responsiveness drives recommendations: in a 2024 secret-shopper study, prospects who spoke to someone by phone were more than three times as likely to recommend the firm as average[2].

What NPS measures, and what it doesn't

Net Promoter Score is a single loyalty number built from one question: how likely are you to recommend us to a friend or colleague? For law firms, where most new matters come from referrals and reputation, that question is close to the one that matters commercially. It is simple to ask, easy to repeat and comparable over time.

It is also blunt. NPS tells you whether clients would recommend you; it does not tell you why. It mixes the experience of service with the outcome of the case, which the firm cannot fully control. A personal injury client who received less than they hoped may score the firm low even when the service was excellent. Treat NPS as a smoke detector, not a diagnosis. When it moves, the comments and the follow-up conversations tell you what is burning.

The method, step by step

  1. Ask the standard question

    Use the standard wording, how likely are you to recommend us to a friend or colleague, on a scale from 0 to 10[1]. For consumer practices, friend or family member reads more naturally; keep whichever wording you choose consistent.

  2. Classify each answer

    Promoters answer 9 or 10, passives 7 or 8, and detractors 0 to 6[1].

  3. Calculate the score

    Subtract the percentage of detractors from the percentage of promoters[1]. Passives count in the total but in neither group, so the score runs from minus 100 to plus 100.

  4. Ask why

    Follow with one open question: what is the main reason for your score? This is the part you will act on.

  5. Record the context

    Store the practice area, the attorney, the stage of the matter and the date with each answer, so you can see patterns later.

A worked example

Example quarter of NPS responses at a fictional firm
AnswerGroupResponses (Example)
9 or 10Promoters22
7 or 8Passives10
0 to 6Detractors8
TotalAll respondents40

In this Example, 22 of 40 respondents are promoters, which is 55%, and 8 of 40 are detractors, which is 20%. The score is 55 minus 20, or 35. If two of the passives had answered 9 instead of 8, promoters would rise to 60% and the score to 40. That sensitivity is the main thing small firms need to understand before they put the number on a dashboard.

When and how to ask at a law firm

  • At matter close, within a week, so the experience is fresh but the outcome is known.
  • At a mid-matter milestone for long cases, so you hear about problems while you can still fix them.
  • Annually for ongoing business clients, as a relationship check separate from any single matter.
  • By email or text link from a named person, never as a cold call.
  • As the first question in a short survey, followed by the open why question and two or three service questions.
  • Never immediately after a bad ruling, unless you are deliberately measuring how you handled bad news.

Decide in advance whether answers are anonymous. Linked answers let you call detractors, which is valuable; anonymous answers may be more candid. Many firms link answers but tell clients who will read them and why.

Small samples and other traps

A firm that closes thirty matters a quarter and gets responses from half of them has fifteen answers. One extra detractor moves the score by several points. Quarter-to-quarter swings will mostly be noise, and attorneys will be tempted to read meaning into them.

  • Track a rolling four-quarter score alongside the quarterly one.
  • Report the number of responses next to every score.
  • Do not compare individual attorneys on small samples; it breeds resentment and gaming.
  • Do not set staff bonuses on NPS. People will start choosing who gets surveyed.
  • Watch the response rate. A rising score with falling responses may mean only happy clients are answering.

Segment before you conclude anything

A firm-wide score hides the differences that matter. Once you have a year of answers, split them in a few simple ways and look for the group that is pulling the score down. You will usually find that the problem is narrower than it looked, which makes it easier to fix.

  • By practice area: a family law team and an estate planning team serve clients under very different stress, and their scores should not be averaged into one story.
  • By matter stage: compare mid-matter answers with closing answers to see whether clients sour during the long middle of a case.
  • By outcome: separate matters that ended as the client hoped from those that did not, so you can judge service apart from results.
  • By contact pattern: compare clients who had a named paralegal with those who did not, or clients who used the portal with those who relied on calls.
  • By how the matter started: referred clients often score differently from clients who found the firm through advertising.

Keep each segment large enough to mean something. If a segment has only a few answers, read the comments rather than calculating a score for it.

The follow-up matters more than the score

Every detractor deserves a personal call within two business days, made by someone senior enough to fix things. The goal is to understand, not to argue the score up.

Detractor call script: β€œThank you for being honest in the survey. I'm calling because I'd like to understand what we got wrong. You mentioned you often didn't hear back from us. Can you tell me more about when that happened? … That's helpful. Here's what we're going to change, and I'll let you know when it's in place.”

Promoters deserve a thank-you too. You may invite them to leave a public review, since 82% of US adults at least sometimes read online reviews before a first purchase[3]. Keep that invitation separate from the survey and unconditional: the FTC's 2024 rule prohibits incentives conditioned on the writing of consumer reviews[4], and state lawyer advertising rules add their own limits.

What tends to drive law firm scores

Clients judge firms on what they can see, and what they see most is communication. A 2024 secret-shopper study of US law firms, summarized by the Illinois Supreme Court Commission on Professionalism, found that only 12% of people who contacted firms said they were likely to recommend them to friends or family[2].

Secret-shopper prospects likely to recommend the US law firm they contacted, 2024
Secret-shopper prospects likely to recommend the US law firm they contacted, 2024Donut chart. Likely to recommend: 12%.Likely to recommend: 12%12%
  • Likely to recommend 12%

Source: Illinois Supreme Court Commission on Professionalism (2Civility), 2024[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
Likely to recommend12%

The same study found that prospects who spoke with someone by phone were more than three times as likely to recommend the firm as the average, and nearly eight times as likely as those who only received a voicemail follow-up[2]. Current clients behave similarly: being able to reach a person is a strong driver of loyalty. If your detractor comments keep mentioning unreturned calls, look at coverage first. An SI Employee such as Ava can answer when staff are in court or on other lines, follow your approved script and pass a summary to the right person, which keeps callers from hitting voicemail.

Share the results with the whole team

NPS only changes behavior if the people who answer phones, draft letters and send bills see it. Share the rolling score, the number of responses and three representative comments at a monthly team meeting, with names removed. Celebrate specific praise, such as a client who mentioned a paralegal by name for explaining the process, because it shows staff what good looks like. Then name the single improvement the firm is working on and report progress on it until it is done.

Benchmark against yourself

Published NPS benchmarks for law firms vary widely by source, method and practice area, and many come from vendors with an interest in the result. Your own trend is a better guide. Set a baseline over your first two or three quarters, then aim to move the rolling score and, more importantly, to shrink the most common detractor reason.

Example (fictional): a commercial litigation boutique started at a rolling score in the low twenties. Detractor comments clustered around surprise invoices. The firm introduced monthly budget-versus-actual notes for every active matter. A year later the rolling score had climbed into the forties, and billing had dropped from the most common detractor reason to the third. For how to turn comments like these into process changes, see turning client complaints into process fixes and our guide to client satisfaction surveys.

Frequently asked questions

How is Net Promoter Score calculated?

Ask how likely clients are to recommend you on a 0 to 10 scale. Promoters answer 9 or 10, detractors 0 to 6. Subtract the percentage of detractors from the percentage of promoters.

Is NPS useful for a small law firm?

Yes, as a trend and a prompt to follow up, but small samples make quarterly scores noisy. Track rolling scores, report response counts and read every comment.

Should we tie staff bonuses to NPS?

No. It encourages choosing who gets surveyed and pressuring clients. Use NPS to find problems, not to rank people.

What is a good NPS for a law firm?

Published benchmarks vary by method and source. Set your own baseline and work to improve the rolling score and reduce the most common detractor reason.

References

  1. Bain & Company (n.d.). Measuring Your Net Promoter Score (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Illinois Supreme Court Commission on Professionalism (2Civility) (2024). Phone Calls Ignored, Emails Unanswered: Fixing the First Impression Problem for Law Firms (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Pew Research Center (2016). Online reviews and ratings (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Federal Trade Commission (2024). Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo