Staffing and Training

Making Your First Hire as a Solo Attorney: Triggers and Roles

When a solo lawyer should hire, which role should come first, the alternatives to an employee, the full cost and the employer setup checklist.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing6 min read

On this page
  1. You are not behind if you haven't hired
  2. The triggers that justify a hire
  3. Measure the bottleneck for two weeks
  4. Which role should come first
  5. What each candidate role costs
  6. Alternatives worth trying first
  7. Becoming an employer: the setup checklist
  8. Hiring the right person for a one-person office
  9. Example: a criminal defense solo's first hire
  10. Your first 30 days as an employer
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References
Staffing and Training: Making Your First Hire as a Solo Attorney: Triggers and RolesArticle coverSTAFFING AND TRAININGMaking Your First Hireas a Solo Attorney:Triggers and RolesAva for LawyersInsightsStaffing and Training: Making Your First Hire as a Solo Attorney: Triggers and RolesArticle coverSTAFFING AND TRAININGMaking Your FirstHire as a SoloAttorney: Triggersand RolesAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • Many solos never hire: there were 274,000 nonemployer legal services businesses in the US in 2023[1].
  • Hire when a specific bottleneck is costing you clients or billable hours, not when you feel busy; name the bottleneck first.
  • Match the first role to the bottleneck: phones and scheduling, substantive work, or billing and administration each point to a different hire.
  • Price the whole cost; in legal services, mean annual wages ran from $39,240 for receptionists to $64,270 for paralegals in May 2023[2].

You are not behind if you haven't hired

Solo practice without staff is normal. Census data count 274,000 nonemployer legal services businesses in 2023, self-employed practitioners with no paid employees, with combined receipts of $23.2 billion[1]. Among law offices that do have employees, most are tiny: 71.8% had fewer than 5 employees in 2023[3].

That context matters because the pressure to hire often comes from comparison rather than need. The right question is not whether a practice your size should have staff. It is which specific bottleneck is costing you clients, revenue or your health, and what is the cheapest reliable way to remove it.

The triggers that justify a hire

  • Missed calls: prospective clients reach voicemail during court, meetings or evenings, and some never call back.
  • Admin creep: scheduling, invoicing, filing and correspondence take a growing share of each day, and they happen at your hourly opportunity cost.
  • Substantive backlog: drafting, records and discovery tasks pile up and deadlines get tight.
  • Declined work: you are turning away matters you want because you can't process them.
  • Hours: most lawyers work full time and some work more than 40 hours a week[4]; if your week has become unsustainable, that is a business problem as much as a personal one.
  • Stable revenue: several months of predictable revenue that could cover a salary without your own draw collapsing in a slow month.

Write down which of these is the biggest. It determines the first role.

Measure the bottleneck for two weeks

Before deciding, put numbers on the problem. Two weeks of simple tracking is usually enough to tell you which role you need and whether the need is steady or seasonal.

  • Calls: how many new-matter calls went to voicemail, how long callbacks took, and how many callers had already hired someone else when you reached them.
  • Time: a rough log of your day in half-hour blocks, marked lawyer work, delegable substantive work, or administration.
  • Backlog: matters waiting on a task you could have handed off, and how long they have waited.
  • Revenue: invoices that went out late, and time you wrote off because the work should have been done at a lower rate.

The log often surprises solos. Many expect to find a drafting backlog and instead find that phone tag and scheduling consume an hour or more a day. Others find the reverse. Either way, the numbers turn a vague feeling of being overwhelmed into a job description, and they give you a baseline to judge the hire against at day 90.

Which role should come first

Match the first hire to the bottleneck
Main bottleneckFirst hire to considerAlternatives before an employee
Missed calls and slow intakeReceptionist or intake coordinator, part-time or full-timeAnswering service, virtual receptionist, AI call answering with booking
Scheduling, correspondence, filingLegal assistant or legal secretaryVirtual assistant, better scheduling and e-filing tools
Drafting, records, discoveryParalegalContract or freelance paralegal for surges
Billing, collections, bookkeepingPart-time office manager or bookkeeperOutsourced bookkeeping, practice management billing tools
Everything at onceA hybrid legal assistant with a clear priority ruleCombine one service for calls with a part-time assistant

For most solos, the first two bottlenecks show up first. A paralegal pays off most clearly when substantive work is the constraint; see hiring your first paralegal and paralegal vs legal assistant for that decision.

What each candidate role costs

In May 2023, mean annual wages for support roles in legal services were $39,240 for receptionists and information clerks, $42,600 for general office clerks, $56,600 for legal secretaries and administrative assistants, and $64,270 for paralegals and legal assistants[2]. Local markets vary, and part-time roles scale down accordingly.

Mean annual wage for support roles in US legal services, May 2023
Mean annual wage for support roles in US legal services, May 2023Bar chart. Receptionists and information clerks: $39,240; General office clerks: $42,600; Legal secretaries and administrative assistants: $56,600; Paralegals and legal assistants: $64,270.Receptionists and information clerksReceptionists and information clerks: $39,240$39,240General office clerksGeneral office clerks: $42,600$42,600Legal secretaries and administrative assistantsLegal secretaries and administrative assistants: $56,600$56,600Paralegals and legal assistantsParalegals and legal assistants: $64,270$64,270Mean annual wage for support roles in US legal services, May 2023Bar chart. Receptionists and information clerks: $39,240; General office clerks: $42,600; Legal secretaries and administrative assistants: $56,600; Paralegals and legal assistants: $64,270.Receptionists and information clerksReceptionists and information clerks: $39,240$39,240General office clerksGeneral office clerks: $42,600$42,600Legal secretaries and administrativeassistantsLegal secretaries and administrative assistants: $56,600$56,600Paralegals and legal assistantsParalegals and legal assistants: $64,270$64,270

Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2023[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
Receptionists and information clerks$39,240
General office clerks$42,600
Legal secretaries and administrative assistants$56,600
Paralegals and legal assistants$64,270

Then add the cost of employment beyond wages. In June 2026, benefits made up 30.0% of private-industry employer compensation costs[5]. A small practice may offer less than the average, but payroll taxes, workers' compensation insurance, paid leave, equipment and software seats are unavoidable.

Example (fictional): A solo family lawyer plans a full-time legal assistant at $25 an hour. Using a 30% benefits share as a planning estimate, total compensation is about $25 divided by 0.70, or $35.71 an hour, roughly $74,300 a year at 2,080 hours. Adding a computer, a phone seat and software brings the first-year cost to about $77,000. If the assistant frees 15 hours of her week and she converts even half of those into billable or consultation time, the hire is likely to pay for itself within the year, and the other half buys back evenings.

Alternatives worth trying first

If the bottleneck is narrow, a service may solve it with less risk than an employee. Answering services and virtual receptionists cover phones. Contract paralegals cover surges. Bookkeepers handle billing. If missed calls are the main problem, an SI Employee such as Ava can answer every new call, follow your approved intake questions, route urgent calls and book or request consultations, which may delay the need for a front-desk hire.

Use alternatives as experiments with a deadline. Run one for 60 to 90 days, track the bottleneck you named, and decide. If the service fixes it, you have avoided an employer commitment. If it doesn't, you have learned exactly what the employee must do.

Becoming an employer: the setup checklist

  1. Register for payroll

    Federal employer identification, state withholding and unemployment insurance accounts, and a payroll provider.

  2. Insurance

    Workers' compensation coverage as your state requires, and check whether your malpractice and office policies need updating for staff.

  3. Hiring paperwork

    Employment eligibility verification, tax withholding forms, state new-hire reporting.

  4. Policies

    A short handbook: hours, pay, leave, technology use and confidentiality. Have the confidentiality agreement signed on day one.

  5. Access and security

    Separate logins for every system, with the minimum access needed. Never share your own passwords.

  6. Supervision plan

    Decide how you will review work and handle calls. Model Rule 5.3 makes supervising nonlawyer staff part of your professional responsibility.

State rules on posting pay ranges, paid sick leave and employee classification vary. Check them for your state before posting the job.

Hiring the right person for a one-person office

Your first employee works without colleagues to learn from or cover for them. Look for reliability, judgment and comfort working with little supervision, and test the actual tasks: a mock call, a scheduling exercise, a drafting sample. Be honest in the interview about what a solo office is like: varied work, close contact with you, no layers to hide behind. The best first hires find that appealing.

Consider part-time first if your volume is uncertain. It is far easier to raise hours for someone who is working out than to cut them for someone you hired full-time too early.

Example: a criminal defense solo's first hire

Example (fictional): A criminal defense solo misses calls every morning she is in court, and families of arrested clients don't wait. She first tries an answering service for 60 days and finds callers are answered but intake is thin, so she still spends evenings calling people back to collect basic facts. She then hires a part-time intake and legal assistant who works mornings, answers new-matter calls with the firm's script, handles court scheduling and sends engagement letters. After three months, she extends the role to full-time and keeps the answering service for evenings.

Your first 30 days as an employer

  • Write down the three tasks the hire owns completely and the boundaries they must never cross, such as legal advice.
  • Meet for 15 minutes every day in the first two weeks, then twice a week.
  • Review every piece of client-facing work in week one, then sample.
  • Ask at day 30 what slows them down; often the answer is a decision only you can make.

Next steps: compare domestic and offshore virtual assistants, plan how you will manage a remote intake team if the role is remote, and see keeping your cell number private as a solo attorney for call routing once someone else answers.

Frequently asked questions

When should a solo attorney hire their first employee?

When a specific bottleneck, such as missed calls, admin load or substantive backlog, is costing clients or billable time, and revenue is steady enough to cover the full cost of the role.

Should the first hire be a paralegal or an assistant?

It depends on the bottleneck. Phones and scheduling point to an assistant or receptionist; drafting, records and discovery point to a paralegal.

Is part-time a good way to start?

Often. It limits risk while you learn how much work you can delegate, and it is easier to add hours than to cut them.

What do I need to set up before hiring?

Payroll registrations, workers' compensation coverage, hiring paperwork, a short handbook with a confidentiality agreement, separate system logins and a supervision plan.

References

  1. U.S. Census Bureau (2023). Nonemployer Statistics 2023: U.S. file (nonemp23us) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2023). May 2023 National Industry-Specific Occupational Employment and Wage Estimates: NAICS 541100 - Legal Services (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. U.S. Census Bureau (2023). County Business Patterns 2023: U.S. detail file (cbp23us) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Lawyers: Occupational Outlook Handbook (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  5. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Employer Costs for Employee Compensation - June 2026 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo