Key takeaways
- Sort reviews by who wrote them: law firms first, other professional offices next, vendor testimonials and commission-earning 'best of' lists last[2].
- Weigh complaint patterns across six to twelve months, not single reviews or star averages.
- Lost or garbled messages are the costliest complaint for a law firm; turn each pattern you find into a test call.
- Reviews are part of the reputation check Rule 5.3 expects when you use an outside service, not the whole of it[3].
Star ratings answer the wrong question
A 4.7-star average tells you that most customers of an answering service were satisfied with something. It does not tell you whether the service takes a prospective client's conflict names correctly at 8 pm, whether its invoices match its quote, or whether its agents stay out of legal advice. Those are the things a law firm needs to know, and they sit in the text of a minority of reviews, usually the critical ones.
Readers already sense how noisy reviews are. In Pew's survey, 82% of US adults read online ratings or reviews at least sometimes before a first purchase, yet 48% of review readers said it is often hard to tell whether reviews are truthful and unbiased, and only about half said reviews generally give an accurate picture of quality[1]. Treat reviews as leads to investigate, then verify the ones that matter yourself.
It also helps to know what you are reviewing. The Census Bureau counted 1,035 telephone answering service establishments employing 41,582 people in 2023[4]. That is a field of many separate call floors, each with its own training, staffing and management. A review describes the habits of one operation at one point in time, not the category, and not necessarily the team that would answer your line.
Know who wrote the review
Answering services sell to dental offices, plumbers, property managers and law firms. A plumber praising friendly agents who book jobs fast says little about intake for a criminal defense practice. Before weighing any review, sort it by source.
- Reviews from law firms. The most useful, especially when they name the practice area or describe intake, conflict questions or after-hours routing.
- Reviews from other professional offices. Good evidence on billing, reliability and account management; weaker on scripts.
- The vendor's own testimonials. Chosen by the vendor. The FTC's 2024 rule prohibits certain reviews by company insiders that do not clearly disclose their connection to the business[5], so look for that disclosure on anything that reads like staff.
- 'Best answering services' comparison sites. Many earn a commission when you sign up. FTC guidance says affiliates should disclose that clearly and close to the recommendation; 'paid link' beside the link is adequate, 'commissionable link' probably is not[2]. The same FTC rule bars a business from presenting a site it controls as an independent reviewer of a category that includes its own services[5].
- Map and directory reviews. Google's policy removes reviews that were paid for, written under a conflict of interest such as employment or a contractual relationship, or posted to undermine a competitor, and it bars businesses from selectively soliciting positive reviews[6]. Enforcement is imperfect, so read for patterns.
Look at dates too. A cluster of five-star reviews in one week, with similar wording and no detail, deserves a discount. A run of complaints after a known event, such as a platform change or a merger, may describe a problem the vendor has since fixed, or one it still has. Ask which.
Read the vendor's replies as closely as the reviews. A reply that names the problem, says what changed and invites the customer to call an account manager tells you how your own complaints would be handled. A reply that argues the facts in public, hints at the customer's mistakes or pastes the same apology under every review tells you the opposite. No reply at all to a detailed complaint about lost messages is an answer too. Keep a note of the three most specific replies and ask about them on the sales call.
What complaint patterns reveal
One angry review is an anecdote. The same complaint in different words from different customers over six months is a pattern, and patterns map to how a service is run.
| Complaint pattern | What it usually points to | What to verify |
|---|---|---|
| Messages missing, late or with wrong numbers | Agents juggling many accounts; no read-back of names and numbers | Leave a test message with an unusual name and a number with repeated digits; time the delivery |
| Bills higher than the quote | Per-minute rounding, minimums, set-up fees, holiday or after-hours surcharges | Ask for a sample invoice at your volume and the rounding rule in writing |
| Agents 'just read a script' | Generic scripts with no room for follow-up questions | Call with an off-script question and listen to how it is handled |
| Agent gave a caller wrong information | Stale account notes or weak training on client instructions | Change one fact in your instructions, then test whether it is used the next day |
| Long rings or hold music | Too few agents at peak hours | Place test calls at 9 am Monday and 5:30 pm Friday |
| Hard to cancel | Auto-renewal and long notice periods | Read the term, renewal and notice clauses before the demo ends |
Messages
Lost, late or garbled details, especially names and callback numbers
Billing
Invoices that do not match the quote: rounding, minimums, surcharges
Scripts
Agents who cannot handle a question outside the script
Boundaries
Agents who promise callbacks or comment on a caller's case
Weigh these above politeness and hold music; each one maps to a test you can run before signing.
Law-firm red flags in review text
Some phrases matter more to a law firm than to a plumber. Look for them in reviews from any industry, because they describe agent behavior that would become an ethics problem on your line.
- 'The agent told my customer...' An agent who interprets or advises will do it for your callers too. Under ABA Formal Opinion 506, questions about what legal services a person needs and about fees belong to the lawyer[7].
- 'They promised a callback within the hour.' A service that makes promises on your behalf creates expectations nobody at the firm agreed to.
- 'The message went to the wrong person.' On a law-firm line, a routing error can send a prospective client's details to an attorney who should never have seen them.
- 'I couldn't get my call recordings' or 'they lost our account notes.' Ask how recordings, transcripts and messages are stored and who at the vendor can see them.
Supervision makes this your problem, not only the vendor's. Comment [3] to Model Rule 5.3, quoted in ABA Formal Opinion 498, says a lawyer using an outside service must make reasonable efforts to ensure it is provided in a way compatible with the lawyer's obligations, and that the extent of the duty depends on factors including the provider's experience and reputation and the terms protecting client information[3]. Reviews feed that reputation check. They are not the whole of it.
What a lost message costs
The most common serious complaint is also the plainest: the message was wrong or never arrived. For a law firm that is more than an inconvenience. A prospective client whose number was taken down wrong cannot be called back, and one called back late may not pick up, since only 19% of US adults generally answer calls from unknown numbers[8]. The first callback attempt has to go to the right number, quickly.
| Input | Example |
|---|---|
| Calls the service answers a week | 40 |
| Messages lost, late or garbled (%) | 5% |
| Share that are new matters (%) | 40% |
| New matters that retain the firm (%) | 25% |
| Average fee per new matter ($) | $4,000 |
| Unanswered calls a month | 8.7 |
| From new customers | 3.5 |
| Bookings that would have followed | 0.9 |
| Monthly value at risk | $3,464 |
How it is worked out: Calls a week ร 4.33 weeks ร unanswered share ร new-customer share ร booking rate ร average value.
Assumptions
Example only. Replace every input with figures from your own call log and test calls.
Example: in this setup a 5% error rate puts about $3,460 a month at risk, or roughly $41,600 a year. That is why a pattern of message errors deserves more weight in your reading than any number of comments about friendly agents.
Turn reviews into test calls
Reviews tell you where to look; test calls tell you what you would actually get. Before signing, place five calls built from the complaints you found and score them the same way. Testing your answering service with test calls has a full scorecard; the steps below are the short version for a buying decision.
Pick the three most repeated complaints
From reviews in the last 12 months, note the three complaints that appear most often, plus any that came from law firms.
Write one persona per complaint
For messages, a caller with an unusual surname and a number with repeated digits. For scripts, a question your instructions do not cover. For boundaries, a caller who asks whether they have a case.
Call at the hard times
Monday at 9 am, Friday after 5 pm and once after 10 pm. Note the rings before an answer and any time on hold.
Compare what you said with what arrived
Check spelling, numbers, the urgency flag and delivery time against your script. One wrong digit fails the call.
Ask the vendor about every failure
A good vendor explains what went wrong and what will change. A defensive one tells you more than any review.
- Your team
- Caller
- System
01Your team
Pattern spotted
Three reviews in six months mention garbled callback numbers.
02Your team
Test persona written
A caller with a hyphenated surname and a number with repeated digits.
03Caller
Test call placed
Friday at 5:40 pm; the tester gives each detail once, at normal speed.
04System
Message delivered
The service's message or call summary arrives by email or in its portal.
05Your team
Scored against the script
Name, number, urgency and delivery time checked; any error fails the call.
Example. One verified test call tells you more than twenty unverified reviews.
Apply the same tests to every option, including an SI Employee. You can have one call you and put the same awkward questions to it that you would put to a human service: an unusual surname, a number with repeated digits, a question about whether you have a case.
Questions reviews cannot answer
Some things never appear in reviews because customers only discover them months later. Ask these in writing and check the answers against the contract.
- How is a call billed: per minute or per call, what rounding increment, what monthly minimum? Get a sample invoice. Answering service hidden fees lists the usual line items.
- What is the notice period to cancel, and does the term renew automatically? See answering service contract terms for law firms.
- Who at the vendor can hear recordings or read messages, and how long are they kept?
- What happens to your number and call history if you leave?
- Who is your contact when a message goes wrong, and how quickly do they respond?
Then compare the answers with what the reviews hinted at. If complaints mention surprise invoices and the vendor will not show a sample bill, the reviews were right. The scoring sheet in how to choose a legal answering service keeps the comparison fair, and the estate planning example shows what a fully specified intake script looks like before you test anyone against it.
Frequently asked questions
Are Google reviews of answering services reliable?
Partly. Google removes paid, incentivized and conflict-of-interest reviews when it finds them[6], but nearly half of review readers say it is often hard to tell which reviews are truthful[1]. Read for patterns and verify them with test calls.
Should we trust 'best answering service' comparison sites?
Use them as a list of names, not a ranking. Many earn commissions, which the FTC says should be disclosed clearly[2], and a business may not present a site it controls as an independent reviewer of its own category[5].
What is the most important complaint to look for?
Lost, late or garbled messages. Politeness can be trained; a service that cannot reliably record a name and a callback number will cost you new matters.
How many test calls should we make before choosing?
At least five per vendor, at busy and after-hours times, each built from a complaint you found in reviews. Score every call the same way.
Do reviews of AI answering tools need different reading?
The same method works. Look for complaints about wrong information, callers who could not reach a person and summaries that missed details, then test those exact situations.
References
Pew Research Center (2016). Online reviews and ratings (opens in a new tab) โ
Federal Trade Commission (2026). FTC's Endorsement Guides: What People Are Asking (opens in a new tab) โ
American Bar Association Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility (2021). Formal Opinion 498: Virtual Practice (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Census Bureau (2023). County Business Patterns 2023: U.S. detail file (cbp23us), NAICS 561421 Telephone Answering Services (opens in a new tab) โ
Federal Trade Commission (2024). Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (opens in a new tab) โ
Google Maps Help (Google) (2026). Maps user-generated content policy: prohibited and restricted content (opens in a new tab) โ
American Bar Association Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility (2023). ABA Formal Opinion 506: Responsibilities Regarding Nonlawyer Assistants (opens in a new tab) โ
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) โ