Staffing and Training

Hiring for Empathy in Client-Facing Roles

How law firms screen receptionists and intake staff for empathy and calm: a behavioral scorecard, structured interview questions and a role-play.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing6 min read

On this page
  1. Why empathy is a core skill at a law firm
  2. Define empathy as behavior
  3. Write the scorecard before you advertise
  4. Where empathetic candidates come from
  5. A structured screening process
  6. Interview questions that reveal empathy
  7. Running the upset-caller role-play
  8. Keep bias out of empathy screening
  9. Reference questions that help
  10. Example: choosing between two finalists
  11. Protect empathy after you hire it
  12. Frequently asked questions
  13. References
Staffing and Training: Hiring for Empathy in Client-Facing RolesArticle coverSTAFFING AND TRAININGHiring for Empathy inClient-Facing RolesAva for LawyersInsightsStaffing and Training: Hiring for Empathy in Client-Facing RolesArticle coverSTAFFING AND TRAININGHiring for Empathy inClient-Facing RolesAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • Callers to law firms are often worried about cost: 46% of low-income Americans who did not seek legal help cited cost concerns[1].
  • Define empathy as observable behavior, such as listening, naming the concern and keeping structure, and score it, rather than hiring on a "good feeling".
  • Structured interviews with the same questions and scoring benchmarks are more valid and reliable than unstructured conversations[2].
  • Use an upset-caller role-play, score calm and boundaries as well as warmth, and never score accent[3].

Why empathy is a core skill at a law firm

People rarely call a law firm on a good day. They have been arrested, injured, served with papers, left by a spouse or threatened with eviction. Many are also worried about money. In the Legal Services Corporation's Justice Gap research, 46% of low-income Americans who did not seek legal help for a problem cited concerns about cost, and 53% did not know whether they could find and afford a lawyer if they needed one[1].

Cost worries among low-income Americans facing legal problemsLegal Services Corporation, Justice Gap research
Cost worries among low-income Americans facing legal problemsColumn chart. Did not seek help and cited cost concerns: 46%; Unsure they could find and afford a lawyer: 53%.0%20%40%60%Did not seek help and cited cost concerns: 46%46%Did not seek help and cited cost concernsUnsure they could find and afford a lawyer: 53%53%Unsure they could find and afford a lawyerCost worries among low-income Americans facing legal problemsColumn chart. Did not seek help and cited cost concerns: 46%; Unsure they could find and afford a lawyer: 53%.Did not seek help and cited costconcernsDid not seek help and cited cost concerns: 46%46%Unsure they could find and afford alawyerUnsure they could find and afford a lawyer: 53%53%

Source: Legal Services Corporation, 2022[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Did not seek help and cited cost concerns46%
Unsure they could find and afford a lawyer53%

Those callers also start with some suspicion. Gallup's December 2025 poll found only 20% of Americans rate lawyers' honesty and ethical standards high or very high[4]. The receptionist or intake coordinator is the first person who can change that impression, or confirm it. Empathy in these roles is not a soft extra; it decides whether frightened people stay on the line long enough to get help.

Define empathy as behavior

"Empathetic" on a job post means little. Turn it into things you can observe and score:

  • Listens without interrupting for the first part of the call, then summarizes what they heard.
  • Names the concern in plain words: "It sounds like you're worried about the court date next week."
  • Stays calm and even when the caller is angry, crying or confused.
  • Keeps structure: moves the call toward the information needed without rushing.
  • Holds boundaries kindly: does not give legal advice or make promises to make someone feel better.

The last point matters. In a law firm, the kindest-sounding answer, "Don't worry, you'll win," can be the most harmful. The right hire combines warmth with discipline.

Write the scorecard before you advertise

An empathy scorecard for receptionist and intake roles. Score each 1-5.
CompetencyWhat good looks likeRed flags
ListeningReflects back key facts accurately; asks clarifying questionsInterrupts early; gets facts wrong
Calm under pressureEven tone with an upset caller; slows down rather than speeding upMatches the caller's anger; becomes defensive
WarmthAcknowledges feelings briefly and sincerelyScripted sympathy; no acknowledgement at all
StructureGuides the call to the next stepLets the call wander with no outcome
BoundariesDeclines to advise; offers the attorney consultationReassures with predictions or advice
ResilienceCan describe how they recover after hard conversationsSays hard calls never bother them

Where empathetic candidates come from

Some of the best client-facing hires have never worked in law. People who have done triage or reception at a medical practice, worked a crisis line, handled insurance claims, taught or managed a busy restaurant floor have often spent years calming upset people while keeping a process moving. Legal knowledge can be taught in weeks; the instinct to slow down when someone is distressed takes much longer to learn.

Write the job post to reach them. Lead with what the role involves, such as helping people in stressful situations get the right appointment, rather than a list of legal software. Mention that training on legal procedures is provided. And check whether your requirements, such as a paralegal certificate for a front desk role, screen out people who would be excellent at the human side of the job.

A structured screening process

  1. Post an honest job description

    Say plainly that the role involves talking with people in stressful situations. It discourages applicants who would hate the job.

  2. Phone screen

    A fifteen-minute call. Note how they handle your questions on the phone, because the phone is the job.

  3. Structured interview

    The same questions in the same order for every candidate, scored against the scorecard by at least two people.

  4. Upset-caller role-play

    A five-minute call with an interviewer playing a distressed caller. Score it on the same scorecard.

  5. Reference checks

    Ask specific questions about difficult customers or patients, not general character questions.

Structure is not bureaucracy. The U.S. Office of Personnel Management notes that interviews with higher degrees of structure show higher validity, better rater reliability and agreement, and less adverse impact than unstructured interviews[2].

Interview questions that reveal empathy

OPM distinguishes behavioral questions, which ask about past behavior, from situational questions, which ask what a candidate would do in a future scenario[2]. Use both:

  • Behavioral: "Tell me about a time someone was very upset with you or your employer. What did they say, and what did you do?"
  • Behavioral: "Describe a time you had to say no to someone who really wanted a yes."
  • Behavioral: "What do you do after a difficult conversation to get ready for the next one?"
  • Situational: "A caller says her husband was arrested last night and starts crying. What do you say first?"
  • Situational: "A caller asks whether he will lose his house. You know it is a serious foreclosure. How do you answer?"

Score the answers against benchmarks you wrote in advance. A strong answer to the foreclosure question acknowledges the fear, avoids predicting the outcome and moves to booking a consultation. A weak one either reassures falsely or reads like a script.

Running the upset-caller role-play

Give the candidate a one-paragraph brief: they are answering the firm's phone, here is the intake form, their job is to take the details and offer a consultation. The interviewer then plays a caller with a realistic story, such as a mother whose teenage son has just been charged with a crime, who is frightened, keeps asking what will happen and gets angry when she hears the consultation has a fee.

  1. Watch the first thirty seconds: does the candidate let her speak, or jump straight to the form?
  2. Watch the anger: does the candidate stay level and acknowledge it, or argue?
  3. Watch the question about outcome: does the candidate avoid predicting while still sounding human?
  4. Watch the close: does the call end with a clear next step and a confirmed number?

Run the same role-play, with the same script and the same interviewer if possible, for every candidate. Change the scenario for different roles, but not between candidates for the same job.

Keep bias out of empathy screening

Empathy judgments are easy to bias. Interviewers warm to people who sound like them. The EEOC treats unfavorable treatment because of ethnicity or accent as a form of national origin discrimination[3]. Score what the candidate does, such as listening, calm, structure and boundaries, not how they sound. Avoid scoring "culture fit," which often becomes a proxy for similarity. Two scorers working from a written scorecard are the best protection. Score independently first and only then compare notes, so the more senior interviewer does not set the score for both. Keep the scorecards with the hiring file.

Reference questions that help

  • "How did they handle customers or patients who were upset or difficult?"
  • "Can you describe a time they had to deliver bad news?"
  • "How did they cope during your busiest periods?"
  • "Would you hire them again for a role dealing with distressed people? Why?"

Example: choosing between two finalists

Example (fictional): a family law firm has two receptionist finalists. One is polished and confident in the interview; the other is quieter. In the role-play, the confident candidate reassures the upset mother that "the attorney will definitely be able to help" and rushes to the fee. The quieter candidate lets her finish, says "That sounds frightening; let's get you in front of an attorney who can explain your options," and handles the fee question calmly. Both interviewers score the quieter candidate higher on calm, boundaries and structure. She gets the job.

Protect empathy after you hire it

Empathy wears down without support. Receptionist roles turn over often, with about 105,100 openings projected each year nationally[5], and constant exposure to distressed callers is one reason. Pair good hiring with a manageable workload, regular coaching and debriefs after hard calls, as covered in preventing front desk burnout. Teach new hires the firm's responsiveness standards, bring attorneys into the same expectations through intake onboarding, and set fair pay using state wage data. If the role includes remote shifts, see hybrid front desks.

Frequently asked questions

How do you test empathy in an interview?

Use structured behavioral and situational questions scored against written benchmarks, and add a short role-play with an interviewer playing an upset caller. Score listening, calm, structure and boundaries.

What are good interview questions for a law firm receptionist?

Ask about times they handled upset people or had to say no, how they recover after difficult conversations, and what they would say first to a caller in crisis.

Can empathy be trained?

Skills such as listening, acknowledging concerns and keeping structure can be coached with call reviews. Calm under pressure and genuine interest in people are harder to teach, so screen for them.

Is too much empathy a problem at a law firm?

It can be if it leads staff to reassure callers with predictions or advice. Look for people who combine warmth with firm boundaries.

References

  1. Legal Services Corporation (2022). The Justice Gap Report: Executive Summary (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. U.S. Office of Personnel Management (2026). Structured Interviews (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (2026). National Origin Discrimination (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. Gallup (2025). Nurses Continue to Lead in Honesty and Ethics Ratings (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  5. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Receptionists: Occupational Outlook Handbook (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo