Key takeaways
- Mass litigation swings both ways: federal civil filings fell 22% to 271,802 in the year to March 2025, largely as one MDL wound down[1].
- Set up early warning for the triggers that matter to your practice, and a temporary coverage plan you can switch on within a day.
- Screen consistently with written criteria, record every disqualifier and send non-engagement letters to people you decline.
- Follow-up calls are regulated: AI-generated voices count as artificial under the TCPA[2], and damages start at $500 per violation[3].
What causes a news-driven spike
Some call surges have nothing to do with the calendar. A product recall, a published study linking a drug to an injury, a large jury verdict, a data breach notice sent to millions of people, an industrial accident or a television advertising campaign by a competitor can each send a wave of calls to injury, mass tort, consumer and employment firms within hours. The spike may last two days or two months, and most callers will not have a case.
The firms that handle spikes well treat them as an operations problem with three parts: knowing early, adding capacity quickly and screening consistently. The firms that handle them badly let the spike overwhelm normal intake, so existing clients and ordinary new matters suffer while staff field calls that will never become cases.
Volume can collapse as fast as it grows
Federal court data show how much mass litigation moves the numbers. Civil filings in US district courts fell 22% to 271,802 in the year ending March 31, 2025, largely because of a drop in cases in the 3M Combat Arms earplug multidistrict litigation[1]. Diversity-of-citizenship filings fell 51%, and personal injury and product liability filings fell 73%[4].
For a firm, the lesson is that spike-driven work is lumpy. Plan temporary capacity for a surge rather than permanent hires, and keep normal intake protected so the firm's core work continues when the wave passes.
Build an early warning list
- Product and drug recalls: subscribe to recall notices from the federal agencies that cover the products your practice handles.
- Litigation milestones: watch for new multidistrict litigation orders, bellwether trial dates and large settlements in your areas.
- Data breaches: note large breach notifications affecting your state or region.
- Local incidents: explosions, building collapses, contamination and transport accidents in your area.
- Advertising: a competitor's new television or radio campaign can raise call volume for everyone, including callers who confuse firms.
Assign one person to check these sources weekly, and to tell the managing partner the same day when something likely to produce calls appears.
Temporary coverage options
| Option | Speed to switch on | Best use |
|---|---|---|
| Overflow answering service | Hours, if instructions are pre-written | Answer every call live and capture screening details |
| Extended staff hours | One day | Short spikes of a few days |
| Borrowed staff from other teams | One day | Firms with trained paralegals in other practice areas |
| Online screening form | Hours | Callers who prefer to submit details; reduces phone load |
| Scheduled callback queue | Hours | Non-urgent callers who agree to a set callback time |
Whatever you choose, write the instructions before you need them. A spike is the worst moment to explain the firm's screening rules to a new answering service. The guide to writing call-handling instructions for your answering service covers the format.
Screen consistently
Most spike callers will not qualify. Written criteria protect both the callers and the firm: everyone is asked the same questions, decisions are recorded and people who are declined are told so clearly.
Define the case
The attorney writes down the product or event, the injury types the firm will consider, the relevant date ranges and any known disqualifiers.
Ask the same questions
Product or exposure, dates of use or exposure, diagnosis and date, treating providers, and whether the caller already has a lawyer for this matter.
Capture conflicts names
The caller, the injured person if different, and the manufacturer, seller or employer, before taking a narrative.
Score and route
Callers who meet the criteria go to an attorney review or consultation; those who clearly do not are told politely, and the reason is recorded.
Close the loop
Send a non-engagement letter to anyone the firm declines, noting that deadlines may apply and that they may wish to consult another lawyer.
Never tell a spike caller that they have a case or that a settlement is coming. Statements like that create expectations, and in some situations an argument that a lawyer-client relationship began on the phone.
A short script for spike calls
- Opening: Thank you for calling. Are you calling about the recent news about [product or event]? I can ask a few questions to see whether our attorneys can review your situation.
- Framing: I am not an attorney and cannot give legal advice. Our attorneys look at each situation individually.
- Questions: Follow the written screening criteria in order, recording each answer.
- If it may qualify: I will pass this to an attorney for review. You will hear from us by [day] at this number. Is it safe to leave a message?
- If it does not: Based on what you have told me, this is not something our firm can help with. We will send you a letter confirming that. Deadlines may apply, so you may wish to speak to another lawyer.
Follow-up calls and texts are regulated
Spikes tempt firms to follow up with automated calls or texts. Be careful. In February 2024 the FCC ruled that calls made with AI-generated voices are artificial under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act[2], and telemarketers must have prior express written consent before robocalling consumers[5]. TCPA damages are the greater of actual losses or $500 per violation, and courts may triple them for willful or knowing violations[3].
The National Do Not Call Registry held 259 million active registrations as of September 2025[6], and sellers must scrub their lists against it at least every 31 days[7]. Calls returning a person's own inquiry are different from cold outreach, but get advice before running any automated campaign. ABA Model Rule 7.3 also bars live person-to-person solicitation for pecuniary gain, with narrow exceptions.
Protect normal intake
A spike should not cost the firm its ordinary work. Keep a separate line, menu option or queue for existing clients and for new matters unrelated to the news, and make sure those callers still reach a person quickly. Review response times for normal intake daily during the spike. If they slip, add capacity to the spike queue rather than borrowing from normal intake. For very high volume, set routing tiers in advance: live answer first, then overflow, then a scheduled callback with a stated time. An SI Employee such as Ava can answer every caller live during a spike, follow the written screening questions and hand the attorney a clean summary of each call.
Co-counsel, referrals and lead sources
Large spikes often lead firms to refer cases to, or take them from, other firms, and to buy advertising or leads. Each arrangement has ethics rules attached.
- Referral and co-counsel fee divisions must meet your state's version of ABA Model Rule 1.5(e), which generally requires client agreement in writing and either a proportional split or joint responsibility.
- Paying for advertising is allowed; paying someone to recommend the firm generally is not, under Model Rule 7.2(b). Check how any lead vendor describes the firm to callers.
- Make sure every vendor's scripts and ads are reviewed before launch, because the firm is responsible for misleading statements made on its behalf.
- Keep records of where every spike case came from, so you can show the source if a bar regulator or court asks.
Example: a recall week
Example, with a fictional firm. A product liability firm learned on a Monday that a widely sold appliance had been recalled after reports of burns. It already had overflow instructions on file with its answering service; by early afternoon the service had the screening criteria. Over ten days the firm received about 400 calls. Roughly one in eight met the criteria for attorney review, and the firm sent non-engagement letters to the rest who gave contact details. Normal intake kept its usual response time because spike calls went to a separate menu option. When volume fell in the third week, the firm switched the overflow off and reviewed the screening data to refine the criteria.
Wind down and review
Spikes end quietly. Agree in advance the volume at which you will switch temporary coverage off, and review what happened: calls received, qualified rate, matters signed, cost of temporary coverage and any complaints. Update the screening criteria and instructions for next time. The same approach works for policy-driven surges, covered in immigration policy news and call surges, and for seasonal peaks such as year-end layoffs.
Frequently asked questions
How should a firm prepare for news-driven call spikes?
Keep an early warning list of triggers, pre-written screening criteria and temporary coverage instructions ready to switch on within a day.
Do most spike callers have a case?
Usually not. Screen with written criteria, record decisions and send non-engagement letters to those you decline.
Can we follow up with automated calls or texts?
Only with care. AI-generated voice calls count as artificial under the TCPA[2], telemarketing robocalls need prior express written consent[5], and damages start at $500 per violation[3]. Get advice first.
How do we stop a spike from swamping normal intake?
Give spike callers a separate queue or menu option, keep normal intake staffed and check its response times daily.
References
United States Courts (Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts) (2025). Federal Judicial Caseload Statistics 2025 (opens in a new tab) โ
Federal Communications Commission (2024). FCC Makes AI-Generated Voices in Robocalls Illegal (opens in a new tab) โ
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2025). 47 U.S. Code ยง 227 - Restrictions on use of telephone equipment (opens in a new tab) โ
United States Courts (Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts) (2025). Federal Judicial Caseload Statistics 2025 (opens in a new tab) โ
Federal Communications Commission (2024). FCC Makes AI-Generated Voices in Robocalls Illegal (opens in a new tab) โ
Federal Trade Commission (2025). National Do Not Call Registry Data Book, Fiscal Year 2025 (opens in a new tab) โ
Federal Trade Commission (2025). National Do Not Call Registry Data Book, Fiscal Year 2025 (opens in a new tab) โ