Marketing and Lead Generation

Disputing Bad Leads in Local Services Ads

How bad Local Services Ads leads are credited now, which law firm leads are never charged, how to rate leads, and the records to keep each week.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing6 min read

On this page
  1. How "disputes" work now
  2. Leads that should never be charged
  3. Bad leads law firms see, and what to do
  4. Rate every lead, every week
  5. Documentation to keep
  6. Prevent the leads credits will not cover
  7. Phone menus: a filter with a cost
  8. Answering is the best lead filter
  9. When lead quality drops suddenly
  10. Reconcile charges monthly
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References
Marketing and Lead Generation: Disputing Bad Leads in Local Services AdsArticle coverMARKETING AND LEAD GENERATIONDisputing Bad Leads inLocal Services AdsAva for LawyersInsightsMarketing and Lead Generation: Disputing Bad Leads in Local Services AdsArticle coverMARKETING AND LEAD GENERATIONDisputing Bad Leadsin Local Services AdsAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • Google now reassesses charged leads and may credit low-quality ones automatically, usually within 30 days[1].
  • Credits for "job type not serviced" or "geo not serviced" leads are no longer supported, so your settings must prevent them[1].
  • Rating leads in the dashboard improves matching and can earn a bonus credit[1].
  • Keep your own call log and intake notes, and reconcile them with charges every month.

How "disputes" work now

Many guides to Local Services Ads still describe a manual dispute button for every bad lead. Google's current help pages describe a different system. Charged leads are reassessed over time and may be credited automatically if later found to be low quality, and credits are generally applied to the account balance within 30 days[1]. The original charge stays on the invoice, with the credit shown separately[1].

Two details matter for planning. Some poor-quality leads may still be charged during the first 24 hours before the system processes them[1]. And Google says it no longer supports credits for leads about job types you do not service or areas you do not serve[1]. Those leads have to be prevented through your settings, because they will not be refunded.

Leads that should never be charged

Before thinking about credits, know what Google says it does not bill in the first place[2]:

  • Leads judged invalid or low quality at the initial assessment.
  • Callers who hang up in an automated phone menu without pressing a key to be routed.
  • Follow-up contact from the same phone number or email within 15 days of the last interaction, which is treated as the same lead.
  • Missed calls outside business hours, since only business-hours missed calls of more than 20 seconds are listed as chargeable.

If your invoices show charges that look like any of these, check the lead details and rate the lead. Repeated patterns are worth raising with Google support, with your records attached.

Bad leads law firms see, and what to do

Common bad Local Services Ads leads for law firms and how to respond
Type of leadHow it arisesWhat to do
Robocalls and spamAutomated or junk calls to the listed numberRate the lead; keep the call log entry
Sales calls to the firmVendors using the ad to reach youRate the lead; do not engage
Wrong practice areaA caller wants help the firm does not offerFix the services list; credits for this are no longer supported
Outside the service areaA caller from a county or state you do not serveTighten the service area; credits are no longer supported
Repeat callerThe same person calls again within 15 daysShould not be charged again; check and rate if it was
Job seekers and wrong numbersNot a prospective clientRate the lead
Existing client calling the ad numberAlready a clientGive clients the direct office number; rate if charged

Rate every lead, every week

Rating is now the advertiser's main lever. Google explains that you can rate a lead from the Leads page by selecting "Rate this lead" and completing the short survey; the feedback helps Google send better-matched leads and can earn a bonus credit[1]. A firm that rates consistently gives the system better information about what a good lead looks like for its practice.

  1. Set a weekly slot

    Put thirty minutes on the calendar each week for one person to review the week's leads.

  2. Match leads to your records

    Compare each charged lead with your call log and intake notes, so you rate from facts rather than memory.

  3. Rate with a clear reason

    Mark good leads as good too, not only bad ones. The pattern matters as much as the exceptions.

  4. Note fixable causes

    If several leads are for a service you do not offer or from outside your area, change the settings that day.

  5. Record the outcome

    In your intake system, mark each lead as wrong fit, consultation, signed or declined.

Documentation to keep

Your own records are what make rating accurate and any conversation with Google support productive. Keep, for each Local Services Ads lead:

  • The date, time and duration of the call, or the time of the message.
  • Whether the call was answered live, went to voicemail or was missed.
  • A short intake note: what the caller wanted and why the firm could or could not help.
  • The outcome and, for wrong-fit leads, the reason.
  • The rating you gave and the date.

Write intake notes with confidentiality in mind. They are internal business records, but they may include details from prospective clients, so keep them in the firm's systems, not in shared spreadsheets outside them. If Ava answers some of these calls, its call summaries give the reviewer the same facts staff would record.

Prevent the leads credits will not cover

Since wrong-service and wrong-area leads no longer earn credits[1], prevention is the only remedy. Review the services list line by line and remove anything the firm would decline. Narrow the service area to the counties you actually serve. Make the business description plain about what the firm does not handle where confusion is common, such as criminal defense firms that do not take traffic tickets.

Answer quickly, too. A missed business-hours call that rang more than 20 seconds can be charged[2], and a callback may not connect: 67% of Americans say they do not answer calls from unknown numbers but will check a voicemail, while 14% generally ignore voicemails altogether[3]. Leave a clear voicemail when you call back, and answer live whenever possible.

How Americans handle unknown callers and voicemail
How Americans handle unknown callers and voicemailBar chart. Don't answer unknown numbers but check voicemail: 67%; Generally ignore any voicemail: 14%.Don't answer unknown numbers but check voicemailDon't answer unknown numbers but check voicemail: 67%67%Generally ignore any voicemailGenerally ignore any voicemail: 14%14%How Americans handle unknown callers and voicemailBar chart. Don't answer unknown numbers but check voicemail: 67%; Generally ignore any voicemail: 14%.Don't answer unknown numbers but checkvoicemailDon't answer unknown numbers but check voicemail: 67%67%Generally ignore any voicemailGenerally ignore any voicemail: 14%14%

Source: Pew Research Center, 2020[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Don't answer unknown numbers but check voicemail67%
Generally ignore any voicemail14%

Phone menus: a filter with a cost

Because callers who hang up in an automated phone menu without pressing a key are not charged[2], some firms put a short menu in front of their Local Services Ads number to screen out robocalls. It can work, but it has a price: real callers in distress also hang up on menus, and a lost injured caller costs far more than a spam charge.

  • If you use a menu, keep it to one short prompt, such as "Press 1 to speak with our intake team."
  • Do not add options for every practice area; route after the call is answered.
  • Test the menu from a mobile phone in a noisy place, as callers will.
  • Compare signed matters before and after adding the menu, not just charges.

Answering is the best lead filter

Many leads that look bad on the invoice were never given a chance. A caller who reaches nobody and does not answer the callback becomes a charge with no outcome. Law firms miss many calls: in Clio's 2024 secret-shopper study, only 40% of US firms answered the phone, and 48% neither answered nor called back[4]. A firm that answers live can sort a wrong-fit caller in a minute, point them to a better resource and rate the lead accurately, which no amount of after-the-fact review can match.

When lead quality drops suddenly

Sometimes the mix of leads changes overnight: more calls from outside your area, more calls about services you removed, or a run of spam. Look for a cause before assuming the system has failed.

  1. Check recent changes to services, service area, hours or budget, by you or an agency.
  2. Check whether the business name, phone number or categories changed on the Business Profile.
  3. Look at the times of the poor leads; a cluster at one hour may point to a routing problem.
  4. Rate every poor lead that week, with consistent reasons.
  5. Contact Google support with dates, examples and your call records if the pattern continues.

Keep a simple change log for the account. When quality shifts, the log usually explains why faster than any report.

Reconcile charges monthly

  1. Export the month's charged leads and credits.
  2. Match each lead to your call log and intake record.
  3. List charged leads with no matching record and investigate them.
  4. Total credits received against leads you rated as poor.
  5. Calculate cost per signed matter after credits, by service.
  6. Decide what to change next month: services, area, hours, budget or coverage.

Example: A fictional immigration firm reviews a month of leads and finds a cluster of calls about traffic tickets and several from a neighboring state where its lawyers are not admitted. Neither type will be credited under the current rules, so it removes a vague services entry and narrows the service area. It also finds three charged leads it has no record of; the calls came during a lunch hour when the phone was not answered. The firm adds lunch-hour coverage, and its cost per signed matter falls the following month.

Frequently asked questions

Can I still dispute a Local Services Ads lead?

Google's current help pages describe automatic reassessment of charged leads, with credits for low-quality leads generally applied within 30 days, plus a lead rating tool. Check your dashboard for the options available to your account.

Will Google credit a lead for a practice area I don't handle?

Google says it no longer supports credits for job-type-not-serviced or geo-not-serviced leads, so remove those services and areas from your settings.

Are repeat calls charged?

Contact from the same phone number or email within 15 days of the last interaction is not charged again as a new lead.

What records should I keep for lead review?

Call times and durations, whether each call was answered, a short intake note, the outcome and the rating you gave.

References

  1. Google Ads Help (2026). About Automated Local Services Ads lead credits (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. Google Local Services Ads Help (2026). How leads work (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. Illinois Supreme Court Commission on Professionalism (2Civility) (2024). Phone Calls Ignored, Emails Unanswered: Fixing the First Impression Problem for Law Firms (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo