Metrics and Firm Finance

Cost per Signed Case: True Acquisition Cost

How to calculate true cost per signed case: which marketing and intake costs to include, how to value staff time, attribution windows and common pitfalls.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing6 min read

On this page
  1. What the number is for
  2. The formula
  3. What to include
  4. Value staff time properly
  5. Measuring intake time without a stopwatch
  6. Worked example
  7. Choose an attribution window
  8. Allocating shared costs
  9. When cost per signed case rises
  10. Pitfalls
  11. Put it next to case value
  12. Who should calculate it
  13. Reporting it
  14. Frequently asked questions
  15. References
Metrics and Firm Finance: Cost per Signed Case: True Acquisition CostArticle coverMETRICS AND FIRM FINANCECost per Signed Case:True Acquisition CostAva for LawyersInsightsMetrics and Firm Finance: Cost per Signed Case: True Acquisition CostArticle coverMETRICS AND FIRM FINANCECost per Signed Case:True Acquisition CostAva for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • Cost per signed case is all acquisition costs for a channel in a period divided by the engagements signed from that channel.
  • Include intake staff time, not only ad spend; benefits made up 30.0% of private employers' compensation costs in June 2026[1].
  • Use an attribution window that matches how long your matters take to sign, and restate when late signings arrive.
  • Calculate it by source and practice area, and always read it next to the value of the cases signed.

What the number is for

Cost per signed case tells you what it really costs to win a new client through a channel. It is the measure that lets a managing partner compare a referral program, search ads, a directory listing and a sponsorship on equal terms. Without it, budget decisions rest on which channel produces the most calls, which is a different and often misleading question.

Most firms understate it. They count media spend and agency fees, and leave out the people who turn inquiries into clients: the intake specialist who answers, the paralegal who chases documents, the lawyer who spends an hour on a free consultation. Those costs vary a lot by channel, because some channels send many unsuitable inquiries that still take time to screen.

The formula

Cost per signed case = (marketing spend + agency and tool fees + intake staff time + attorney consultation time + coverage costs such as an answering service) divided by engagements signed from those inquiries in the period.

Run it by source and by practice area. A blended firm-wide figure averages a cheap referral channel with an expensive advertising channel and tells you nothing about either. It also hides the practice areas where acquisition is unaffordable relative to the fees the matters bring in.

What to include

Cost elements for true acquisition cost
Cost elementInclude?How to measure
Ad and directory spendYesInvoices for the period, by channel
Agency, call tracking and intake software feesYesAllocate by channel where possible, otherwise by share of inquiries
Intake staff timeYesHours spent on intake multiplied by a loaded hourly cost
Attorney consultation timeYes, especially for free consultationsConsultation hours multiplied by an internal hourly cost, not the billing rate
Answering service or after-hours coverageYesInvoices, allocated by share of calls
Referral feesOnly where your state's rules permit themAs paid
General rent and utilitiesUsually noLeave in overhead unless intake has dedicated space

Be consistent more than perfect. If you decide to leave out a cost, leave it out for every channel and every period, and note the decision on the report. The comparison between channels matters more than the absolute figure.

Value staff time properly

Staff time is usually the largest hidden cost. Start with pay, then add benefits. US receptionists earned a median of $18.27 an hour in May 2025[2], and paralegals and legal assistants a median of $62,890 a year[3]. Across private industry, employers paid an average of $46.89 per hour worked in total compensation in June 2026, and benefits made up 30.0% of that cost[1].

Private industry employer compensation costs per hour worked, June 2026
Private industry employer compensation costs per hour worked, June 2026Stacked bar chart. Wages and salaries: 70%; Benefits: 30%.Wages and salaries: 70% (70%)Benefits: 30% (30%)Private industry employer compensation costs per hour worked, June 2026Stacked bar chart. Wages and salaries: 70%; Benefits: 30%.Wages and salaries: 70% (70%)Benefits: 30% (30%)
  • Wages and salaries 70%
  • Benefits 30%

Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2026[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Wages and salaries70%
Benefits30%

A simple loaded-cost rule follows from that mix: divide an hourly wage by 0.70 to approximate the hourly cost including benefits. Replace it with your own payroll figures when you can, because benefits vary widely between firms. For attorney time, use an internal cost based on compensation, not the billing rate. The billing rate measures what the time could earn, which belongs in a different calculation.

Measuring intake time without a stopwatch

Few firms track intake hours by channel, so estimate them from a sample. For two weeks, have intake staff note the minutes spent on each new inquiry, including screening, callbacks, conflict checks and booking, and tag each with its source. Average the minutes per inquiry by source, then multiply by the number of inquiries in the period.

The sample often surprises people. Channels that generate many unsuitable inquiries consume screening time even when they produce few clients, and that time never appears on any invoice. Repeat the sample once a year, or after any major change to intake.

Worked example

Example: a fictional personal injury firm reviews one quarter of search-ad leads.

Example cost per signed case for one channel
Input (Example)Amount
Search ad spend$18,000
Agency and call tracking fees$3,000
Intake staff: 90 hours at $27 loaded$2,430
Attorney consultations: 30 hours at $90 internal cost$2,700
Total acquisition cost$26,130
Engagements signed from search ads12
Cost per signed case$2,178

Example: counting ad spend alone would have shown $1,500 per signed case. Including people and tools raises it by about 45%, which changes how the channel compares with referrals, where intake and consultation time are the main costs. The firm does not drop the channel; it asks whether better ad targeting could cut the screening time spent on unsuitable inquiries.

Choose an attribution window

Some matters sign within a day; others take months. Pick a window that fits the practice: count engagements signed within a set number of days of the first inquiry, and attribute each to the source recorded at first contact. When late signings arrive, restate the earlier period, so channels with slow conversion are not unfairly penalized.

  • Short-cycle matters, such as many criminal defense and traffic cases: about 30 days.
  • Medium-cycle matters, such as family, employment and estate planning: 60 to 90 days.
  • Long-cycle matters, such as complex injury or business disputes: 90 days or more, reviewed quarterly.

Allocating shared costs

Some costs serve every channel at once: the intake software, the phone system, the website, the answering service. Allocate them in proportion to something you can count, usually the share of inquiries each channel produced in the period. If search ads produced half of all inquiries, they carry half of the shared intake software cost. Keep the allocation method the same from period to period, and resist the temptation to load shared costs onto the channel you already dislike.

Website costs are a judgment call. If the website mainly supports advertising landing pages, allocate it like other shared tools. If it is mostly where referred clients check you out before calling, treat it as general overhead and leave it out. Either choice is defensible as long as it is written down and applied consistently.

When cost per signed case rises

  1. Check whether inquiries fell or signings fell; the fix is different.
  2. Look at the qualification rate: a rising share of unsuitable inquiries points to targeting.
  3. Look at the booking and show rates: a fall points to intake response or reminders.
  4. Look at the signing rate: a fall points to the consultation, pricing or competition.
  5. Check for one-off costs, such as a new agency setup fee, that distort a single period.

Pitfalls

  1. Using billing rates for attorney time, which inflates acquisition cost and mixes it with lost revenue.
  2. Counting cases referred by past clients against this quarter's advertising spend.
  3. Ignoring declined and conflicted inquiries, which still consumed intake time.
  4. Abandoning the measure when one large case makes a channel look cheap; track case value separately.
  5. Comparing with other firms' figures without knowing what they included.
  6. Trying to cut acquisition cost by buying reviews or rewarding them; the FTC's 2024 rule bans buying fake reviews and conditioning incentives on writing reviews[4].

Put it next to case value

Cost per signed case only means something next to what a signed case is worth. Track the average fees collected per matter by source over the following year. A channel with a higher acquisition cost may still be the best investment if it brings larger or more profitable matters. Dividing average fees collected by cost per signed case gives a simple return multiple you can compare across channels.

Example: if the fictional injury firm's search-ad cases go on to collect an average of $12,000 in fees, the channel returns about five and a half times its acquisition cost. If referral cases collect a similar amount at a fraction of the acquisition cost, the firm should invest in its referral relationships before adding ad spend.

Who should calculate it

Give the calculation to one person, usually the office manager or whoever owns the marketing budget, and have the managing partner review it. The calculator needs access to marketing invoices, the intake log with sources, payroll figures and the list of signed engagements. Keep a short method note with the spreadsheet: which costs are included, how shared costs are allocated, which loaded rates are used and what attribution window applies. When the person changes, the method should not.

Reporting it

Report cost per signed case monthly for high-volume channels and quarterly for slower ones, next to inquiries, qualified inquiries and signed cases, so readers can see why it moved. See cost per lead versus cost per signed case for how the two measures differ, intake conversion rate for the funnel underneath, and the cost of a missed call for what unanswered inquiries add. It belongs in the core KPI set every managing partner should track.

Frequently asked questions

What is cost per signed case?

The total cost of attracting and converting new clients through a channel in a period, divided by the number of engagements signed from that channel.

Should attorney consultation time be included?

Yes, especially for free consultations. Use an internal hourly cost based on compensation rather than the billing rate.

How is this different from cost per lead?

Cost per lead divides spend by inquiries. Cost per signed case divides all acquisition costs by the clients who actually signed, so it reflects lead quality and intake performance.

How often should we calculate it?

Monthly for high-volume channels and quarterly for slower ones, restating earlier periods when late signings arrive.

References

  1. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Employer Costs for Employee Compensation - June 2026 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Receptionists: Occupational Outlook Handbook (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Paralegals and Legal Assistants: Occupational Outlook Handbook (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. Federal Trade Commission (2024). Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo