Key takeaways
- There are four workable models: free, paid, paid and credited toward the retainer, and a refundable deposit to hold the slot.
- A fee filters out some prospects you may want: low-income Americans seek legal help for 25% of serious problems versus 32% for higher-income Americans[1].
- Money paid before the consultation is unearned until it happens; check your state's trust accounting rules before taking it.
- Write the policy in plain language, state it before booking and apply it the same way to everyone.
Why the policy matters more than the amount
Firms argue about whether to charge for consultations as if the amount were the main decision. In practice, how the policy works matters more: when the fee is paid, whether it is credited if the prospect hires the firm, what happens if they cancel, and how staff explain it on the phone. A modest fee that is poorly explained loses more prospects than a higher one that is clear, fair and stated up front.
The right policy also depends on practice area. A firm handling contingency injury claims has different economics from a firm doing flat-fee estate planning or hourly business litigation. Decide per practice area, not firm-wide, if your matters differ that much.
Four policy models
| Model | How it works | Often used for | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free consultation | No charge for the first meeting, usually time-limited | Contingency matters, high-volume consumer practices | Attracts advice-seekers; needs strict time limits and screening |
| Paid, not credited | Fixed fee for the meeting, kept whatever happens | Complex advice where the consultation itself delivers value | Prospects may feel charged for a sales meeting |
| Paid and credited | Fee is applied to the retainer if the prospect hires the firm within a set period | Family law, business, estate planning | Credit terms must be clear and tracked |
| Refundable deposit | Amount taken to hold a slot, returned or credited after the meeting | Firms with high no-show rates | Forfeiture rules raise ethics questions; get guidance first |
Who a fee filters out
Any fee screens out some people. That is partly the point: a fee reduces no-shows and advice-shopping. But it can also screen out the clients a firm most wants to reach, particularly in consumer practices. Low-income Americans seek legal help for only about 1 in 4 of the civil legal problems that substantially affect them[2], and higher-income Americans seek help for 32% of such problems compared with 25% for low-income Americans[1].
Source: Legal Services Corporation, 2022[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Higher-income Americans | 32% |
| Low-income Americans | 25% |
Cost is a stated reason for much of that gap: 46% of low-income Americans who did not seek help for a problem cited cost concerns[3]. If your practice serves consumers with limited budgets, a free or credited consultation removes one barrier at the first step. If your practice serves businesses with complex questions, a paid consultation can signal that the meeting itself delivers advice worth paying for.
What a consultation costs the firm
Free is never free for the firm. The median US lawyer earned $76.76 an hour in May 2025[4], before the staff time spent booking, confirming and preparing the meeting. That cost is worth paying when consultations convert at a healthy rate and lead to engagements of meaningful size. It is harder to justify when a large share of consultations are with people who wanted free advice and never intended to hire anyone.
Example: a firm holds 20 free 45-minute consultations a week. If half of them are with prospects who were never likely to hire, the firm spends over seven attorney hours a week on meetings that cannot convert. Better screening at intake may solve that without a fee. If screening is already tight, a credited fee may be the better tool, because it filters advice-seekers while costing hiring clients nothing.
Making a free consultation work
If you keep consultations free, give them a shape that protects attorney time. Set a firm time limit and say it at booking. Screen at intake for practice area, jurisdiction, conflicts and whether the caller wants representation or a quick answer. Define what the free meeting includes: a review of the situation, an explanation of options and an explanation of fees, but not document drafting or a detailed written opinion. Prospects who want more can book a paid advice session or engage the firm.
Free consultations also benefit from a short pre-meeting questionnaire. A prospect who has taken ten minutes to describe their situation and upload a document is more committed than one who booked with a single click, and the attorney walks in better prepared.
Handling the money correctly
The moment a firm takes money before the consultation, trust accounting rules come into play. Payment received before a service is delivered is generally unearned, and most states require unearned fees to be held in a client trust account until they are earned. Rules differ by state, so check yours before you set up online payment for consultations.
- Consultation fee paid in advance: treat it as unearned until the consultation takes place, then move it to the operating account according to your state's rules.
- Credit toward the retainer: record the credit in the engagement letter and the billing system so it is not missed or applied twice.
- Deposit to hold a slot: be careful with forfeiture. Keeping money because a prospect did not attend can look like a nonrefundable fee for services never provided; get ethics guidance before adopting it.
- Refunds: if the firm cancels, if a conflict is found after payment or if the attorney cannot help with the matter, refund promptly and in full.
- Billing honesty: California's State Bar guidance reminds lawyers that hourly billing must reflect time actually spent[5]; the same discipline applies to what a consultation fee covers.
Decision criteria for choosing a model
- How do clients in this practice area usually pay: contingency, flat fee or hourly?
- How often do booked prospects fail to attend, and is that a problem a reminder or confirmation call would fix?
- What share of consultations come from people seeking free advice rather than representation?
- How well does intake screening work before a consultation is booked?
- What do competing firms in your market offer, and does a fee make you look more or less credible to your clients?
- Can your billing and trust accounting handle advance payments correctly?
If no-shows are the main problem, fix reminders and confirmations before introducing a fee. If advice-seekers are the main problem, tighten screening first. A fee is a blunt instrument for problems that have sharper tools.
How to explain the policy
Staff should explain the policy the same way every time, before the booking is confirmed. Write the wording down and keep it short.
- Credited fee: βThe consultation is a one-hour meeting with the attorney. There's a fee for it, and if you decide to hire us within 30 days, the full amount is credited toward your first invoice.β
- Free consultation: βThe first meeting is free and lasts up to 30 minutes. The attorney will look at your situation, explain your options and tell you how fees would work if you go ahead.β
- Paid consultation: βThe consultation fee covers an hour of the attorney's time and advice on your situation. You'll leave with a clear view of your options whether or not you hire us.β
- Refunds: βIf we have to cancel, or if we find we can't help with your matter, we refund the fee in full.β
Example policy text
Example: Consultations last up to 60 minutes and carry a fixed fee, paid when you book. If you engage the firm within 30 days of your consultation, the full fee is credited toward your first invoice. If you need to reschedule, contact us at least 24 hours in advance and we will move your appointment at no cost. If the firm cancels, or we cannot assist with your matter after reviewing it, we refund the fee in full.
Adapt the wording to your own state's rules and have an attorney approve it. Publish it on the booking page, repeat it in the confirmation email and make sure every staff member gives the same answer when asked.
Review the policy after six months
Whatever model you choose, set a date to review it. Compare attendance, conversion to signed engagements and the share of consultations that were advice-only before and after the change. Ask intake staff which questions about the policy come up most often on calls; repeated confusion means the wording needs work. If a fee has reduced no-shows but also reduced bookings from the clients you most want, consider switching to a credited model or tightening screening instead. Treat the policy as an operating decision you can adjust, not a statement of the firm's worth.
Frequently asked questions
Should a law firm charge for consultations?
It depends on practice area and market. Contingency and consumer practices often offer free consultations, while business and complex advisory work more often charge. A fee credited toward the retainer is a common middle ground.
Does a prepaid consultation fee have to go into a trust account?
In many states, money paid for services not yet delivered is unearned and must be held in trust until earned. Check your state's trust accounting rules before taking payment at booking.
Can I keep a deposit if a prospect doesn't show up?
Be cautious. Keeping money for services never provided can be treated like a nonrefundable fee, which many states restrict. Seek ethics guidance before adopting forfeiture terms.
How long should a consultation fee credit last?
Many firms use 30 to 60 days. Choose a period that matches how long prospects in your practice area typically take to decide, and state it in writing.
References
Legal Services Corporation (2022). The Justice Gap Report: Executive Summary (opens in a new tab) β
Legal Services Corporation (2022). The Justice Gap Report: Executive Summary (opens in a new tab) β
Legal Services Corporation (2022). The Justice Gap Report: Executive Summary (opens in a new tab) β
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Lawyers: Occupational Outlook Handbook (opens in a new tab) β
The State Bar of California, Standing Committee on Professional Responsibility and Conduct (2026). Practical Guidance for the Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence in the Practice of Law (opens in a new tab) β