Legal Tech and AI

Billing for AI-Assisted Work Under Opinion 512

What ABA Formal Opinion 512 says about billing AI-assisted work: hourly time, flat fees, tool costs as overhead or expenses, and time spent learning tools.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. What Opinion 512 covers
  2. Five billing scenarios and what the opinion says
  3. Learning time is not billable, with one exception
  4. Time entries that hold up
  5. Overhead or expense: a decision path
  6. Engagement letter language
  7. Flat fees: run the reasonableness test
  8. Answering client questions about AI on the bill
  9. A pre-bill checklist for AI-assisted entries
  10. Where AI use shows up first
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References
Legal Tech and AI: Billing for AI-Assisted Work Under Opinion 512Article coverLEGAL TECH AND AIBilling for AI-AssistedWork Under Opinion 512Ava for LawyersInsightsLegal Tech and AI: Billing for AI-Assisted Work Under Opinion 512Article coverLEGAL TECH AND AIBilling forAI-Assisted WorkUnder Opinion 512Ava for Lawyers

Key takeaways

  • Hourly bills must reflect actual time, including time spent preparing inputs and reviewing AI output, never time saved[1].
  • A flat fee that was reasonable before AI may become unreasonable if the work now takes far less effort[1].
  • Tools that work like general office equipment are overhead; a per-use third-party AI service for one client can be billed as an expense at actual cost.
  • Explain the basis of any AI-related charge before charging it, preferably in writing[2].

What Opinion 512 covers

The ABA Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility issued Formal Opinion 512 on generative AI tools on July 29, 2024. It addresses competence, confidentiality, communication, supervision, meritorious claims, candor to the tribunal and fees. The fees section applies Model Rule 1.5, which requires fees and expenses to be reasonable, and draws heavily on the committee's older Formal Opinion 93-379 on billing practices[1].

Several states have published similar guidance. California's bar says hourly billing must reflect time actually spent, recognizing that generative AI may reduce the time required, and suggests flat fees for more predictable work[3]. Florida Bar Opinion 24-1 says AI use does not permit improper billing practices such as double-billing[4]. Texas addressed lawyers' use of generative AI in Opinion 705 in February 2025[5]. If you practice in one of those states, read the state guidance alongside the ABA opinion, because your disciplinary authority applies its own rules.

Five billing scenarios and what the opinion says

The opinion works through billing by example. The table summarizes the main scenarios and a practical rule for each[1].

Opinion 512 billing scenarios
ScenarioWhat Opinion 512 saysPractical rule
Hourly matter where AI drafts a pleadingBill the time spent inputting information and reviewing the draft; the opinion's example is fifteen minutes of input plus review timeRecord input and review time as separate narrative lines
Hourly matter where AI makes you fasterYou may not bill more hours than you actually spent, even if you were particularly efficientNever bill estimated time saved on an hourly matter
Flat-fee matterIf AI lets you finish much more quickly, charging the same flat fee may be unreasonableReview flat fees for AI-heavy matter types at least yearly
Tool built into everyday softwareA tool that works like equipping a practice, such as grammar checking in a word processor, is overheadDo not pass the cost to clients without advance disclosure
Per-use third-party service for one clientOrdinarily reasonable to bill the actual out-of-pocket cost as an expenseBill at cost, pass on discounts and add no surcharge without agreement

Learning time is not billable, with one exception

Opinion 512 reminds lawyers that they may not charge clients for time made necessary by their own inexperience. A lawyer therefore may not bill a client to learn an AI tool the lawyer will use regularly for clients, because keeping up with the tools of practice is part of maintaining competence. The exception: if a client explicitly asks for a specific AI tool and the lawyer does not know how to use it, it may be appropriate to bill the time spent learning it. Before doing so, the lawyer and client should agree the billing terms and preferably put them in writing[1].

In practice, keep firm-wide AI training on a non-billable code. If a client's procurement team insists on a particular platform, note the request in the engagement file, agree how setup and learning time will be handled, and send a short confirming email before any of that time is recorded.

Time entries that hold up

Example entries for a fictional employment matter billed hourly:

  • Example: "0.3 Prepare instructions and source documents for first draft of position statement in AI drafting tool."
  • Example: "1.1 Review and revise AI-generated draft position statement; verify all dates, quotations and cited authorities against the record."
  • Example: "0.4 Review AI summary of personnel file; spot-check summary against source documents."
  • Example to avoid: "2.5 Draft position statement", when most of the drafting was the tool's processing rather than your work.

Narratives that separate preparation from review show the client, and anyone auditing the bill, that time reflects work actually done. Florida's warning about double-billing matters when the same AI output is reused across clients: bill each client only for the time spent on that client's matter[4]. If you adapt a template that took hours to build for one client, the next client pays for the adaptation, not the original build.

Overhead or expense: a decision path

  1. Ask what the tool is like

    If it works like general practice equipment, such as word processing, email or a research subscription used across clients, treat it as overhead.

  2. Ask who it serves

    If the cost arises from work for one client, such as a per-document review fee for that client's contracts, it may be billable as an expense.

  3. Check the agreement

    Without a contrary disclosure in advance, do not bill overhead to clients. For expenses, bill the actual cost unless the client agreed otherwise.

  4. For in-house tools, agree rates in advance

    A firm that built a distinctive AI tool may agree specific rates with the client. Without an agreement, charge no more than direct cost plus a reasonable allocation of directly related expenses, and make sure the charge does not duplicate other charges[1].

  5. Disclose before charging

    Rule 1.5(b) requires the basis or rate of fees and expenses to be communicated, preferably in writing, before or within a reasonable time after the representation starts, and any changes must be communicated too[2].

Engagement letter language

Opinion 512 says that before charging a client for the use of AI tools or services, the lawyer must explain the basis for the charge, preferably in writing[1]. Example clause for a fictional firm's engagement letter:

Example: "The firm may use software tools, including generative AI, to assist with drafting, review and research. Lawyers and staff review all such work. Hourly time is billed only for time actually spent, including time to prepare inputs and review results. General software costs are part of our overhead. If your matter requires a specialized third-party AI service billed per use, we will tell you in advance and bill the actual cost as an expense."

Keep the confidentiality conversation separate. Billing language is not informed consent to put client information into a tool. The opinion says general, boilerplate provisions in engagement letters are not enough to obtain informed consent where it is required, so that conversation needs its own explanation of the specific tool and risks.

Flat fees: run the reasonableness test

Rule 1.5(a) lists factors for judging whether a fee is reasonable, including the time and labor required, the skill needed, the fee customarily charged locally, the results obtained and whether the fee is fixed or contingent[2]. For matter types where AI now does much of the first-draft work, compare your flat fee with recent effort data. Where the fee still reflects skill, risk and outcome, it may remain reasonable. Where it was set mainly on drafting hours that have shrunk, revisit it.

  • Pull the hours logged on recent matters of the type, before and after AI adoption.
  • Note what drove the fee: hours, risk, expertise or speed.
  • Adjust the fee, or write a short note explaining why it remains reasonable.
  • Record the review date in the matter-type file and set the next one.

Answering client questions about AI on the bill

Clients increasingly ask how AI affects what they pay. Prepare short, accurate answers so lawyers do not improvise them on the phone:

  • "Are you charging me for the AI?" Explain whether the tool is overhead or a disclosed per-use expense, and point to the engagement letter.
  • "Shouldn't this be cheaper now?" On hourly matters, you bill actual time, so efficiency already shows up as fewer hours. On flat fees, explain what the fee reflects beyond drafting time, or adjust it.
  • "Who checked this?" Name the lawyer who reviewed the work and describe the checks in general terms.
  • "Did my information go into a public tool?" Answer precisely for the tool used. If you cannot answer confidently, find out before replying.

A pre-bill checklist for AI-assisted entries

  1. Every AI-assisted entry describes the lawyer's own work: preparing inputs, reviewing, revising, verifying.
  2. No entry bills the tool's processing time as if a person did the work.
  3. Reused output is billed only for the time spent adapting it to this client.
  4. Any AI expense matches the vendor invoice and the advance disclosure.
  5. No learning time for regularly used tools appears on the bill.

Where AI use shows up first

Among legal professionals who use generative AI, the top uses are document review, legal research and document summarization[6]. Those tasks are often billed by the hour, so they are where billing discipline matters most and where clients are most likely to ask questions.

Top uses of generative AI among legal professionals who use it, 2025
Top uses of generative AI among legal professionals who use it, 2025Bar chart. Document review: 74%; Legal research: 73%; Document summarization: 72%.Document reviewDocument review: 74%74%Legal researchLegal research: 73%73%Document summarizationDocument summarization: 72%72%Top uses of generative AI among legal professionals who use it, 2025Bar chart. Document review: 74%; Legal research: 73%; Document summarization: 72%.Document reviewDocument review: 74%74%Legal researchLegal research: 73%73%Document summarizationDocument summarization: 72%72%

Source: Thomson Reuters Institute, 2025[6]

Show the data
ItemValue
Document review74%
Legal research73%
Document summarization72%

Related reading: ABA Formal Opinion 512 on generative AI covers the rest of the opinion, training staff to work alongside AI tools covers the supervision side, and automating intake workflows without AI shows how much can be streamlined with simple rules before any billing questions arise.

Frequently asked questions

Can I bill for time saved by AI?

Not on an hourly matter. Opinion 512 says lawyers billing hourly must bill actual time, which includes preparing inputs and reviewing output, but not the time they would have spent without the tool.

Can I charge clients for an AI subscription?

Generally not if the tool works like general office equipment; that is overhead. A per-use third-party service for one client's matter can usually be billed as an expense at actual cost.

Do flat fees solve the problem?

They can suit predictable work, but the fee must still be reasonable. If AI makes the work much quicker, the same flat fee may become unreasonable.

Can I bill a client for learning an AI tool?

Not for tools you will use regularly. Only if the client explicitly asks for a specific tool you do not know, and you agree the billing terms in advance.

References

  1. American Bar Association, Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility (2024). Formal Opinion 512: Generative Artificial Intelligence Tools (archived copy) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. American Bar Association (2025). Rule 1.5: Fees, ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct (archived copy) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. The State Bar of California, Standing Committee on Professional Responsibility and Conduct (2026). Practical Guidance for the Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence in the Practice of Law (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. The Florida Bar (2024). Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  5. Texas Center for Legal Ethics (Professional Ethics Committee for the State Bar of Texas) (2025). Opinion 705 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  6. Thomson Reuters Institute (2025). 2025 GenAI report: Executive summary for legal professionals (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo