Key takeaways
- An AI receptionist answers and takes a message; an SI Employee completes defined intake work, such as approved questions, routing and booking.
- More autonomy means more supervision: California's State Bar ties lawyer diligence to an AI system's access and autonomy[1].
- Both must stay inside the rules for nonlawyer intake: identify nonlawyer status, ask factual questions only, give no legal advice[2].
- When a lawyer answers intake calls, the hour costs about four times a receptionist's median pay[3][4].
Two labels for two different jobs
Vendors use "AI receptionist" and "SI Employee" loosely, and some use both for the same product. The useful distinction is about the work, not the label. An AI receptionist answers the phone, says who you are, takes a name, a number and a reason for calling, and passes the message on. An SI Employee is configured to complete a defined piece of work: ask your approved intake questions for the practice area, collect the names your conflict check needs, follow your escalation rules for urgent calls, book or request a consultation, and hand staff a structured record of what happened.
Neither is a lawyer, and neither should behave like one. The difference is how much of the intake process is finished by the time a person in your firm picks it up.
Task by task
| Task | AI receptionist | SI Employee |
|---|---|---|
| Greeting and disclosure | Greets callers and says it is an automated assistant | Same, with firm-approved wording |
| New inquiry | Takes name, number and a short reason | Asks the firm's approved questions for that practice area |
| Matters you do not take | Takes a message regardless | Recognizes excluded matters and gives approved wording or referral details |
| Conflict check information | Rarely collected | Collects the names the firm specifies; never decides a conflict |
| Urgent calls | Message for later | Follows a written escalation tree with a tested fallback |
| Consultations | Callback request | Books into a tested calendar or records a request staff confirm |
| Hand-off | A short message | A structured summary with recording and transcript, plus a notification |
Answering versus finishing the work
The test is what lands on your desk the next morning. With a basic receptionist service, it is a list of names and numbers, and the real intake starts when someone calls back. With an SI Employee configured well, much of the first intake call has already happened: the caller has answered the firm's standard questions, urgent matters were routed overnight, and a consultation is booked or requested. Staff still review every record, but they start from a structured summary instead of a voicemail.
That only works if the firm does the configuration properly. The intake questions, excluded matters, escalation contacts and booking rules all have to be written down, approved by a lawyer and tested before callers hear them.
More autonomy means more supervision
Professional guidance is starting to draw this line explicitly. California's State Bar names autonomously facilitating client intake as an example of agentic AI and says lawyer diligence and supervision must correspond to the system's level of access and autonomy[1]. A system that only takes messages needs light oversight. A system that asks intake questions, routes calls and books consultations needs written scripts, regular review of call records and a named lawyer responsible for its behavior.
The rules that bound both
- Identify nonlawyer status. Florida Ethics Opinion 88-6, which Florida Bar Opinion 24-1 calls especially useful for intake chatbots, says nonlawyers conducting an initial intake interview must identify their nonlawyer status, limit questions to factual information, give no legal advice and refer legal questions to the lawyer[2].
- Screen for existing representation. Opinion 24-1 suggests screening questions that limit an intake chatbot's communications if the person is already represented by another lawyer[5].
- Watch for accidental relationships. Opinion 24-1 warns that intake chatbots risk creating a prospective-client or even lawyer-client relationship without the lawyer's knowledge[6].
- Disclose that it is AI, in plain words, at the start of the call.
What it costs when lawyers do intake themselves
In many small firms, the lawyer is the intake department. The median hourly pay for US lawyers was $76.76 in May 2025, against $18.27 for receptionists[4][3]. Every hour a lawyer spends asking routine intake questions is an hour of the firm's most expensive time spent on work a well-supervised system or staff member could do, leaving the lawyer to make the decisions only a lawyer can make: whether to take the matter and on what terms.
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2025[4]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Receptionists | $18.27 |
| Lawyers | $76.76 |
Staffing is moving the same way
Support roles are shrinking. The Bureau of Labor Statistics projects legal secretary and administrative assistant employment to fall 5% from 2025 to 2035[7], and it expects advances in technology to limit demand for paralegals and legal assistants[8]. For small firms, that means fewer people to answer phones and do first-stage intake, and more pressure to decide which parts of the work a system can complete reliably.
How to tell what you are being sold
- Ask the vendor to call the demo line as a new client in your main practice area. Does it ask your questions or generic ones?
- Call as someone with a matter you do not handle. What does it say?
- Call as an urgent caller after hours. Who is contacted, in what order, and what happens if nobody answers?
- Ask to book a consultation. Does it book into a real calendar, or take a request?
- Ask what you receive after the call: a message, or a summary with recording and transcript?
- Ask who approves the script and how changes are tested before going live.
If the answers to the first four questions are "it takes a message", you are looking at a receptionist service, whatever the brochure calls it.
Where Ava fits
Ava is an SI Employee made for law firms: it follows the intake questions your firm approves for each practice area, collects the names you need for your own conflict check, routes urgent calls through your escalation tree with a tested fallback, and books into a tested consultation calendar or takes a request your team confirms, with a summary, recording and transcript for staff to review. It does not give legal advice or promise representation, and the firm stays in charge of the script.
Example: an estate planning firm's Monday morning
Example (fictional): a two-lawyer estate planning firm compares two weekends. With a message-taking service, Monday starts with nine messages, and the paralegal spends the morning calling people back to ask the same questions, reaching five. With an SI Employee configured on the firm's approved questions, Monday starts with nine structured summaries: six consultation requests with the family details the firm needs, two callers whose matters the firm does not handle and who received the approved referral wording, and one existing client to call back. The paralegal confirms the requests and runs conflict checks before lunch.
What configuration involves
Write the intake questions
For each practice area, list the questions staff ask on a first call, in order, and remove any that call for legal judgment.
List excluded matters
Write the matters the firm does not take and the wording, plus any referral details, the system should give.
Define urgent
Write what counts as urgent for each practice area and who is contacted, in what order, with a fallback.
Set booking rules
Decide which consultations can be booked directly, which need staff confirmation and how far ahead.
Approve and test
A lawyer approves the final script, then staff test it with fictional calls before it goes live.
Mistakes firms make when choosing
- Buying on the label rather than testing what the system actually does on a call.
- Skipping the configuration work and expecting the system to know the firm's practice areas.
- Letting the system book consultations before the calendar has been connected and tested.
- Not reading the call records for the first month.
- Forgetting to update the script when the firm stops taking a matter type.
Most of these come from treating the purchase as a phone upgrade rather than a staffing decision. Treat it as hiring: write the job description, train to it, supervise closely at first and review performance on a schedule.
Decision criteria
- If you only need someone to answer and take messages, a receptionist service may be enough.
- If staff spend hours each week repeating the same intake questions, the SI Employee model is worth testing.
- Either way, require plain AI disclosure, no legal advice, and a named lawyer who approves the script.
- Budget time for configuration and weekly review in the first month.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between an AI receptionist and an SI Employee?
A receptionist answers and takes a message. An SI Employee completes defined intake work, such as approved questions, urgent routing and booking, and hands staff a structured record.
Does an SI Employee give legal advice?
It should not. Intake by nonlawyers should be limited to factual questions, with legal questions referred to a lawyer[2].
Does more capable AI need more supervision?
Yes. California's guidance says supervision must correspond to an AI system's level of access and autonomy[1].
How do I test what a vendor really offers?
Call the demo as a new client, an excluded matter and an urgent after-hours caller, then look at what you receive afterwards.
References
The State Bar of California, Standing Committee on Professional Responsibility and Conduct (2026). Practical Guidance for the Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence in the Practice of Law (opens in a new tab) โ
The Florida Bar (2024). Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1 (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Receptionists: Occupational Outlook Handbook (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Lawyers: Occupational Outlook Handbook (opens in a new tab) โ
The Florida Bar (2024). Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1 (opens in a new tab) โ
The Florida Bar (2024). Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 24-1 (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Secretaries and Administrative Assistants: Occupational Outlook Handbook (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Paralegals and Legal Assistants: Occupational Outlook Handbook (opens in a new tab) โ